Covid-19, WHO says animal-to-human transmission highly likely

Covid-19, WHO says animal-to-human transmission highly likely

Environment · ·

A World Health Organisation report indicates an animal origin for Covid-19 as highly probable.

The transmission of the coronavirus from animals to humans, most likely through an intermediate host, remains the most plausible scenario to explain the spread of Covid-19. By contrast, the escape of the virus from a laboratory would appear to be extremely unlikely. This is what emerges from the new WHO report (World Health Organisation) on the origins of the coronavirus pandemic. Further studies will now be needed to verify all the hypotheses and dispel the – many – doubts that still remain.

Un'immagine dai wet market in Cina
An image from the wet markets in China © Animal Equality

How the WHO report on Covid-19 came about

Seven months after the start of the emergency, in July 2020, the WHO and China began investigating the origins of the coronavirus. An international team of 17 experts from various countries was selected to work alongside an equal-sized team of Chinese professionals. After a period of online meetings, the team conducted a 28-day study from 14 January to 10 February 2021 in the city of Wuhan, China, where the emergency began.

La conferenza stampa per la presentazione del nuovo rapporto dell'Oms
The press conference for the presentation of the new WHO report © Kevin Frayer/Getty Images

The WHO report describes four possible scenarios for Covid-19

According to the experts, there are four possible scenarios that would explain the spread of the pandemic: a direct spillover, meaning the transmission of a zoonotic disease from an animal to a human; a spillover caused by an intermediate animal that passed the virus to humans after itself being infected by the carrier animal; a spread along the frozen food supply chain; and a laboratory accident with a subsequent escape of the virus. The first two hypotheses would appear to be the most likely, especially the second, and the report considers the laboratory theory extremely improbable.

It is worth remembering that the study does not present clear answers, but hypotheses that still need to be fully verified. On this point, WHO Director-General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus has stated that "this report is an important starting point, not a finishing line. We have not yet found the actual source of the virus and we must continue to follow the science, without overlooking any detail."

Il coronavirus visto attraverso un microscopio
The coronavirus seen through a microscope at the CDC, the American Centers for Disease Control and Prevention © Cdc/Getty Images

The coronavirus may have originated from pangolins, bats or intermediate species

Until now, the preliminary hypotheses to have emerged from the WHO's work would therefore appear to confirm the spillover theory, possibly originating from a bat or a pangolin, as reservoir species for this virus. However, as the study clearly states, none of the viruses identified in these mammals is sufficiently similar to Sars-Cov-2 to make it its progenitor. Furthermore, the extreme susceptibility of mink and felines to the virus suggests that another species may have played an intermediate role in its transmission. Scientists also conducted tests on animal products sold at the Huanan market in Wuhan, but found no evidence of animal infections.

The team therefore plans to work backwards to identify the origins of Sars-Cov-2 and does not rule out investigating the trade in animals and their derived products commonly sold in certain markets, also analysing locations that have already been linked to cases of contagion with humans, such as fur farms.

visone in gabbia
Mink farms are cruel to animals and dangerous for our communities © Essere Animali/Flickr

Many questions about Covid-19 remain unresolved

In fact the report neither confirms nor refutes any of the scenarios described to date and does not even provide clarification on the many questions that still remain unanswered. It is not known with certainty where the first case of Covid-19 occurred, how humans were actually infected, and no concrete evidence has been presented that the spillover truly took place at the Huanan market in Wuhan. It is also not known with certainty whether the virus truly came from a bat and, if so, where that bat came from.

The one thing that is certain, according to the WHO, is that Europe is vaccinating its citizens far too slowly: only 10 per cent of the total population of 900 million has received a dose and only 4 per cent has been fully vaccinated. "Vaccines are our best tool for getting out of this pandemic," said Hans Kluge, the WHO's director for the European region. "But the rollout is tremendously slow. We need to speed up the process by increasing the number of companies producing them, reducing the barriers that make administration difficult, and using every single dose we have available. And we need to do it now."

Non si sa ancora con certezza se il coronavirus provenga da un pipistrello
It is still not known with certainty whether the coronavirus originated from a bat © Ingimage

Viruses come from animals, but it is humans who are to blame

After almost a year and a half of emergency, we are thus returning to the initial hypothesis, but as was noted a year ago, it is not animals we should be afraid of, but what we are doing to their habitats. Spillovers do not happen by chance; the right conditions must arise for a virus to manage to break through interspecies barriers and infect another species, animal or human. As Sabrina Giannini has told us, the bat is innocent because "we always tend to blame the animals, even when it is evident that we ourselves are the architects of the problems."

This study joins a long list of analyses that for sixteen months have been desperately highlighting how intensive farming, deforestation, habitat exploitation, uncontrolled agricultural expansion, wild animal trade and the constant growth of human settlements are dangerously bringing our species closer to viruses and bacteria from which nature tries to protect us. Yet, despite a year spent in lockdown, millions of lives lost and enormous economic and social damage, we still struggle to acknowledge the role we ourselves have played in this pandemic. We prefer to believe in conspiracy theories rather than admit that our food and consumption model is the true origin of spillovers.