Intelligent, alert and with a good memory. A book explores the personality of the bee

Intelligent, alert and with a good memory. A book explores the personality of the bee

Culture & lifestyle · ·

Bees play a fundamental role for our planet. In his book, Stephen Buchmann takes us on a journey of discovery into their world.

Are bees insects capable of remembering, learning, communicating and dreaming? Stephen Buchmann, ecologist and entomologist, takes us on a journey of discovery into a very particular universe: that of bees. With his book La personalità dell'ape (Edizioni Ambiente, 2024), the author invites us to explore the extraordinary complexity of these pollinators, fundamental to the balance of ecosystems yet threatened by human activities. We spoke with him.

libro la personalità dell'ape
Stephen Buchmann's book © Edizioni ambiente

What is the true personality of the bee? What are the things we don't know about their world that we should know?
Some time ago, a famous biologist wondered what it would be like to be a bat and use echolocation to explore their world. He ultimately concluded that it would be impossible. In the same way, we cannot know what a bee sees, hears or perceives. We can only test their reactions and observe their behaviour under certain circumstances to get an idea of their perceptions, which are drastically different from our human "umwelt" — our subjective experience of the world. Bees of the same species look very similar to one another, but we can tell them apart by applying small dots of coloured paint. By observing the behaviour of bees marked in this way, unique and distinctive characteristics emerge. Some bees are "lazy" and make fewer trips in search of pollen and nectar, while others can learn a task much more quickly (or not learn it at all) compared to their companions. Ultimately, we can only imagine what the world of bees is truly like.

One of the chapters in the book is entitled "As intelligent as a bee". How does their brain work?
Bees are intelligent creatures, capable of learning and remembering events for periods ranging from a few hours to their entire lives. The brain of a honey bee, with a volume of around 1 mm³ and approximately 800,000 neurons, is minuscule compared to the 86–100 billion neurons of the human brain. Despite the small size of their brain — comparable to a poppy seed — bees demonstrate an incredible cognitive capacity: they are sentient, they feel pain, they recognise shapes and they learn. They can navigate mazes and learn how to interact with flowers of different shapes, colours, scents and sizes to find hidden nectar and pollen.

Are they capable of dreaming or remembering?
Bees are capable of remembering. They memorise the colour, scent, size and shapes of the flowers they visit, and are able to recognise geometric shapes and even human faces. So, if you are a beekeeper, be kind — the bees will remember you on your next visit! Bees, such as honey bees, sleep for long periods both during the day and at night. While sleeping, they hang by their front legs in characteristic positions. They pass through several sleep stages: at first they move their antennae, then they become still and the antennae stop moving. We do not know whether bees dream. I like to imagine that they are capable of dreaming of vast expanses of flowers. What we do know, however, is that during sleep bees consolidate the memories of their days.

How does a bee behave when approaching a flower? Let's talk about smell, sight and colour.
Insects like bees are rather short-sighted, with vision approximately sixty times less sharp than that of humans. In flight, they perceive a blurred patch of colour that they identify as a flower or a cluster of flowers, but they cannot make out details until they come within about 25–27 cm. Only at this distance can they see patterns and fine details. Bees have trichromatic vision, detecting three primary colours as humans do, but with one difference: they perceive green, blue and ultraviolet (which we, except in rare cases, cannot see). They often approach flowers from a downwind position to pick up their scent, and follow the sweet fragrance with a zigzagging flight. The sense of smell in bees is comparable to our own, with a similar threshold for perceiving scents.

When we think of bees, we usually think of Apis mellifera, a social bee. Yet, reading your book, we discover that social bees are not the most common — solitary bees are far more numerous.
Depending on the taxonomist consulted, there are between seven and eleven species of honey bee belonging to the genus Apis, native to south-east Asia. Beekeepers have spread them throughout the world, excluding Antarctica, for their role as pollinators and honey producers. Globally, around 21,000 species of bee are known: some 4,000 are found in the United States and around 1,100 in Italy. Besides honey bees, other social bees include stingless bees, which live in the tropics, and bumblebees, with around 250 species, found mainly in China.

Approximately ninety per cent of the world's bees are solitary. After mating, females dig their own nest without assistance, make numerous trips to collect pollen and nectar — mass provisioning — to form pea-sized balls in which they lay a single egg. Once the offspring leave the cells, these bees have no further contact with them. I like to think of these bees as "single mothers" with a family to feed.

api accoppiamento
Male bees adopt various mating strategies © Bruce Taubert

How do they choose a partner and how does reproduction take place? Some even mate in flight.
Male bees adopt various mating strategies. Many emerge from the ground or from twigs and seek out virgin females nearby, while others congregate around flowers. In Arizona, the male of Centris pallida, a solitary bee, emits a mating call that is believed to ensure paternity of the offspring. If the female is deprived of this, she will mate with another. Honey bees also have a remarkable system: males gather in specific areas at 30–40 metres in height, known as drone congregation areas. After mating, the males lose their genitalia inside the queen and fall to the ground, dying. The queen bee can then lay up to 1,000 eggs per day.

Bees are masters of nest-building, in which they also use flowers, leaves or pollen. How do they do it?
These insects are true master architects. Honey bees transform the sugars in nectar into wax by chewing it and adding salivary enzymes. The perfect geometry of the honeycomb is not due to any knowledge of geometry, but to a process called stigmergy. Bees accumulate small heaps of wax, to which other bees add more, and which, with the heat of the hive (34–38°C), are transformed into perfect hexagons without any direct intervention by the bees. Other bee species use different techniques, such as leafcutter bees, which create casings for pollen, nectar and eggs from pieces of leaf. Mason bees, on the other hand, build linear cells using mud to create dividers between the larvae, while others (Osmia spp.) also make their nests inside abandoned snail shells.

What role do bees play in ecosystems and in our societies? Why is it important to protect them?
Bees are pollinators and must be protected at all costs. Around one third of the human diet depends on their pollination activity, which they do not carry out as a service to humanity. It happens while they collect pollen and nectar for their own nourishment, accidentally transferring pollen from one flower to another. Furthermore, bees are part of the food chain, preyed upon by ants, spiders, lizards, birds and mammals. Ground-nesting bees also help to improve soil quality through bioturbation and fertilisation with their faeces. Our existence is closely bound to their presence and activity.

Why did you decide to study bees, and do you have a particular memory of these animals?
I began studying insects in third grade, driven by my love of nature and my desire to be outdoors. I have fond memories of studying native bees in the Sonoran Desert in Arizona with the late John Alcock of Arizona State University. My favourite bee genus is Centris, known for its fascinating mating biology. I can't imagine studying any other animals, except perhaps dinosaur fossils.

At the end of the book you list several actions that people can take to protect bees. What are the most important ones each of us can do?
To protect bees, avoid or use insecticides and herbicides sparingly, spraying at night when bees are not active. Also, plant with pollinators in mind, choosing native plants and avoiding hybrids from large garden centres, which often offer few floral rewards. In addition, you can join a conservation organisation and become a bee observer, reporting your sightings to platforms such as BugGuide and iNaturalist, which is also available in Italy.

Leave dead branches and trees as nurseries for bees and wasps, which will make use of the galleries created by beetles. Female bees, such as leafcutter or mason bees, which are often unable to excavate their own galleries in wood, will frequently move into them. You can also build a "bee hotel" at home by drilling holes (generally 7–8 mm in diameter and around five centimetres deep) into blocks of recycled wood and positioning them under the eaves, offering a shelter for female bees in spring and autumn. These actions will help to protect and support pollinators, giving you and your family many hours of enjoyment.