If we are made of earth, we must respect its rules, now more than ever
Food — di Tommaso Perrone
Agroecology and education are among the ingredients for emerging from this pandemic stronger than before. Siamo fatti di terra proposes solutions.

Agroecology and education are among the ingredients for emerging from this pandemic stronger than before. Siamo fatti di terra proposes solutions.
This pandemic has changed many things. Perhaps too many. It has forced us to abandon our way of life — both the one we should have changed years ago, such as our relationship with the Planet and its natural resources, and the one we would never have wanted to change, such as our relationships with the people we love.
It has made us change our everyday habits, from our approach to school and work to our leisure time. It has even made us rethink our concept of "home" — a place that has once again become somewhere to truly "live in" rather than, for some, merely a "place in passing".
Last year, LifeGate together with Alce Nero — the participatory enterprise made up of organic farmers and processors — embarked on an educational journey that took us around Italy to talk about sustainability.

Though taking different forms and timescales, its goal was precisely to raise awareness and improve the relationship between human beings and the Earth that sustains them, along with the food and natural resources it provides each year. This journey, entitled Siamo fatti di terra, seeks to prompt reflection on a simple fact: what is good for the environment and the planet is good for people. Because no food, no agricultural product, can nourish an organism in a healthy way if it comes from a sick model that exploits land, resources and workers.
This pandemic has confirmed, once again, that this was the right direction. After all, the virus that gave rise to this global health emergency is itself the result of the wrong way in which we have related to nature. For this reason, we have chosen to continue this journey in a new form, while returning to the protagonists who, a year ago, helped us understand which direction to take.
When we asked Professor Giovanni Dinelli of the Department of Agricultural and Food Sciences at the University of Bologna what role agroecology plays today, he replied that "the Covid-19 pandemic has highlighted how fragile our production systems are, and how our entire economy has a resilience capacity close to zero. With the pandemic, we have experienced first-hand how a butterfly's wing beat in China can unleash a hurricane in America or Europe."
That is why, first and foremost, we must learn to observe again, Dinelli argued: "Observation is the first principle of agroecology. We have unlearned how to do it: industrial agriculture operates on 'recipes' that we have applied without asking any questions. Now we are beginning to realise how many adverse side effects this approach has generated in our agroecosystems. Observing and then choosing what is best for the Earth also means beginning to heal ourselves. This new way strips us of the terrible presumption that living systems can withstand any insult we decide to inflict upon them."
Our healing process begins here. With rediscovery, with teaching old and new techniques. As GreatLife does — the European project led by the University of Bologna, whose aim is to trial resilient crops in order to reduce the impact of climate change, while helping to support farmers' incomes and create quality products for the end market.
"To draw any conclusions," Dinelli continues, speaking about GreatLife, "we will have to let time do its part: one year is far too short a period to understand whether our project has succeeded in fulfilling its educational purpose." He concludes by quoting statesman Nelson Mandela: "'Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world,' he said. I firmly believe this. But I believe even more strongly in what American journalist Sydney J. Harris said: 'The purpose of education is to turn mirrors into windows.' I hope that GreatLife can contribute in a meaningful way to creating many windows."

Dinelli's vision of agroecology is not so different from that expressed by Manlio Masucci of Navdanya International, the organisation founded by Indian activist and scientist Vandana Shiva to defend biodiversity and the right to a healthy diet free from toxins: "Agroecology can offer solutions to some fundamental aspects linked to the pandemic. The first one that comes to mind concerns our immune system. When we talk about junk food, we are talking about food with few nutrients and many substances that are harmful to our bodies. When we talk about pesticides, we are talking about immunosuppressive products, not just probable carcinogens and endocrine disruptors."
And one cannot speak about pesticides without hearing the words of a person who is among the finest examples of Italian research excellence in the world. We are talking about Dr Fiorella Belpoggi, head of the "Cesare Maltoni" Cancer Research Centre, which is part of the Ramazzini Institute in Bologna, whom we asked about the latest developments on the dangers and potential banning of glyphosate, one of the most widely used herbicides in the world: "Glyphosate has several adverse health effects. These adverse effects, already published in dozens of studies in authoritative peer-reviewed journals, concern not only the carcinogenic effects identified by the International Agency for Research on Cancer (Iarc), which falls under the World Health Organization, but above all the endocrine-disrupting effects on the hormonal balance of unborn children and newborns, who may be exposed to it through their mother during pregnancy or through breast milk at birth."
Belpoggi and the Ramazzini team of experts are working hard to be ready by 2022, when Europe will have to decide on the renewal of the authorisation of the herbicide: "As we had announced, in 2019 the Ramazzini Institute began a large-scale experiment to study both the adverse effects of glyphosate and two of its formulations — those currently most used in Europe and the United States — on the endocrine system, influencing reproduction and development, and in parallel a study on carcinogenicity, using low doses that are considered to have no effects. The study on reproduction and development is being processed, the carcinogenesis study will see its 'in vivo' phase concluded next year, and by 2022 we expect to have at least the preliminary data available," Belpoggi continues, "so that we can provide them to the European Commission so that the new authorisation can also be based on our independent data. The results may potentially determine a ban should carcinogenic effects be identified."

A challenge made even more arduous by the current situation, given that the independence of the studies relies largely on donations from ordinary citizens. "Achieving this goal is an enormous challenge, above all because the money needed to fund the entire study is collected with great commitment, but also with great difficulty, through crowdfunding activities (for those who would like to, donations can also be made online, ed.). The lockdown prevented us from organising all the recreational and scientific events on which a large part of our budget coverage is based."
For all these reasons, and also to address a climate emergency, as well as a health one, it is essential to radically change the model of development, to cut the economic incentives that governments still guarantee today to fossil fuels and to conventional agriculture, which built its fortunes on those very same fuels. "At the moment I don't see any real political will to change things," Masucci states, "and this is despite the input from the European Union (see the Green Deal and projects such as Farm to Fork and Biodiversity 2030, ed.). On the contrary, we are witnessing clumsy attempts by some politicians to rehabilitate herbicides such as glyphosate. The law on organic farming has been stalled in the Senate for almost two years. These are negative signals that make us understand how there are still strong vested interests pushing to defend the status quo."

But there is no shortage of good news, because, as the organisation Navdanya International demonstrates, more and more territories are mobilising for change from below in the face of this legislative and institutional stalemate: "The next step is the creation of biodistricts (areas dedicated to organic farming where producers, citizens, tourism operators and public administrations enter into agreements for the sustainable management of resources. In Italy there are more than thirty of them, ed.). The trend is growing and we are observing how changes at the local level can also bring about changes at the regional and national level."
These words convey passion, conviction. That is why Siamo fatti di terra continues with more determination than ever. If it is the task of scientists to "translate and make information available to everyone", as highlighted by Dr Belpoggi, it is equally true that it is essential to ensure that this same information reaches the widest possible number of citizens.
On our journey we will meet experts in nutrition and biodiversity, protagonists from the world of art and culture, in an effort to understand not only what "new normal" will look like or mean, but to bring examples of change. Solutions are not lacking, but we must commit ourselves so that human beings can continue to live in harmony with other forms of life. Because if we are made of earth, we must respect its rules, now more than ever.
Sponsored article