Pesticides are still far too widespread in agriculture. The figures in two reports

Pesticides are still far too widespread in agriculture. The figures in two reports

Food · ·

A German study and an Italian one are calling on their respective governments to reverse course in order to meet the sustainability targets of the 2030 Agenda. A German study and an Italian one on pesticides are calling on their respective governments to reverse course in order to meet the sustainability targets of the 2030 Agenda.

The Pesticide Atlas 2022 was published a few days ago – a German report on the use of pesticides in agriculture, produced by the Heinrich Böll Foundation, the environmental NGO Bund für umwelt und naturschutz Deutschland (Bund) and the German branch of the Pesticide action network (Pan), which are calling on Germany to reverse course: to steadily reduce pesticide use and ban the most toxic ones, as well as to halt the export of substances banned in the European Union to the growing markets of the Global South.

atlante dei pesticidi
Some pesticides banned in Europe are exported to countries in the Global South © Ingimage

Pesticide Atlas: the figures behind the environmental emergency and the health risks

According to the report, the quantity of pesticides used worldwide has increased by 80 per cent since 1990 and by as much as 150 per cent in South America, where such substances are used extensively, for example in intensive GM soya cultivation. The consequences of pesticide use are wide-ranging: from environmental contamination to the loss of biodiversity in ecosystems, through to the risks to the health of workers who, especially in the Global South, are not adequately protected. There are approximately 255 million poisoning incidents in Asia, just over 100 million in Africa and around 1.6 million in Europe.

"In Europe we use too many pesticides – explained Barbara Unmüßig, president of the Heinrich Böll Foundation – Apples are sprayed around 30 times per season, vines up to 17 times and potatoes up to 11". Reducing their use is essential to tackling the dramatic loss of biodiversity.

atlante dei pesticidi
A graph published in the Pesticide Atlas shows the difference in biodiversity between an organic crop and one where pesticides are used © Pestizidatlas 2022

"High pesticide use contributes to the loss of numerous beneficial organisms, without which even more pesticides are needed," added Olaf Bandt, president of Bund, while Doris Günther, CEO of Pan Germany, wished to highlight the health emergency: "There are 385 million annual pesticide poisonings worldwide – a scandal. German companies export highly dangerous pesticides to Africa, Asia and Latin America that we have banned in Europe to protect people and the environment."

Contamination above threshold levels and with banned substances

The need to halt pesticide use also emerges from the recently published report Stop ai pesticidi 2021 by Legambiente, in collaboration with Alce Nero, which reveals how the presence of plant protection products remains far too widespread in Italian and European food. "It is urgent to approve the organic farming law as soon as possible," the environmental association says, "to adopt the Pan, the National Action Plan for the sustainable use of plant protection products, and a National Strategic Plan for the implementation of the CAP whose primary objective is a sharp reduction in synthetic chemicals in agriculture."

Of the 2,519 food samples of plant origin and beekeeping products – both Italian and foreign – analysed in the dossier, 35 per cent were found to be contaminated – albeit within legal thresholds – with one or more pesticides, while 1.39 per cent of the food samples analysed were irregular. 97 different active substances were found, some highly toxic, such as chlorpyrifos-methyl – whose use was banned by the European Union in 2020 but which continues to be used to counter the effects of the Asian stink bug, with specific exemptions for the most at-risk crops – thiophanate-methyl and mancozeb.

atlante dei pesticidi
Grapes are among the fruits found to be most contaminated by pesticides © Ingimage

In line with the trend of previous years, fruit remains the category with the highest percentage of regular samples containing one or more residues, with traces of at least one active substance present in 53.59 per cent of cases. Within this category, the foods showing the greatest presence of plant protection products are table grapes (85.71 per cent), pears (82.14 per cent), strawberries (71.79 per cent) and peaches (67.39 per cent). These are also the products with the highest multi-residue content. The highest levels of irregularity are instead recorded in samples of citrus fruit (3.47 per cent), small fruit (4.44 per cent) and exotic fruit (3.13 per cent).

In vegetables, a greater proportion of regular, residue-free samples is observed (73.81 per cent), with only a few types showing high quantities of plant protection products, such as tomatoes (60.20 per cent) and peppers (48.15 per cent), which also show the most irregularities. Among processed foods, wine and honey are those with the highest percentages of permitted residues, at around 39.90 per cent and 20 per cent respectively.