Climate: there is a link between extreme temperatures and hate speech

Climate: there is a link between extreme temperatures and hate speech

Economy & innovation · ·

Temperature swings accompanied by offensive thoughts and more aggressive tweets: here is how extreme climates influence people's behaviour.

It is not just our imagination: on days of extreme heat, people's mood changes and becomes unpredictable. According to a study published by the scientific journal Lancet planetary health, however, the influence of outside temperature would also have repercussions on our online behaviour, affecting the amount of hatred present online.

The link between hate speech and climate

Hate speech refers to all those types of aggressive and discriminatory messages, tweets, comments and videos, with racist, homophobic and transphobic content, or content that is otherwise offensive towards minorities or LGBTQ people. To verify the correlation between climate and this type of content, the working group at the Institute for climate impact research in Potsdam, Germany, led by analyst Leonie Wenz, collected around four billion tweets from the United States, identified on the basis of their geolocation. The selected messages had been sent between May 2014 and May 2020. Once the messages were obtained, Wenz and her team used artificial intelligence to trawl through the mass of tweets, searching for a wide range of English words and phrases deemed offensive, racist and discriminatory. The results appear to trace a strong link between extreme temperatures and the presence of hate speech online – or at least on Twitter, the social network chosen for this study. According to the analysis, tweets sent on days when temperatures in the US exceeded 42 degrees Celsius were found to contain 22 per cent more offensive and racist words than average. Not only that: the trend appears fairly uniform across geographic areas – from rural zones to wealthier suburbs – and income levels. Sweltering heat and drought thus seem to go hand in hand with a sharpening of tones in online discussions. Although it was not possible to carry out an in-depth analysis of the demographic or racial groups most "active" in creating offensive content, the study underlines that it is not difficult to understand who the targets of these messages were. Chief among them, Black people and Hispanics, who in the United States are the primary targets of hate speech.

hate speech
The increase in offensive content is correlated with extreme temperatures © iStockphoto

Offensive online content increases with temperature swings

Something similar appears to occur in the opposite direction as well, when temperatures drop below zero, and another increase in hate speech is recorded – although this time a more measured one: "only" 12.5 per cent. What drives these spikes are temperature swings rather than absolute temperatures: in hotter areas, the increase in this type of content on the hottest days is more contained. According to the study's authors, this means that the increases in offensive tweets "are dependent on the temperatures we are accustomed to." According to the study's authors, this link between extreme temperatures and hate speech will grow ever stronger over the coming years due to global warming and extreme weather events and climatic phenomena. "The expression of online hatred could increase in the future," becoming one of the most significant political and cultural effects of the climate that awaits us.