ClientEarth and Eeb take stock one year after the introduction of the European plan to ban seven thousand hazardous substances: there is still much to be done.
In 2022, the European Union announced a roadmap to ban the use and trade of thousands of chemical substances hazardous to the environment and human health.
After one year, very little has been done and the chemical industry lobby is putting spokes in the wheel.
Exactly one year ago, the European Union launched a roadmap to ban over seven thousand chemical substances hazardous to health and the environment that are currently on the market, by 2030. Despite the extensive media coverage the news received, that plan is, in fact, failing. This is the claim made by environmental organisation ClientEarth and the European Environmental Bureau (Eeb), a network of 170 organisations, in a joint press release. The European roadmap had in fact planned to ban:
the most harmful flame retardants: chemical substances often linked to the onset of cancer, yet present in the majority of homes;
all bisphenols, which can have a serious impact on human fertility and are handled on a daily basis by most Europeans, being present in bottles, toys and many other objects;
all non-essential Pfas: chemical compounds considered "eternal", known in fact as forever chemicals, because they take hundreds of years to break down in the environment and cause liver damage, thyroid disease, obesity, fertility problems and cancer. Pfas are already everywhere: in the United States, traces of Pfas have even been found in the blood of almost all Americans, while a recently published report has shown that over 17,000 sites across Europe are now permanently contaminated.
finally, around two thousand harmful chemical substances used in nappies, dummies and baby products.
Which chemical substances have not yet been banned
One year on, the review published by Eeb shows that hundreds of tonnes of toxic substances are still evading bans. In particular:
only five of the 148 bisphenols identified will actually be restricted. Recently, moreover, officials at Echa (European Chemicals Agency) announced that the average citizen is exposed to unsafe levels of Bpa, that is bisphenol A, calling for a reduction in the daily intake limit of as much as 20,000 units;
lead shot, commonly used in hunting ammunition and shooting sports as well as in fishing equipment. It is estimated that, as a result of such uses, approximately 44,000 tonnes of this metal are dispersed into the European environment every year, causing the poisoning of wildlife species such as birds (lead can also compromise human health when present as a residue in hunted game). Echa has proposed a reduction in lead shot, but the Commission has so far banned it only in wetlands;
chemical substances with "very serious" risk levels present in nappies for babies: a concern affecting 90 per cent of European infants, and despite Echa having acknowledged the existence of these substances, the Commission has not yet banned them.
More broadly, the organisations criticise the slow progress made so far, to the point that "regulatory gaps" have emerged and several deadlines have been missed. For instance, it took two and a half years to restrict Pfas in skin-sensitising substances, and more than a year to regulate microplastics added to exfoliating creams. The study also highlights the scarce resources made available to officials working on these regulatory processes and the lack of data sharing on the part of companies.
When it comes to Pfas, the delays are even more evident. It took 20 years, in fact, to arrive at a draft list to restrict the use of these chemical compounds. The Stockholm Convention, published in 2001, regulates the use of certain persistent organic pollutants, including numerous chemical compounds from the Pfas family. In the years that followed, various bans were introduced, ranging from the use of perfluorooctane sulfonic acid (Pfos), employed mainly for fabrics, carpets and paper, to the ban on producing, importing and exporting perfluorooctanoic acids (Pfoa), used as waterproofing coatings.
Yet at the European level, work is still ongoing to integrate the Stockholm Convention: at present, there are only five countries that have put forward a proposal for more stringent restrictions on Pfas: Sweden, Norway, Denmark, the Netherlands and Germany. The reason for these delays, according to activists, lies within the industrial and chemical sector lobbies, which are investing heavily to course-correct and protect their own interests. Some time ago, companies had already raised their shields against the revision of Reach, the Registration, Evaluation, Authorisation and Restriction of Chemicals regulation adopted by the EU in 2006.
For the lobbies, chemicals are necessary for the transition
Yet the chemical substances to which European citizens are exposed are constantly increasing, and by 2050 their production will have more than tripled compared to 1950 levels. According to Hélène Duguy, legal and policy adviser at ClientEarth, Europe is displaying "the failure of a piecemeal EU approach to chemical bans". This means that "people and our environment are not protected from the most harmful chemicals. The European authorities and the Commission have all the legal tools to act."
And now industries are using the transition as a justification: American chemical company Chemours told the Financial Times that chemicals are necessary in the production of electric batteries and green hydrogen. The company is facing a lawsuit in California, where it is accused of having produced Pfas for decades despite being aware that these substances caused developmental problems, tumours and other conditions. Prosecutors are seeking compensation of hundreds of millions of dollars to clean up the contaminated areas.
But on one point Chemours is right, Eeb argues: if alternatives to the Pfas used in electric batteries are not found, it is highly likely that these substances will never be banned. Continuing to pollute forever.
The European plan to ban hazardous chemicals is failing
Environment — di Maurizio Bongioanni
ClientEarth and Eeb take stock one year after the introduction of the European plan to ban seven thousand hazardous substances: there is still much to be done.