Most wildfires in Italy are deliberately started, but climate change is making the situation worse

Most wildfires in Italy are deliberately started, but climate change is making the situation worse

Environment · ·

60 per cent of blazes are arson, yet there is a link between extreme temperatures and the fires of recent days, in Italy and elsewhere: here's why.

On one hand, extreme temperatures recorded in many areas, such as the 47 degrees in Palermo. On the other, fires burning tens of thousands of hectares of woodland and Mediterranean scrubland, from Sicily to Calabria via Puglia, reaching the very outskirts of Palermo itself: 53,610 hectares so far in Italy as recorded by the Copernicus satellite system, as though an area equivalent to the whole of Molise and Rome combined had gone up in flames.

But is there a link between these two simultaneous emergencies — extreme temperatures and wildfires — that are battering southern Italy? Or should the causes of the flames destroying forests and valleys and lapping at beaches and towns be sought solely in arson, in the hands of criminal human beings? The answer, based on the data, appears to be straightforward: yes, arson is to blame. But there is a "but", because a link between extreme temperatures and wildfires also exists.

Incendio a Palermo
The fire on Monte Grifone, near Palermo © Francesco Pandolfo

What is the link between extreme temperatures and arson?

Sixty per cent of wildfires in Italy are deliberately started, according to an estimate provided by Coldiretti that is very close to the 54 per cent cited to parliament a year ago by the then minister for Ecological Transition Roberto Cingolani: the fire is ignited by human hands, by some pyromaniac or more probably by local criminal organisations. We saw this in recent days through footage captured by a drone belonging to the Calabria regional authority, which filmed a man in the very act of deliberately starting a fire.

A figure that cannot, however, be considered official: Italian justice has in fact recognised the deliberate nature of a blaze in only 4 per cent of the investigations opened last year (there can obviously be no other way of obtaining an official figure than a confirmed court ruling): Legambiente, in a report from last summer, explained that in 2021 the number of people charged was 658, an increase of 20 per cent compared with the previous year. Taking the estimates from Coldiretti and the former Ministry of Ecological Transition as reliable nonetheless, the impact is objectively undeniable. Equally undeniable, however, is that one of the key factors contributing to the worsening of this emergency is the rise in temperatures caused by greenhouse gas emissions into the atmosphere.

The role of climate change

The link between record temperatures and wildfires can be seen from the fact that the 53,522 hectares burned so far in Italy represent an increase of 11,000 hectares compared with last year. According to the latest report on the state of climate services, wildfires, together with droughts, extreme temperatures, floods, landslides and storms, represent the main causes of environmental disasters and their consequences in terms of human and economic losses. Every year, around half a million hectares of natural areas are burned in the European Union, and climate change is expected to further exacerbate wildfire risks.

And according to the analysis by scientists at World Weather Attribution, climate change has increased the likelihood of wildfires due to extreme temperatures by at least 30 per cent. As noted in a dossier presented by Alleanza Verdi Sinistra on the wildfire situation in Italy, scientists estimate that if global temperatures were to rise by 2 degrees Celsius, the fire weather conditions experienced in the summer of 2019–20 "would be at least four times more common as a result of human-caused climate change".

🔥L'Italia brucia. E il Governo?
Mentre oltre 53.5 mila ettari di boschi sono andati in fumo solo quest'anno – una superficie pari a Roma e Molise messe insieme – investe in carri Leopard e Ponte sullo Stretto.
@AngeloBonelli1

⬇️Scarica il Dossier⬇️
europaverde.it/wp-content/upl…

Against this backdrop, as a result of the fires that have devastated southern Italy in particular, together with drought and desertification, the arrival of the first storms brings an extremely high and alarming risk of landslides and floods.

Dry ground is "prey" to flames

The cause-and-effect link between extreme temperatures and wildfires is, moreover, clear: the high temperatures, combined with the drought of recent months that was not resolved by the heavy and sudden rainfall in the weeks that followed, have dried out the land, making it highly susceptible to fire. As a result, on one hand it becomes easier for a fire to break out accidentally; on the other, an act of arson still has a far greater chance of spreading rapidly under favourable conditions. This, combined with inadequate land management and human negligence, has led to the situation we see today: some experiencing it first hand, the luckier ones through images on television or online.

Those 15 billion for hydrogeological instability, deferred

Ultimately, the answer is yes: global warming, and with the record temperatures of recent days, has made Italy more vulnerable to wildfires and has also contributed to the desertification of the land. The soil is increasingly exposed to erosion, to the consequences of intensive farming practices, and to the salinisation of the soil and freshwater.

For this reason too, in Italy Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni announced "a major plan against hydrogeological instability": for now, however, the only initiative has been to redirect to other items from the Piano nazionale di ripresa e resilienza (Pnrr) funds originally earmarked for action on climate change and land management.

Among these, totalling 15 billion euros, are funds allocated to interventions for the resilience and energy efficiency of municipalities, measures for flood risk management and hydrogeological instability, and the protection and enhancement of urban and peri-urban green spaces. In theory, these funds should be recovered with the next Pnrr instalment, which the European Commission is expected to disburse by the end of 2023.