Donald Trump: what happens now after the impeachment
Rights — di Elisabetta Scuri
Donald Trump seems immune to every scandal surrounding him. Will he survive the impeachment too? We asked Riccardo Alcaro of the Istituto affari internazionali.

Donald Trump seems immune to every scandal surrounding him. Will he survive the impeachment too? We asked Riccardo Alcaro of the Istituto affari internazionali.
That unmistakable blond toupee, the lip movements that enunciate every word with precision, the skin tone that tends towards orange, the ever-present red or blue tie in honour of the American flag. And those deadly tweets fired at political opponents. It's quite true: the current president of the United States, Donald Trump – elected in 2016, but inaugurated at the White House on 20 January 2017 – has a unique style. As unique as his presidency has been: studded with scandals, controversies and divisions, it does not, however, appear to have disappointed his voters.
One wonders whether things will change now that Trump is facing impeachment: the House has formally charged him with abuse of power and obstruction of Congress, so he will now have to be tried by the Senate, which will decide whether to remove him from office or not. To get an advance sense of what his fate might be and what the (far-reaching) repercussions on the international community could look like, we spoke with Riccardo Alcaro, research coordinator at the Istituto affari internazionali (Iai) and head of its "Global Actors" programme.

In plain terms, what is impeachment?
Impeachment is the indictment, the charging of the sitting president by one of the two chambers of the United States parliament, known as Congress. Congress is divided into two chambers: the House of Representatives and the Senate. The former is constitutionally the body empowered to potentially place the president under investigation, and that is what has happened. Trump has been indicted for having committed, in the view of the majority of House members, acts that can be defined as high crimes or misdemeanours, in the words of the Constitution. These are not criminal offences in the penal sense of the term, but acts contrary to the Constitution. In his case, they amount to abuse of the presidential office — that is, he used his office for his own political gain by putting pressure on a third country. The second charge is obstruction; he is alleged to have prevented several of his aides, who had been called by the House of Representatives to testify, from giving their testimony. The ball now passes to the Senate, where there will be a kind of trial: while the House votes on the indictment, the Senate votes on whether to remove him from office or not. Whereas in the House an absolute majority suffices for the indictment, actual removal requires a two-thirds supermajority.
How did all this come about?
Last summer it emerged that Trump, in a phone call with the president of Ukraine [Volodymyr Zelensky, ed.], had pressed for the opening of two investigations that he could have exploited to his advantage in the 2020 campaign when he would be running again. Trump asked for an investigation to be opened into a Ukrainian company on whose board sat the son of Joe Biden – one of the candidates for the Democratic nomination, a possible challenger to Trump in the next election, who last summer was leading in the polls for the Democratic Party primary and was considered by Trump to be his most formidable opponent.
By pressing the Ukrainian president to open this investigation, his aim was to use whatever came out of it – even if there was in fact no evidence of wrongdoing – as a political weapon during the electoral campaign against Biden. This was not a request to strengthen Ukraine's anti-corruption measures or anything of the sort, but an actual request to publicly link the words "Biden" and "corruption investigation" regardless of whether any circumstantial evidence actually existed that Joe Biden (who also served as Obama's vice-president) had committed any wrongdoing. Nor was it simply a request that Trump made, because the House of Representatives inquiry revealed that it was a request with something of a "gangster" tone to it: the opening of this investigation had been made a condition for a state visit by the Ukrainian president to the White House and, above all, for the disbursement of 400 million dollars in military aid from the United States to Ukraine. The latter is a militarily very weak country that was attacked by Russia in 2014 and is still engaged in a low-intensity war with it. It therefore depends enormously on the political, military and financial support of other countries. The Ukrainian president was in an impossible situation: on the one hand he needed US assistance, but on the other he was being asked to indirectly harm one of the American political parties that might one day return a president to office.
How has the international community reacted?
It has reacted with dismay. Democrats say Trump exploited presidential powers to damage a political opponent, and did so by putting pressure on a third country, a US partner on which it depends enormously. Republicans argue that what Trump actually did does not amount to genuine blackmail: fine, perhaps he's no saint, but the evidence does not support the claim that there was actually a quid pro quo between the two sides. That said, Trump did effectively put pressure on the other party. It is the first time an American president has used his office for personal gain, turning the relationship with a third country into an instrument of domestic politics. From a certain point of view there is dismay because it has never happened before. Yet there is no chance that Trump will actually be removed from office, because the Democrats do not have a majority in the Senate, where they would need two thirds of the vote. Republicans will never vote for removal. He will be acquitted by the Senate because the Republicans will block it. On the other hand, politically it is a storm. If he survives and is re-elected, for all the other countries in the world new avenues and new options will open up for interacting with the United States, favouring one candidate or another, and exploiting American domestic politics for their own gain. It's as if a cattle market were opening up. I know you're an important politician, even a US presidential candidate, I know you want this and that and I'll offer it to you, I'll help your political career and in return you'll help me afterwards. This is something new, a turning point in the way Americans manage their international relations, which have always been handled on a fairly bipartisan basis — that is, by common consensus between Democrats and Republicans — but what has certainly never happened before is this intrusion of American domestic politics into foreign policy; no president has ever been seen to do anything like this.
Can we call this a historic moment?
The Trump presidency is certainly historic for many reasons, above all because of the nature of the man himself, who is antithetical to certain human qualities of bearing, behaviour, conduct and rhetoric that were considered absolutely inseparable from the presidential office in the United States. We have never seen a president govern by tweet, we have never seen a president so ignorant of the machinery of government, of how the federal government works, we have never seen a president continuously attack his political opponents, even on a personal level; we have never seen a president use rhetoric so controversial, so laden with hatred, so populist in the extreme sense of the word — whereby the political opponent is reduced to an anthropologically inferior being and the press is accused of being public enemy number one — in short, a rhetoric that at times recalls that of authoritarian regimes. That a figure of this kind could become president of the United States was simply unthinkable before 2016. And then he is a figure who is genuinely exploring, through his personality, the limits of presidential power in the United States. Many of the scandals that have surrounded Trump would, as a rule, destroy the political career of a member of Congress, or even of an American president, yet Trump seems immune, seems invulnerable to this kind of scandal. It is reminiscent of Silvio Berlusconi's career in Italy — he too was surrounded by scandals that would have ended anyone else's political career, yet he always emerged unscathed. Obviously, though, there is a difference in scale between Italy and the United States, and Trump could prove historic above all if he were to be re-elected.
What do you expect from the 2020 elections?
Let's say that American presidents can be re-elected for two terms of four years, and that's it. As a rule, incumbent presidents start with a big advantage. On top of that, the American economy is doing very well, unemployment is extremely low — we are below 4 per cent —; Trump's electoral base is extremely loyal and satisfied, so under normal circumstances he would be in an absolutely unassailable position. But he is so controversial as a person that he genuinely generates a very strongly felt and very powerful opposition, which makes him more vulnerable than another president in his position would be. That said, he has a good chance of being re-elected. We will have a clearer picture of those chances once the Democratic Party has completed the primary process and selected Trump's challenger.
National polls tend to show Trump ahead against the Democratic challenger, but this means little, first of all because the challenger is not yet known, and also because national polls in the United States count for little: the president is not elected by an absolute majority of voters, but through a complicated system called the electoral college, which assigns a certain number of votes to each of the 50 federal states that make up the USA, proportional to the population of that state. So, for example, California, which is the most populous, has a higher number of votes than Wyoming, which is the least populous; however, as a rule, thanks to this system, it is possible for a president to receive fewer votes than his challenger, yet win the electoral college and become president. That is exactly what happened with Trump in 2016, when he received as many as three million fewer votes than Hillary Clinton, but won in more states and therefore won the presidency.
What does the electoral geography of the United States look like?
From the early 2000s onwards, the electoral geography of the United States has gradually consolidated: we have the west coast, from north to south — Washington state, Oregon and California —; the north-east, that is New York state and all the small states known as New England — Massachusetts, Connecticut, Rhode Island and so on —, which are Democratic. All the states in the interior of the country and above all in the south, on the other hand, are Republican. And then there is a whole series of states that are somewhat in play: Florida is one, Ohio is another, and Trump's great achievement was in recognising that he could win in those states around the Great Lakes region — Michigan, Wisconsin — which traditionally voted Democratic because the working class there was originally very strong, but then weakened with the process of deindustrialisation and relocation; Trump therefore saw an opportunity to win back the vote in those areas with a protectionist, anti-globalist rhetoric. It was a successful operation, even though he won by only 40,000 votes.