Nuclear waste: the government publishes the map of sites suitable for a repository
Energy — di Maurizio Bongioanni
The map of 51 sites suitable for hosting the permanent nuclear waste repository has been published. But none of them wants it.

The map of 51 sites suitable for hosting the permanent nuclear waste repository has been published. But none of them wants it.
On 13 December 2023, the new National Map of Suitable Areas (Cnai) was published, with the aim of identifying the most "appropriate" sites for hosting Italy's national repository for nuclear waste. The Cnai identifies 51 sites, of which 21 are in Lazio,
10 in Basilicata, 5 on the border between Basilicata and Puglia, 5 in Piedmont, 2 in Sicily, and 8 in Sardinia. One of these will be selected to build the permanent repository where Italy's nuclear waste will be buried. Here is what it's all about.

Although Italy has no active nuclear power plants, there are thousands of tonnes of radioactive waste on our territory. Some of it has been and continues to be produced by the decommissioning of nuclear power plants that ceased operating following the 1987 referendum (approximately 60 per cent of the total), while the rest comes from the "waste" generated by scientific research, industry and the nuclear medicine sector. The latter will continue to be produced in our country in the future.
To date, this amounts to 78,000 cubic metres of nuclear waste classified as having a medium-low or low level of radioactivity — that is, those radionuclides whose radioactivity takes a few hundred years (yes, you read that correctly) to decay — to which a further 17,000 cubic metres of medium-high and high-activity waste must be added, whose radioactivity takes thousands of years to decay. At present, a large proportion of this waste — particularly that coming from power plants being decommissioned — is stored abroad: in France, Belgium and the United Kingdom.
Unlike other European countries, Italy does not yet have a facility for the permanent storage of radioactive waste. The European Union, however, has called on each member state to manage its own nuclear waste domestically. The primary objective of the national repository is therefore to find a location for the 78,000 cubic metres of low and medium-low radioactivity nuclear waste that we have produced and continue to produce.
For low and medium-level nuclear waste, surface engineered barriers are sufficient — such as the national repository that is the subject of this article and of the research launched by the government. The repository must be designed to last at least 300 years. The conditioned and compacted waste (conditioning involves encapsulating solid waste, or solidifying liquid waste, in cement or glass) will first be sealed inside steel drums filled with cementite. These drums will then in turn be sealed inside reinforced concrete boxes, and all the boxes — around a hundred of them — will be arranged in a large surface-level tank, also made of concrete. This tank will finally be covered with a layer of soil and a grass surface.
A separate matter concerns the 17,000 cubic metres of medium-high and high-intensity waste. For these, cylindrical containers known as "canitester" — 3 metres tall and designed to withstand flooding, explosions, fires and earthquakes — will be used. This waste will be temporarily housed in the new repository, pending a geological repository for permanent disposal, if that term can be applied.

The Ministry of the Environment and Energy Security (Mase), in agreement with the Ministry of Infrastructure and Transport, approved, by its own decree, the National Map of Suitable Areas that meet the technical and socio-environmental characteristics set out in the technical guide drawn up by Isin (the National Inspectorate for Nuclear Safety and Radiation Protection): some of these parameters require that suitable sites must not be located in areas at risk of earthquakes, volcanic eruptions or hydrogeological hazards. They must be at a minimum distance of 5 kilometres from the coast and must be far from residential areas, industrial facilities and military installations. They must also not be within a protected natural area or near habitats where endangered animal species live.
The published list is therefore a long-awaited technical document that has been subject to numerous delays and that further narrows down the options set out in the previous list of areas deemed only "potentially suitable" for building the repository. In addition to the Cnai, the ministries have given municipalities that meet the technical parameters the opportunity to put themselves forward as candidates to host the repository. Applications must be submitted within 30 days of the publication of the map, after which Mase will initiate, with the technical support of Sogin, the Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) procedure for the sites indicated on the map or that have in the meantime put themselves forward. So far, only one municipality has voluntarily come forward: Trino Vercellese, in Piedmont, where a nuclear power plant once operated before being decommissioned. The municipality selected to host the repository will be guaranteed incentives.
Let us turn to timescales and costs. First of all, what scale are we talking about? The radioactive waste repository must cover an area of at least 20 hectares of land (10 hectares for waste alone), but the area that must host it needs to extend over 150 hectares, as treatment and maintenance facilities will be built around it — and above all, a 40-hectare technology park will need to be established.
The initial estimated cost, according to Sogin, is 900 million euros, financed through the A2 tariff component of electricity bills. As reported on the website www.depositonazionale.it, to these resources must be added "up to 1 billion euros for research projects at the technology park, through public and private funding".
Once the definitive area for the repository has been identified (which could take another year), construction work on the national repository and the technology park is expected to last approximately four years, with the facility then entering into operation by 2029.

One of the main criticisms concerns the self-candidacy process promoted by Mase, and it is levelled by the president of Legambiente, Stefano Ciafani, who describes it as an incomprehensible parallel process: "Why on earth would the territories of these municipalities, if they did not previously meet the stringent requirements demanded during the assessment phase, now instead be considered 'suitable' for hosting the national nuclear waste repository? It is well known, for example, that the mayor of the municipality of Trino, in Piedmont, never concealed from the outset his interest in having the national repository on his territory, despite the fact that no fewer than six criteria had led to its exclusion. For what reason could it now, instead, formally put itself forward to be chosen?".
Furthermore, currently none of the 51 selected sites has responded positively to the idea of hosting the national radioactive waste repository on its territory. Many observers and commentators relegate the issue to the Nimby (Not in my back-yard) phenomenon — that is, the refusal to allow a given risky or high-impact project to be built next to one's own "home" — but the matter takes on more complex dimensions if we consider, for example, the award of contracts for the construction of the facility and its efficiency over time. There is no shortage of examples of major public works in which cases of corruption or infiltration by organised crime undermine the quality of the project itself, or simply of delays to the schedule which, as well as inflating costs, prolong the hardship suffered by the host territory.
In short, while not ruling out the prospect of vigorous protests from local communities when the time comes to get the project concretely under way, oversight will need to be efficient and guarantee both timelines and the integrity of the works. Otherwise, the risk of witnessing yet another poorly managed project on the part of the companies involved will be enormous — a situation that will once again, and to an even greater degree, exacerbate the lack of trust in institutions. And the so-called Nimby phenomenon.