Problem-solving ability may explain the success of grey squirrels

Problem-solving ability may explain the success of grey squirrels

Environment · ·

According to a British study, North American grey squirrels are displacing their European counterparts in part because they are better at solving complex problems.

In Great Britain, Ireland and Italy, the North American grey squirrel (Sciurus carolinensis), considered by the IUCN to be one of the hundred most invasive non-native species, risks displacing the native red squirrel (Sciurus vulgaris). A recent study conducted in Great Britain has offered a new, cognitive explanation for the remarkable rise of these "alien squirrels".

Scoiattolo grigio che scende da un tronco
Since Great Britain and Ireland are islands, the presence of the grey squirrel is a serious but localised problem. In Italy, however, it also poses a threat to red squirrel populations in neighbouring France and Switzerland, and in the long term across the entire European continent © Ingimage

Two competing species

The non-native grey squirrel, recklessly introduced to Europe by humans, is gaining the upper hand over the native European squirrel through mechanisms of food competition. The alien species is more robust than the native one, reproduces more quickly, and is immune to a virus that is lethal to red squirrels. But, according to the study A battle of wits? Problem-solving abilities in invasive eastern grey squirrels and native Eurasian red squirrels, conducted by researchers at the University of Exeter and Edinburgh, these are not the only "weapons" at the grey squirrel's disposal.

Read also: È arrivata la conferma, abbiamo uno scoiattolo tutto italiano: lo scoiattolo meridionale

The secret of the grey squirrels

The key to the grey squirrel's success may lie in its ability to solve complex problems, which surpasses that of red squirrels. Researchers tested the abilities of both species through a series of exercises. The tasks involved opening containers with hazelnuts inside: the first exercise was simpler, requiring the squirrels to open a container with a transparent lid, while the other was more complex and required the manipulation of several levers. The simpler exercise was completed successfully by both species, while the difference in the more difficult one was clear — it was solved by 91 per cent of grey squirrels compared to 62 per cent of red squirrels.

Scoiattolo nordamericano che mangia
The Ec-Square project portal notes that, according to a medium-term projection, the expansion of the grey squirrel will lead it to colonise the Alps, the Apennines, and the transalpine countries of France and Switzerland, which border Italy © Ingimage

Behavioural flexibility

The study, published in the journal Animal Behaviour, therefore suggests that the success of grey squirrels — the ratio of grey to red squirrels is 15 to 1 — can be explained by superior behavioural flexibility. "Our research shows that problem-solving ability could be another key factor in the success of grey squirrels," explained Pizza Ka Yee Chow, of the Centre for Research in Animal Behaviour at the University of Exeter. "This ability could be particularly important for an invasive species like the grey squirrel, since it evolved elsewhere and must adapt to its surrounding environment".

Read also: Lo scoiattolo rosso si è ripreso l'Umbria

Read also: In Irlanda la martora ha salvato lo scoiattolo rosso

Innate or acquired talent?

It is not yet clear, however, whether the cognitive gap between the two species is innate or linked to other factors. "We don't know whether grey squirrels are genetically more gifted at problem-solving, or whether they work harder because they are an invasive species living outside their natural environment," Chow stated.

Scoiattolo rosso nel bosco
In Great Britain and Ireland, the red squirrel is at risk of extinction due to the introduction of the grey squirrel by humans © Ingimage

There is still hope for the reds

The test did, however, yield some encouraging results for red squirrels too: among the individuals who succeeded in the more complex exercise, some solved it more quickly than the grey squirrels and showed greater responsiveness in changing tactic after trying an ineffective method. "Investigating the different cognitive abilities of animals can help us understand important aspects related to conservation," said Stephen Lea of the University of Exeter. To curb the numbers of grey squirrels, Great Britain launched a pilot sterilisation programme in 2017 that involves using bait laced with an immunocontraceptive vaccine. In Italy, meanwhile, the U-Savereds project is under way, funded primarily by the European Union and also supported by Ispra and Legambiente, which provides for the eradication of the grey squirrel.