Pesticides: why Europe and the CAP are falling behind

Pesticides: why Europe and the CAP are falling behind

Environment · ·

European countries have failed to reduce pesticide use sufficiently, partly due to the CAP. The Court of Auditors has confirmed it.

In February 2020, the European Court of Auditors published its special report number 5. Entitled "Sustainable use of plant protection products: limited progress in measuring and reducing risks", the document explains that progress in terms of both monitoring and reducing the hazards — to health and to the environment — associated with the use of pesticides has been insufficient in recent years. Despite the promises. The main reason? The Common Agricultural Policy, which is supposed to regulate the work of farmers across all member states, has not been stringent enough. But to understand the reason behind this criticism, a brief step back is needed.

The @EUauditors conclude that the @EU_Commission still lacks a robust evidence base to assess whether the directive has achieved the EU’s objective of making pesticide use sustainable.

The report➡️ europa.eu/!kk98Xh

The 2009 directive on the sustainable use of pesticides

As is well known, plant protection products (pesticides) are used to protect crops from harmful organisms, pests and diseases. They include insecticides, fungicides and herbicides. These can be harmful to the environment, as well as to human health. For this reason, many of them have been banned over time. The European Union has had (since 1991) common rules for authorising the placing on the market of such products. In 2009, a directive on the sustainable use of pesticides was then adopted.

Progress towards measuring and reducing risks from pesticide use in the #EU has been limited, according to our new report 👇

The act established a "framework for Community action" on the matter. For its implementation, National Action Plans (NAPs) were defined, detailing the objectives, measures, timescales and indicators used to "measure" the reduction of risks. Italy, for example, adopted its NAP through the interministerial decree of 22 January 2014, which promotes more sustainable practices in the use of plant protection products and provides guidance on reducing the impact of plant protection products in agricultural areas, non-agricultural areas (urban green spaces, roads, railways) and protected natural areas.

The negative verdict of the European Court of Auditors

The Court of Auditors was asked precisely to assess whether such Community actions had been effective or not. The response of the European Union's financial oversight body, last February, was decidedly negative. "Progress," the report reads, "has been limited. Several member states transposed the provisions of the sustainable use of pesticides directive late, while farmers still have little incentive to adopt alternative methods. In addition, the European Commission is not in a position to precisely monitor the effects or risks associated with such products."

pesticidi francia consiglio costituzionale
Spraying pesticides on an agricultural field © David McNew/Getty Images

For this reason, the Court had recommended new, harder-to-circumvent measures in the new Common Agricultural Policy, for the period 2021–2027. Within the framework of the Green Deal, the Commission itself had indeed announced its intention to introduce quantitative targets for pesticide reduction. The problem, however, is that in the name of the subsidiarity principle, it is up to each member state to adopt concrete means to achieve the result.

"Practical and measurable criteria are needed"

What is to be done, then? The Court recalled that European regulations have required farmers, since 2014, to resort to preventive, physical or biological methods to protect crops. "This means," the audit body explained, "that plant protection products should only be used when other methods employed have proved ineffective." Checks, however, are scarce. For this reason, the same institution had asked the Commission to "ensure that member states translate the general principles of integrated pest management into practical and measurable criteria." And it had asked that these be incorporated into the new CAP.

The latter was approved in October 2020. After the EU's legislative and executive powers had come under strong pressure from agro-industrial and pesticide lobbies, according to an analysis by Nina Holland, Martin Pigeon and Hans van Scharen, researchers at the non-governmental organisation Corporate Europe Observatory. And in particular from Copa-Cogeca, which reportedly "exerted its influence in an attempt to weaken all the environmental measures contained in the text."

Criticism of the new Common Agricultural Policy

The result is a text that was considered disappointing by the Good Food Good Farming group, which represents 400 non-governmental organisations across Europe. The Green Deal itself and the European Farm to Fork strategy appear more ambitious, having previously set two far-reaching objectives. The first is a 50 per cent reduction in pesticide use by 2030. The second is to ensure that, by the same date, a quarter of European land is farmed according to organic criteria.

Pesticidi
According to a recent study, pesticide mixtures can be harmful even when the limits for individual substances are respected © Ingimage

The CAP 2021–2027 does, however, introduce the so-called eco-schemes: bonuses awarded to farmers who take part in environmental programmes with more demanding standards. At least 30 per cent of European transfers to farmers must be compulsorily allocated to these schemes. Will this be enough to ensure that the sector adopts systems compatible with the protection of the climate, the environment and health? A reminder that health is one and the same, for human beings and for the Planet.