Ukraine, the battle of Mariupol and the propaganda machine

Ukraine, the battle of Mariupol and the propaganda machine

Rights · ·

The battle of Mariupol, in Ukraine, is the epicentre of the war and of a wealth of conflicting, hard-to-verify reports.

"Mariupol has been liberated." "No, there is no evidence that the city has been totally lost." The propaganda machine in the war in Ukraine is running at full capacity. The first statement was made by Russian president Vladimir Putin; the second by his American counterpart Joe Biden. Understanding which version is true is particularly complex.

The Ukrainian commander's video: "Perhaps these are our final hours"

On Wednesday 20 April a video was released in which Ukrainian commander Serhiy Volyna addressed the international community in dramatic terms: "We may be living our final days, if not our final hours." Yet the Kyiv authorities have not confirmed any capitulation.

Serhiy Volyna of the 36th Marines in Azovstal, Mariupol. The latest of a series@of desperate appeals from the defenders in the past 24 hours

What is known is that for more than two months the city — a strategic port where around 500,000 people once lived — has in some way represented the epicentre of the war. For the Kremlin, it is also a crucial objective from a propaganda standpoint: Putin is intent on exploiting its capture in order to claim an important battlefield victory.

The civilian population in dire conditions in Mariupol

To that end, the urban centre has been heavily bombarded for many weeks, and has also been the scene of fierce clashes between the armies. The worst consequences have been borne by the civilian population, which on the one hand has struggled to flee due to the lack of humanitarian corridors. On the other, it is forced to live not only in the midst of the battle but also without water, electricity, food or medicine.

Over time, Russian forces have seized neighbourhoods and streets, but a pocket of fierce resistance has concentrated in the vast Azovstal steelworks, in whose underground levels hundreds of Ukrainian civilians and soldiers are said to have taken shelter. The site was first bombarded, then besieged by Vladimir Putin's forces.

Why the battle is strategic

What makes the capture of Mariupol — and equally its defence — so crucial is above all the city's geographical position and the economic weight of its port. A significant share of Ukraine's grain exports reaches the rest of the world through this terminal, along with the port of Odessa. Moreover, controlling the city would allow Russia to link the Donbas to the south of the country, which is already under occupation.

A Mariupol e in altre città dell'Ucraina la popolazione è rimasta senza acqua
In Mariupol and other Ukrainian cities the population has been left without water © Chris McGrath/Getty Images

Not to mention that the capture of Mariupol could alter the Kremlin's military plans, which would then have several thousand additional soldiers available to deploy elsewhere. Finally, Putin could make political capital out of the city's symbolic value, given that it is the birthplace of the Azov Battalion, whose ranks include openly neo-Nazi servicemen. Moscow has always relied on the need to "denazify" Ukraine to justify its invasion.

Ukraine's accusations against the International Red Cross

Propaganda, once again. Exactly as appears highly likely in the case of the recent, extremely serious accusations levelled by Kyiv against the International Red Cross. According to Lyudmyla Denisova, the Ukrainian Parliament's human rights commissioner, the humanitarian organisation had allegedly made itself "complicit in the deportation" of civilians to Russia.

L'esercito russo sembra essere a un passo dalla conquista della città di Mariupol, a sud est del paese, mentre la capitale Kiev, per il momento, resiste all'assedio
The Russian army appears to be on the verge of capturing the city of Mariupol, in the south-east of the country © Chris McGrath/Getty Images

"For a month I have been trying to meet the president of the Red Cross to discuss the matter with him, after he himself stated that he wished to open an office in Rostov, inviting Ukrainians to be received on the territory of the aggressor state," she said. For its part, the Red Cross firmly rejected "these false accusations", stating that "no forced evacuations have ever taken place." It also recalled having "facilitated the voluntary and safe passage of civilians and wounded people" from Mariupol "to other cities in Ukraine."

As for the office in Rostov, the international organisation confirmed that it had "explored the possibility of opening an office in order to alleviate the suffering of people affected by the conflict." It also recalled that "building and maintaining dialogue between the parties is essential to providing support to civilians." It is, in short, hard to imagine that the Red Cross could be colluding with Putin to deport the population. And, as in every war, it is hard to distinguish truth from what the propaganda machines of those doing the fighting want to pass off as such.