Migrants: Europe changes course — every country will have to welcome refugees

Migrants: Europe changes course — every country will have to welcome refugees

Rights · ·

Asylum seekers will not be required to stay in the first European country they arrive in, but will be able to join family members in the country of their choice. A victory for Italy?

Also following Italy's lengthy insistence, the European Union has decided to amend the so-called Dublin Regulation, the set of rules that determines which member state is responsible for processing an application for international protection. The draft reform approved by the European Union's Committee on Civil Liberties provides that the first country of arrival will no longer be automatically responsible for asylum seekers, and introduces the automatic transfer of asylum seekers according to a fixed distribution method. The draft underlines that all asylum seekers must be registered upon arrival, and envisages a strengthening of security checks.

How things have worked for asylum seekers until now

Germania profughi migranti
A group of refugees in Germany ©Sean Gallup/Getty Images

Under the current rules, the Dublin Regulation provides that responsibility for an asylum seeker is automatically assumed by the first European country on which the migrant sets foot. In recent years, given the growing traffic along the Mediterranean Sea route with landings at Lampedusa, that country has in the majority of cases been Italy itself, with evident management problems: our country has had to shoulder an ever-increasing number of asylum seekers, with the consequences of severe overcrowding in the reception system and a backlog in the bureaucratic procedures aimed at granting (or not granting) refugee status. Not only that, because many of the migrants who have landed in Italy are actually aiming to leave Italy to reunite with family members who emigrated to other European countries in previous years (often Germany, Switzerland, or northern Europe), and in order not to be forced by the Dublin rules to remain in Italy they refuse recognition, effectively entering a state of irregularity.

Read also: 18 December is World Migrants Day

Free to go to the European country of the asylum seeker's choice

If the new draft were actually to enter into force, certain distortions could be resolved, to the benefit of the asylum seekers themselves as well as of the countries most exposed to migratory flows, such as Italy: the first country of arrival will no longer be automatically responsible for asylum seekers.

The attribution of responsibility would instead be based on "genuine links" with a member state, such as family ties, having previously lived there, or studies undertaken there. In the absence of such links, asylum seekers would be automatically assigned to an EU member state on the basis of a fixed distribution method, as soon as they are registered and following a security check and a rapid assessment of the admissibility of their protection application. This is precisely to avoid "frontline" states, such as Italy, Greece and all those on the eastern border, shouldering all the international obligations to which the EU is subject with regard to people in need, and to speed up asylum procedures. Countries that do not comply with the rules risk having their access to European funds reduced.