Prevention is better than cure, when it comes to fires. The case of Mompantero

Prevention is better than cure, when it comes to fires. The case of Mompantero

Environment · ·

Preventing fires is worthwhile. Moreover, according to Pefc, certified forests are affected by fires up to 9 times less.

Val di Susa, 2017. A series of fires devours 4,000 hectares of meadows and woodland. The largest fire is that of Mompantero, where almost 2,000 hectares of forest are engulfed in flames. The fire is so intense that in some areas 100 per cent of the vegetation disappears.

Val Susa, 2023. Five years have passed since that terrible disaster and LifeGate was invited to the site of the fire to hear about what is being done on the "prevention" front. Because it is a fact that extinguishing a fire costs up to eight times more than preventing one. A warning to bear firmly in mind this summer, marked by new heatwaves. And fires, as Greece is demonstrating in this record-breaking July and as Italy has demonstrated in recent years.

An awareness that public bodies are learning to develop: the proper management of woodlands is, in fact, fundamental to protecting Italy's green heritage from devastating fires. According to Pefc Italia (Pefc stands for Programme for the Endorsement of Forest Certification Schemes), the organisation that promotes the sustainable management of forest resources through its eponymous environmental certification, fire prevention depends on the active management of woodlands: it is the safest and most cost-effective way to protect our green lungs from the destructive force of fire.

incendi-mompantero
The fire that burned almost 2,000 hectares of woodland in Mompantero © Pefc Italia

What is meant by "active management" of woodlands

What is meant by "active management"? "It means enhancing woodlands, managing them, without abandoning them," Giorgio Talachini, owner of La Foresta soc. coop. di Susa, in the province of Turin, tells us — one of the few companies in the area that actually carries out active woodland management on the ground. "For decades we have felled timber with the sole purpose of burning it. Yet there is a 20–30 per cent share of timber that can be used for other purposes, such as in construction. The failure to supply this slice of the market has meant that Italian sawmills no longer exist: all production of this kind has been moved abroad. We import semi-finished products, just as we import firewood. In short, our woodlands are not being put to good use, so we need to reverse this trend."

Building a woodland culture, making people understand that when trunks are felled there is a resource-management plan behind it — this is not about making indiscriminate cuts and nothing more. That is the meaning of Talachini's words. If we see a bulldozer in the forest, then, it does not necessarily mean deforestation is taking place. On the contrary, caring for a woodland means preventing fires, as well as sustaining a commercial sector.

This is where communication comes into play: Pefc Italia has produced detailed information sheets with specific actions that public administrations and private managers must implement to prevent fires. Because to avoid acting only in a state of emergency, it is often enough for local stakeholders to take very simple yet, at the same time, preventive actions capable of drastically reducing the risk of fire in woodlands, forests and urban green areas. Among the possible actions, these five are fundamental:

  1. woodlands at risk of fire must be managed and not left to their own devices: agricultural abandonment is the problem of the Italian forestry sector; felling trees is not a negative event — when done correctly, it in fact helps maintain a balance among the various components of the woodland, fostering the growth of younger trees at the expense of diseased and dry ones (and therefore those most at risk of fire);
  2. the creation of water points and the presence of forest road networks are necessary to intervene promptly in the event of a fire: to this must be added the construction of infrastructure such as helicopter landing points;
  3. the support, training and maintenance of specialist teams in fighting forest fires and forest-fire volunteers is a good practice to be extended across the whole country;
  4. clearing the undergrowth helps keep the problem of fires under control: a well-tended woodland is less susceptible to the spread of flames and, in the same way, meadows and all green areas within urbanised zones must be tended, with tall grass removed regularly. In some regions, moreover, the presence of illegal dumping sites and abandoned waste, including in woodlands, poses a health risk in the event of a fire and can sometimes trigger fires that then spread to natural and forested areas — a further reason to demand the correct disposal of all waste;
  5. launching awareness campaigns aimed at citizens is important so that they are engaged and aware of the fact that woodland not only produces oxygen and absorbs carbon dioxide, but also plays the role of protecting the hydrogeological stability of the land. Reminding citizens of the safety rules to be observed when in a woodland is important for preventing fires caused by negligence.

Zero-cost forest fire prevention: the virtuous case of the PRe-FEu project

All this attention to prevention and active management has been channelled into a project funded by the Piedmont Rural Development Programme (Psr): the project is called PRe-FEu, an acronym standing for fire prevention for timber supply chains, launched in the Val di Susa in 2020 with the aim of mitigating the risk of fire and enhancing the timber resource.

One of the keys to the project is creating preventive green infrastructure that achieves an economy of scale capable of ensuring the long-term economic sustainability of that infrastructure in terms of efficiency. "The intervention stems from the need to make Alpine valleys safer — valleys that in some cases present a high fire risk due to the continuity and uniformity of forest formations and a potential for the development of large fires, spreading across considerable areas, in years of extreme drought," explains Roberta Berretti, researcher at the Department of Agricultural, Forestry and Food Sciences (Disafa) at the University of Turin. The integrated vision of PRe-FEu places soil and biodiversity conservation, water quality, timber supply understood as a raw material, climate mitigation, support for firefighting activities and economic sustainability all on an equal footing.

To achieve this, the project (which involves a range of actors, including the Consorzio forestale Alta val Susa, the municipal unions in Val Susa, the La Foresta cooperative, Disafa, the Piedmont Region's forest fire system, local forestry firms and sawmills, and landowner associations) works on a pilot area of around 1,000 hectares in the lower Val di Susa, certified to Pefc standards, where fire prevention is being trialled through the use of green barriers composed of varied and diversified tree species relative to the surrounding woodland.

press-tour-pefc
The Pefc press tour in which LifeGate also took part © Pefc Italia

Mompantero and the management of burned woodland

Prevention is not only relevant to areas at risk of fire, but also to those already burned. In October 2017, the woodland of Mompantero, in the Val di Susa, was struck by a huge fire that affected around 2,000 hectares of woodland and meadow. The La Foresta cooperative carried out the timber salvage of 30,000 cubic metres, building purpose-made trailers designed to pass along the narrow roads leading up to Rocciamelone, where the highest sanctuary in Europe stands — a destination for intense pilgrimage.

"October is not a fire season, but it came after a scorching summer, one of the hottest in the past 70 years. During that period, for the first time, Piedmont found itself having to manage 9,700 hectares of fires", are the figures listed by Berretti. An exceptional event, with different characteristics depending on the forest affected. The most dramatic fire was the one concentrated at Mompantero, where 100 per cent of vegetation disappeared in some areas, but the fire was more extensive and involved a strip of forest stretching from Bussoleno to Venaus, totalling 4,000 hectares, of which 2,500 were forested.

After the institutions intervened to contain the emergency, the time came for post-fire management. And for prevention in the years ahead: "The innovative aspect was leaving the necromass (i.e. dead wood) in place, to maintain some shaded areas. The starting point is that nature has the potential to recover on its own, so management means assessing in which areas to let the natural process take its course and where to intervene instead — for example by replanting trees", explains Berretti. Five years on from that fire, the maintenance work at the site is not yet complete. But should it happen again in this area, things would go differently and the fire could be kept under control: "this is part of what is known as preventive silviculture: we cannot eliminate the risk of fire, but we can certainly reduce it. And it can be done by changing the dynamics of fire".

Inadequate funding

Active management and monitoring of forest heritage are fundamental strategies for limiting fire risk and protecting forests, but unfortunately they still do not receive adequate funding. Last year, Western Europe was hit by a wave of wildfires caused by the August heatwave and prolonged drought conditions. These fires caused the emission of a record 6.4 billion tonnes of CO2, the highest level in summer months since 2007. Italy too had a difficult summer in 2022, with 451 fires that destroyed 58,751 hectares of woodland.

To counter this emergency, the European Union announced that it would double the capacity of its rescUE firefighting fleet, increasing the number of aircraft from 13 to 28.

vigili-fuoco-valsusa
A firefighting operation at Mompantero, 2017 © Vigili del fuoco

Certified forests burn less

Planning therefore consists of active management and prevention. The concept of adaptive silviculture is new but is establishing itself as a necessity. Forests not only guarantee hydrogeological balance and produce oxygen, but also store large quantities of CO2. When fires destroy these forests, large quantities of greenhouse gases and fine particulates are released into the atmosphere, causing irreparable damage to the environment.

Forests that are consciously managed and certified for sustainable forest management are affected by fires up to nine times less than non-certified areas. Pefc Italia highlights that managed and certified forests have a far lower probability of being affected by fires compared to non-certified ones. Analysing the events of 2017, the year in which fires struck the country hard, only 0.24 per cent of the certified area burned, while 1.24 per cent of the non-certified area was affected by fires.

The lower incidence of fires in certified areas is attributed to constant monitoring, prevention measures and better accessibility. Seventy-five per cent of fires are caused by irresponsible human actions, as well as climate change, but only 18 per cent of Italian forests are certified.

Fire prevention is a shared responsibility and requires a constant commitment from everyone, from administrators to citizens. Only through conscious and active forest management and greater awareness will it be possible to protect Italy's forest heritage from devastating fires and preserve the environment for future generations.

We thank Pefc Italia for inviting us on the press tour to Mompantero, from which this content was born.