Valle d'Aosta wants to cull wolves, but won't be able to

Valle d'Aosta wants to cull wolves, but won't be able to

Environment · ·

The region will ask Ispra for authorisation for a controlled culling plan for the wolves present in Valle d'Aosta.

Across the whole of Valle d'Aosta there are, according to estimates, just 20–25 wolves, with a density of 0.006 individuals per square kilometre, yet for the region that is too many, and it would like to cull some of them. Valle d'Aosta has in fact decided to ask Ispra, the Istituto superiore per la protezione e la ricerca ambientale, for authorisation for a culling plan to contain the wolf population.

To protect farmers, or for their votes?

According to Alessandro Nogara, Valle d'Aosta's regional councillor for Agriculture and Natural Resources, the controlled culling of wolves would be nothing less than "the only viable course of action." The justification is always the same — killing predators would be a measure to limit damage to farmers — but, as is often the case, it could simply be a political initiative aimed at winning the votes of certain categories involved.

Comune di La Thuile
"A dedicated committee is working on the analysis of the data and documentation; I expect to reach a result within a couple of months," said Alessandro Nogara, Valle d'Aosta's regional councillor for Agriculture and Natural Resources © Ingimage

Derogation culls no longer permitted

Valle d'Aosta would invoke the Ministry of the Environment's Piano di conservazione del lupo, which provided for, among the various countermeasures to mitigate the conflict between humans and wolves, the culling of a number of wolves not exceeding 5 per cent of the total population in Italy. The controversial 5 per cent cap has, however, been removed, and in any case the plan provides for culling as a last resort, only after a series of countermeasures — twenty-one to be precise — have first been taken to reduce the impact of wolves, which the region would need to demonstrate it has carried out. Finally, Ispra cannot authorise legislative derogations or permit the culling of a species protected by national and European regulations.

Culling wolves would serve no purpose

The culling of wolves — which will not happen in any case, the proposal being without foundation — would be of no use, as explained by the Valle d'Aosta branch of Legambiente. "The measure would be pointless and counterproductive: it is well known that wolves' wide-ranging nomadic behaviour would quickly bring other individuals back to territories where culling had taken place. If improperly adopted, the measure risks creating imbalances and undermining the other steps that are truly useful for correctly managing the phenomenon."