The Pan Europe Consumer Guide 2021 has drawn up a list of vegetables, classifying them from red to green according to the presence of pesticide residues.
Vegetables are allies of good health, but when they contain pesticide residues they can become a threat to our wellbeing. Exposure to these synthetic chemical substances can, in fact, sometimes disrupt our hormonal system, on which many other vital functions depend, such as, for example, those of the reproductive system.
Vegetables classified according to the presence of pesticide residues
The Pesticide action network Europe, a network of European non-governmental organisations that promotes sustainable alternatives to pesticides, has produced the Pan Europe consumer guide 2021. It is a useful tool for consumers to know how to shop while avoiding, as much as possible, vegetables in which pesticides suspected of being endocrine disruptors are present. The European guide also explains how these substances can potentially harm health and how to avoid them.
Chemical substances that can interfere with hormonal activity are found in many commonly used products, such as food grown with pesticides, for example. This interference, if prolonged over time, can even trigger chronic conditions. Research has identified the five pesticides considered most at risk: Boscalid, which is associated with thyroid damage; Dithiocarbamates, which can cause tumours and damage to the reproductive system; Tebuconazole, which could cause foetal malformations and kidney damage; Iprodione, potentially responsible for reproductive problems; and finally, 2,4-D, accused of having negative effects on the endocrine glands and even causing fertility problems. Added to this, according to Pan's research, is a dangerous cocktail effect of the same substances, arising from the sum of multiple simultaneous exposures to pesticide residues.
Vegetables divided into three colour-coded lists
The guide therefore divides fruit and vegetables into three categories using data from the latest Efsa (European food safety authority) report on pesticide monitoring. On the basis of this information, it draws up a red list of high-risk foods likely to contain pesticides suspected of being endocrine disruptors (40–70 per cent of the product with pesticide residues), a yellow list of medium-risk vegetables (10–40 per cent of the product with pesticide residues), and finally a green list of generally safe products (less than 10 per cent of the product with pesticide residues). For each food, the country of origin is also indicated based on the presence of residues, along with the highest figure with respect to the pesticide cocktail.
Here is what to choose for safe shopping
On the red list, one finds, for example, lamb's lettuce from Belgium and Germany, cherries from Chile, pears from Portugal, and strawberries from Greece. On the yellow list are foods that represent a middle ground between those to avoid and those that can be consumed freely, and they include blackberries, grapes, carrots, blueberries, plums, celery, radishes, raspberries, spinach, tomatoes, oranges, kiwi fruit, beans, peppers and bananas. Finally, foods free from potentially hazardous residues, featured on the green list, are: white cabbage, broccoli, garlic, rice, aubergines, mandarins, cucumbers, cauliflower, courgettes, mango, onions, watermelon, pineapple, sweetcorn, cereals, olives, potatoes and avocado.
The guide also suggests ways to limit exposure to the controversial substances that may be present in vegetables: first and foremost, where possible, by purchasing only organically grown produce. If sourcing an organic product is a problem, the products on the red list should be avoided and replaced with products from the green list. For the yellow list, the advice is to try nonetheless to supplement it (or better still replace it entirely) with products from the green list. This is especially important during pregnancy, since even the smallest amount of exposure to pesticides suspected of being endocrine disruptors can be a problem for the foetus.
Further recommendations include washing fruit and vegetables before bringing them to the table; peeling vegetables and fruit if they are not organic, even though this only helps to remove residues on the skin and not those inside the vegetable; paying attention to provenance, since there are many differences between countries of origin and those with the worst track records should be avoided. And finally, as a general rule: avoiding foods on the red list.
Pesticides: a guide reveals which vegetables get a red, yellow or green rating
Food — di Elisabetta Pina
The Pan Europe Consumer Guide 2021 has drawn up a list of vegetables, classifying them from red to green according to the presence of pesticide residues.