From Mani Tese, an award to expose unsustainable fashion

From Mani Tese, an award to expose unsustainable fashion

Environment · ·

After the success of its first edition, Mani Tese launches its second investigative journalism award. Dedicated, this year, to the theme of unsustainable fashion.

There is time until 4 May 2020 (a deadline extended from the original 23 April) to submit one's application for the Award for investigative and social journalism, promoted by the non-governmental organisation Mani Tese and dedicated to investigating the impact of the clothing industry on human rights and the environment. The objective is to expose an illegal activity or an injustice, but also a particularly significant good practice in the sector. The winner will receive an expenses reimbursement of up to 10,000 euros for the production of the investigation, made possible again this year by funding from the Italian Agency for Development Cooperation (Aics).

💡 #GetSapienza #manca1mese! "Premio @ManiTese", concorso che premia le migliori inchieste sull’impatto delle imprese sui diritti umani e sull’ambiente realizzate da giornalisti #studentiSapienza e #laureatiSapienza

To evaluate the proposals, as in the first edition, a jury made up of prominent journalists will be formed: Gad Lerner, Gianluigi Nuzzi, Tiziana Ferrario, Eva Giovannini, Francesco Piccinini, Stefania Prandi, Emilio Ciarlo, Margherita Rebuffoni. For this edition two new names are added to the list: Federica Angeli, under police protection for her investigations into the Roman mafia, and Riccardo Iacona, host of the investigative programme Presa Diretta. On the proposal of one of the jury members, the award will be presented by Nadia Toffa's mother, in memory of the young journalist from the programme Le Iene, who passed away last year.

Fast fashion in Mani Tese's sights

The award is part of the work that Mani Tese has been carrying out for years to denounce the injustices of the fashion sector, particularly fast fashion. It is an unsustainable system, but unfortunately a very widespread one, in which human rights violations, economic exploitation and environmental crimes are the order of the day. It is a system built on a relationship of economic dominance by the West over producing countries in the Global South. On global supply chains that over time have shifted responsibility from commissioning brands to end suppliers, from international fashion houses to workers without rights or guarantees, paid by the day and at risk of enslavement, in countries such as Bangladesh, India and Vietnam.

moda mani tese
A clothing warehouse. The association Mani Tese will award a journalistic investigation into unsustainable fashion © Peter Macdiarmid/Getty Images

The problems are plain to see: even today, in the emergency caused by the Covid-19 pandemic, there are accounts of workers leaving the Indian cities where they work to return, by any means available, to their rural areas of origin. This is also the reality for workers in the fashion industry: if they do not work, they do not earn. With no social safety net, no protection, no rights whatsoever. In India, the real risk is hunger.

Read also: Dall'esodo dei lavoratori migranti ai soprusi da parte della polizia: l'India ai tempi del coronavirus

Giosuè De Salvo, Head of Advocacy, Education and Campaigns at Mani Tese, explains that the textile sector offers fertile ground for triggering change, because it touches people's everyday lives. Moreover, being among the largest sectors in the world, even small gains can bring enormous benefits. Over the years the organisation has championed the cause of the most vulnerable, seeking to act at an international level against exploitation.

But above all by raising greater awareness among consumers. In addition to the interactive exhibition Fashion Experience, staged in 2019 in Milan, the initiative "Cambia Moda!" is now active, with the aim of encouraging people to shop more responsibly, choosing quality over the quantity of items purchased and prioritising respect for workers' rights and the environment. To help even younger people understand what lies behind the clothes they wear, Mani Tese offers global citizenship education courses aimed at schools as well.

Why an investigative journalism award of this kind is needed

The investment required to organise the journalism award is considerable, but Mani Tese explains that it is genuinely convinced of the value of the project. Especially after the success of the first edition, which led to the identification of a highly significant case of waste and, above all, to the launch of a process to amend the legislative provision that was permitting this injustice. According to De Salvo, the world of NGOs and that of journalism have much in common and can work together perfectly: both represent a "service". But they must also guard against the risk of becoming "in the service of" an unsustainable system.

🧥Qual è il vero costo #sociale e #ambientale di un capo di #abbigliamento pagato pochi euro?
👉Scopritelo visitando il nuovo portale Cambia MODA! cambiamoda.manitese.it
Realizzato da @ManiTese in collaborazione con @IstitutoOikos e @GuardavantiOng, con il contributo di @aics_it

"Organisations provide services that are useful in guaranteeing rights and making up for the shortcomings of the system, wherever there are injustices or mechanisms that do not work. But if these activities continue to be carried out without questioning the reality of things and the upstream mechanisms that cause injustices, then NGOs too find themselves in the service of an unsustainable system. We believe the key lies in dismantling these mechanisms, in questioning the system," reflects De Salvo. Ideally, then, reaching a point at which the work of organisations like his own will become superfluous.

A wholly analogous argument applies to journalism as well. "Where the world is reported through news and current affairs, journalism certainly provides a useful service. But when it settles down, stops being critical and stops questioning what it is reporting, then it becomes journalism in the service of the system," concludes De Salvo. Hence the need for investigative journalism in the public interest, aimed at exposing unlawful activities or practices that, while lawful, are ethically questionable.

Amazon's waste at the centre of the first edition's investigation

Such is the case of the investigation funded by last year's award, entitled "Amazon, uno smaltimento al di sopra di ogni sospetto", thanks to which a team of journalists identified a mechanism that was leading the e-commerce giant to unacceptable levels of waste. Enormous quantities of unsold goods, still in perfect condition, destroyed rather than returned to the seller or donated to charity: disposal as the most convenient route. The bitter irony is that Amazon's behaviour was entirely legal. The company, like the other players in the supply chain, was not breaking any law but was exploiting outdated rules and e-commerce legislation dating back to the late 1990s. Thanks to the investigation and the resonance it found in the national media, the Lazio Region recently approved an amendment to a regional law, with the specific aim of promoting "the reduction of waste linked to the destruction of damaged returns and unsold goods".

Redistribuire i beni invenduti invece di distruggerli: la @RegioneLazio si impegnerà a favorire “la riduzione degli #sprechi legati alla #distruzione dei resi danneggiati e dei beni invenduti”. Un primo risultato dell'inchiesta su #Amazon: roma.fanpage.it/con-una-nuova-…
#AmazonDestroy

At the same time, in front of the cameras of "Presa Diretta", the head of the Ministry of the Environment's General Directorate for Waste and Pollution, Sergio Cristofanelli, expressed his support for a revision of the law to reduce waste. It is now up to civil society, and Mani Tese in the first instance, to monitor future developments through actions to scrutinise and oversee the conduct of the public authorities. Together with journalists.