What do the new European rules on the use of child car seats say? What advice should you follow to ensure maximum safety for children? Here is what the data and experts say.
Travelling safely is a right of every child. Making sure this happens is the duty of us adults. This is why the subject of child car seats and their correct use requires particular attention. The evolution of safety standards and the resulting updates to current European regulations, as well as the imminent holiday season and family travel, give us a further opportunity to shed light both on what the law says and on the valuable advice that experts can offer us.
Italian parents and the use of car seats
The data painting a picture of car seat use on Italian roads is far from reassuring. On average, only 4 in 10 parents regularly use the restraint systems required by law (Ulisse report by the Istituto superiore di sanità). While in the North this figure rises to 59.1 per cent, in the South and on the islands it plummets to 16.7 per cent, while in central Italy it stands at 40.2 per cent. Another discouraging figure comes from the Asaps observatory (Associazione sostenitori ed amici della polizia stradale), according to which in 2016 the number of child road accident victims increased by 26 per cent compared with the previous year. In total, this amounts to 53 deaths (11 more than in 2015), with 1,312 injuries across 1,049 significant accidents.
Children without car seats: mistakes and misconceptions to dispel
Research carried out by Altroconsumo and presented at the Vai sul sicuro conference, organised by the portal Cercaseggiolini, revealed that 33 per cent of adults do not bother to fasten children correctly in their seats when journeys are short and roads are quiet. Indeed, these conditions lead 75 per cent of adults to consider the risk low. Other reasons that lead people not to secure young passengers in restraint systems include tantrums (28 per cent), the convenience of simply holding them in their arms (14 per cent), or low travelling speed (25 per cent).
All of these beliefs are, however, contradicted by the facts. Most accidents actually occur on urban roads (74.7 per cent), where speeds are lower. It is enough to know that in an impact at 56 kilometres per hour, a child weighing 15 kilos generates an impact force of 225 kilos, making it impossible to hold them with arms alone, according to the Automobile club d'Italia. With seatbelts and car seats, on the other hand, the risk of serious or fatal injury is reduced by 90 per cent.
Child car seats, the 2017 regulations
Italy
In Italy, Article 172 of the Highway Code states: "Children whose height is less than 1.50 metres must be secured to the seat with a child restraint system appropriate to their weight, of an approved type." The penalties for failure to comply with this rule have recently been tightened and involve the payment of a fine of between 80 and 323 euros, and in the case of a repeat offence (that is, two fines within two years) a driving licence suspension of between fifteen days and three months. If the person is caught driving during this period of suspension, the driving licence is ultimately revoked. All of this serves to underline the importance of complying with the regulation for the benefit of children's safety.
Europe and the world
There are also international regulations valid in Europe and in much of the world, such as Un Ece R-44/04, which came into force in its latest update on 1 January 2017 and which introduces various new provisions relating to the approval of car seats.
One important development is the introduction of the criterion of children's height alongside that of weight (age, by contrast, is indicative only). For example, the obligation to use car seats with a backrest now applies to children up to 125 centimetres tall, who will therefore no longer be able to use simple booster cushions (also known as boosters). The latter may only be used for children between 125 and 150 centimetres tall. This decision stems from the greater safety provided by side-impact protection, which in the event of a collision cushions the impact of the child's head and chest against the windows.
Beyond the 150-centimetre height threshold, each child may simply use the car's seatbelt, but up to the age of 12 must always travel in the rear seat.
The regulations apply to car seats produced after 1 January and do not require those already owned or produced previously (but not before 1995) to be scrapped. The label is the point of reference. It goes without saying that, beyond what is legally required, following more up-to-date safety standards can only be a matter of common sense.
The i-Size regulation and the Isofix attachment
Alongside the regulation mentioned above (Ece R-44/04), there is also the more recent Un Ece R129, also known as i-Size and conceived as the first of its kind by the United Nations Economic Commission for Europe (Unece). The latter governs i-Size Isofix devices (universal integral Isofix) and is a new European safety regulation for child restraint systems developed primarily for Isofix car seats.
These acronyms — enough to give anyone a headache — refer in practice to the international fixing system that allows car seats to be anchored to vehicles more easily. All parents know very well just how laborious the installation process can be. Correctly fitting car seats is, however, essential to ensure they function properly. The Isofix attachment is designed precisely to simplify this stage and involves two universal connectors on the base of the seat that can be inserted into the corresponding hooks built into the car.
The benefits of the i-Size standard (which will replace the existing one in the future) are several. For example, this standard allows the seat to be kept in the "rear-facing" position — that is, facing against the direction of travel — for longer, which is the safest position for children. As is well known, in young children the weight of the head relative to the body is proportionally greater than in adults, and the neck muscles are not yet strong enough to withstand the force of impact in an accident. The Altroconsumo Bambini a bordo in sicurezza test demonstrated that this position "reduces the risk of neck trauma and injury by 80 per cent".
For this reason, the regulation has extended the obligation for children to travel in this position: whereas previously it applied until 9 kilos, it now applies until 15 months of age. Keeping them in this position for longer is in any case recommended, since it is only after the age of four that the weight of a child's head and body even out and the muscles become capable of withstanding greater forces.
Choosing a child car seat
A key criterion in choosing a child car seat is therefore precisely the attention to safety standards offered by the manufacturer. Among the brands most focused on this issue is the German company Cybex, regarded as a leader in child safety and consistently engaged in promoting campaigns on the subject. On its official website, an entire section, SafetyCenter, is dedicated to specific information and in-depth content, also offering a direct line to sector experts who are available to answer questions and clear up any doubts.
Cybex also chooses to subject its products to numerous crash tests and assessments carried out by independent institutes such as the German Automobile Club, the Italian Altroconsumo and its German counterpart Stiftung Warentest, whose evaluation criteria are more stringent than those required for standard type-approval.
All aspects that no parent should ever overlook before making such an important purchase, bearing in mind that investing in the safety of one's children is always a wise choice.
Child car seats, regulations and safety tips on board
Well-being — di Alice Zampa
What do the new European rules on the use of child car seats say? What advice should you follow to ensure maximum safety for children? Here is what the data and experts say.