- On Ukraine, Donald Trump is likely to scale back US engagement, but peace in 24 hours is impossible.
- Trump's victory is good news for Israel, but the Middle East holds little interest for the tycoon.
- Relations with China will continue to be defined by tariffs, but there are those in the country who prefer Trump to Harris.
- The election of Trump also spells a new trade war for the European Union.
Donald Trump has won the presidential election and will be the 47th President of the United States. In the summer, when the weakness of incumbent president and Democratic rival Joe Biden had emerged in full force, the outcome seemed a foregone conclusion, but the switch to Kamala Harris had put everything back in play, or so the polls said.
In the end, Trump prevailed in every swing state, such as North Carolina and Georgia, and this paved the way for his victory. His inauguration will take place in January, but what we can do now is try to imagine what the new Republican administration will do in the field of foreign policy. There are many sensitive international files, but the hottest are undoubtedly those concerning Ukraine, the Middle East, the China question and the European Union.
Let's try to make sense of it all, with the help of experts.
Trump and Ukraine
If there is one country that has held its breath more than any other in the face of the US election, it is Ukraine. Since Russia under Vladimir Putin launched its invasion in February 2022, Ukraine has increasingly relied on Western weapons and aid. In 2023, just under half of its military spending (25 billion dollars) was covered by US donations, and while Democratic candidate Kamala Harris always showed her intention to continue in this direction if elected, Republican candidate Donald Trump made the opposite declarations. Now that the latter has won the election, things could change considerably on the Ukraine file.
"A possible and in some respects likely disengagement by the United States from its support for Kyiv would mean the Ukrainian government having to accept a peace on terms that are certainly less favourable than those it could have secured had Kamala Harris been elected," Gianluca Pastori, an analyst at the Istituto per gli studi di politica internazionale (Ispi), explains to LifeGate. "Clearly the choice of disengagement also depends on what configurations emerge at the level of the American political system more broadly," Pastori continues. "We know the stance of Trump and Vice President J. D. Vance, but foreign policy is not made by the president, the vice president and the administration alone. There is also Congress, which will certainly have a Republican majority but will not necessarily be a friendly Congress. To understand exactly how US policy will evolve, we need to wait a little longer, even though the trend will clearly be towards a less pressing commitment on Ukraine than the current one."
Among Donald Trump's campaign promises was the claim that he could stop the war in Ukraine within 24 hours. "A statement that is absolutely not credible," Pastori continues. "Peace is always the fruit of a negotiating process, and a negotiating process takes time and needs to happen away from the spotlight."
Trump and the Middle East
Among the first to publicly congratulate Donald Trump after his victory was Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. During his first term, which began in 2017, Trump was a president very close to Israel, designating Jerusalem as the country's capital and moving the US embassy there, as well as working hard to normalise relations between Israel and Arab nations through the Abraham Accords and withdrawing the United States from the Iran nuclear deal. During the election campaign, Trump reaffirmed his support for the country, while also stressing his desire to bring all wars to an end as quickly as possible.
"Like Ukraine, the Middle East is another theatre from which Trump wants to withdraw, because one of the indications that emerged during this election campaign is that Trump's foreign policy priority will be the relationship with China, and everything else will take a back seat," Ispi analyst Gianluca Pastori continues. "The intention to pull back from the Middle East and reduce US engagement in the region entails a broadly delegated role for the Israeli ally, so Trump in the White House is undoubtedly a blessing for Netanyahu."
But what will become of a Palestinian state, the region's unresolved issue par excellence? "While Kamala Harris had expressly championed the two-state solution and the Biden administration was and still is in favour of the two-state solution, Trump is far more vague on this point," Pastori continues, noting that the Palestinian question is the elephant in the room and is becoming ever less important, interesting and appealing to the leaderships of Arab countries.
What we might expect in the months following Trump's inauguration is pressure on Israel to bring its military offensives to an end — driven not so much by a desire for peace as by a wish to restore a balance in the United States–Israel–Arab countries triangle that serves US commercial interests in the region.
Trump and China
The competition between China and the United States exploded during Donald Trump's first term as US president. In 2018, the tycoon launched the trade war, imposing tariffs on 50 billion dollars worth of goods imported from the country and also raising the level of rhetorical tension with the Chinese Communist Party. On the campaign trail, the incoming president said he intends to continue down this path.
"On the trade front, Trump has already announced the resumption of tariffs on a large scale," Gianluca Dottori explains. "Trump has said that the centrepiece of American foreign policy will be the containment of China, clipping the wings of Beijing's rising international role, and to this end the preferred weapon will be the economic weapon." As the Ispi analyst notes, there is a fairly clear convergence of views between Trump's policy proposals and those of Harris on China. "Trump is the one who started the trade war with Beijing, but the Biden administration has done a great deal over the past four years to sustain it. This is perhaps truly the great bipartisan point, which tells us how important the Chinese challenge is for the United States today and how important the United States perceives it to be."
But how has Donald Trump's victory been received in China? "Chinese analysts had specified that whether Trump or Harris won, little would change, emphasising how the perception of the Chinese threat was probably the only thing the two candidates had in common", Simone Pieranni, a journalist specialising in China, explains to LifeGate. "Then there are those who pointed out that Trump, as a businessman, could be a better interlocutor, and those who said the opposite. What is certain is that they are waiting for the first moves to understand the scale of this victory, bearing in mind that a US that is unstable or perceived as such due to the Trump presidency is generally considered an advantage by Chinese leaders, allowing them to present China as the sole responsible power. Think, for example, of the signing of the climate agreements".
Trump and the European Union
Donald Trump's victory prompted great enthusiasm from a section of the political establishment in European Union countries. From Matteo Salvini to Italian prime minister Giorgia Meloni, from Hungarian president Viktor Orbán to French Rassemblement National leader Marine Le Pen, there was a succession of jubilant messages. And yet, the new Trump administration is likely to adopt hostile positions towards the Old Continent.
"Trump has been very clear — he explicitly spoke of across-the-board tariffs, which therefore hit Chinese imports but European imports too", Gianluca Dottori points out. "We must also prepare ourselves, in this area, for tensions that will be significant, not least because the European Union ideologically and as a supranational structure represents something that Trump is fighting against and that he feels he is at war with".