Rossella Muroni: “With the wolf, we rediscover a culture of coexistence”

Rossella Muroni: “With the wolf, we rediscover a culture of coexistence”

Environment · ·

The wolf is always making headlines in our country. We spoke with Legambiente president Rossella Muroni to understand why.

Love it or hate it, the wolf (Canis lupis italicus) is Italy's most talked-about animal. The conflict between humans and wolves is said to have its roots in the year 1000, when, partly as a result of population growth and the progressive destruction of forests, the living spaces of the two species drew closer together than ever before. In Italy, until 1971 the wolf could be hunted in any season and by any means; this indiscriminate hunting pushed the species to the brink of extinction, with barely a hundred individuals surviving in the wild. After a spectacular demographic recovery, the wolf is now once again at risk of being legally hunted.

Lupo italiano
Despite the recovery of populations, the wolf cannot be considered out of danger in Italy owing to the persistence of threats such as hybridisation with dogs, poaching, collisions with vehicles and diseases such as distemper

Numerous controversies followed the presentation by the Ministry of the Environment of a draft of the new national action plan for the conservation and management of the wolf. The new plan would allow (even in national parks) the legalised culling of a maximum of 60 wolves — a decision fiercely contested by environmental and conservation organisations. We discussed this with Rossella Muroni, president of Legambiente, who had just returned from taking part in the national meeting in Sulmona Dall'Appennino alle Alpi, le buone pratiche per il futuro del lupo in Italia, organised by Legambiente and the parco nazionale della Majella in collaboration with Federparchi.

What topics were covered at the Sulmona meeting?

There was a collective discussion about the well-known wolf management plan, presented in draft form by the Ministry of the Environment and designed to address one of the most heated debates currently taking place in our country — on wildlife management in general and on the wolf in particular. We start from the premise that we come from a successful conservation story: many winning projects to protect and safeguard the wolf in Italy have been undertaken, enabling the species to recover — Legambiente's Wolfnet project, for instance.

Rossella Muroni
Rossella Muroni, presidente di Legambiente © Dario Orlandi

One of the topics generating great debate and controversy among farmers is the alleged reintroduction of wolves in Italy.

No new individuals have been released into the wild. The numbers have simply grown thanks to recent protection legislation, an increase in prey and the depopulation of foothill areas. The problem is that the culture of coexistence with certain species has been lost — a culture that once underpinned a particular kind of rural civilisation. There are two issues to address: coexistence with the productive activities that exist in areas where wolves are present, from tourism to, above all, livestock farming and animal husbandry. From this point of view, what we believe is missing is the involvement of trade associations, which could bring farmers closer to the debate and help find shared solutions rather than fuelling constant opposition. The main source of friction is the question of compensation for damage caused by wildlife. Reimbursements are often slow and partial, which causes considerable economic harm and increases resentment towards wolves.

It is equally true that farmers do not always take the right precautions to protect themselves against predator attacks.

That is true. The Wolfnet project, for example, was set up precisely to rediscover a culture of coexistence, including through different livestock management practices. From the type of herding to the use of appropriate fencing, from monitoring the land to raising sheepdogs — which can act as a natural deterrent to wolf presence. Not everyone knows, for instance, that a sheepdog should be raised within the flock: this helps it contextualise its own role and feel responsible for the safety of the sheep. It is a matter of rediscovering an ancient culture rooted in the knowledge of animal husbandry.

Pastore maremmano abruzzese
The Maremma-Abruzzo sheepdog is one of farmers' best allies against wolves

What do you think of the possible culling of some individuals proposed by the ministry?

In Italy, the leading cause of wolf mortality is poaching. We therefore need to consider two elements: first, the wolf as a species has not yet been declared out of danger — the population is growing and the trend is positive, but it is still too early to declare victory; second, poaching is an example of illegal behaviour, and legalising culling would in some way legitimise this type of crime. It is like building amnesties in cases of illegal construction: it somehow justifies unlawful conduct. By providing for the legalised culling of some wolves, a wrong message is being sent, in an attempt to make people accept it. This dynamic has in fact already occurred: in Veneto, Tosi had issued an ordinance allowing citizens to kill wolves if they posed a threat to themselves or their livestock.

What measures should be taken to find a solution?

All the stakeholders involved should be brought together around a table, so that all observations can be gathered and the critical issues identified with a view to finding a shared solution. This should, however, be the government's responsibility, not that of individual organisations.

Many attacks on livestock blamed on wolves could be the work of dogs or hybrids. What is Legambiente's position on the question of hybrids?

We need to start from an understanding of the phenomenon: an in-depth study should be commissioned from Ispra to determine the actual number of wolf-dog hybrid individuals. To make progress in this area, a scientific approach that establishes the scale of the phenomenon is indispensable. It is certainly an issue that needs to be clarified, because it gives rise to urban myths.

Lupo appenninico
There are today around a thousand wolves present in Italy — a remarkable result when one considers that the species had been at risk of extinction in the 1970s © Massimiliano Sticca

What must we do to coexist with the wolf?

We need to try to reach a less anthropocentric outlook and attempt to coexist with other animal species. Despite opposition from farmers, a strong movement in defence of the wolf has emerged, bearing witness to the fact that it is a species held in affection by the majority of Italians. The Wwf, for example, launched a petition against the wolf culling plan that met with great success.