Why Scorsese will no longer make the Frank Sinatra film

Why Scorsese will no longer make the Frank Sinatra film

Culture & lifestyle · ·

The director has thrown in the towel and definitively shelved the biographical film project about Frank Sinatra, which had been in the pipeline for eight years.

It has been talked about since 2009, with Leonardo DiCaprio and Al Pacino in the roles of the young and the old Sinatra respectively, and Robert De Niro as Dean Martin. But the film about the life of Frank Sinatra directed by Martin Scorsese, with Michael Chabon, Billy Ray or Phil Alden Robinson on the screenplay, will not be made. The announcement was made to the Toronto Sun by the director himself, during the promotion of his latest feature film Silence.

Martin Scorsese all'anteprima di Silence ha parlato della sua rinuncia al biopic su Frank Sinatra
Martin Scorsese at the premiere of Silence in Los Angeles, 5 January 2017 © JB Lacroix/WireImage

Martin Scorsese is said to have received criticism and objections from the Sinatra clan over the direction the story had taken, particularly regarding certain details about the private life of the legendary singer and actor that would have brought his darker sides to light — aspects long considered taboo in official biographies. After multiple discussions and revisions to the script, the director of, among others, No direction home about Bob Dylan and Shine a light about the Rolling Stones officially withdrew from the project:

We can't do it, they wouldn't approve it. Certain things are difficult for a family, and I completely understand that. But if they want me to make the film, they need to know that I can't hide certain things. Frank Sinatra was a complex character, far more complex than an ordinary person.

Frank Sinatra sorride con l'amico Dean Martin
Frank Sinatra and Dean Martin on the set of Ocean's Eleven, 1960 © Mondadori Portfolio via Getty Images

The light and shadow of Sinatra in a biopic

Scorsese had already spoken about the difficulties of portraying a character like The Voice in a previous interview. "I can't make a film in which I only tell the glorious moments of Sinatra's life, his greatest hits," he had said. But this time the director of The Aviator and Goodfellas, who is certainly not one to give up easily (it took him 26 years to bring the epic Silence to the screen), has had to reckon with Sinatra's heirs.

Frank's relatives had "rubber-stamped" the biopic eight years ago, even with a certain enthusiasm. Tina Sinatra had said:

My father greatly admired the talent of the people he chose to work with, and the talented people who worked with him had great admiration for my father. I am personally satisfied that this paradigm is repeating itself, with Martin Scorsese leading the charge on the film about Sinatra's life.

They may therefore have had second thoughts, perhaps after watching Alex Gibney's 2015 documentary Sinatra: All or nothing at all, which highlights some ambiguous and controversial aspects of the man.

Frank Sinatra con i boss della mafia nel 1976
Frank Sinatra in his dressing room with Gregory DePalma, Thomas Marson, Carlo Gambino, Jimmy Fratiano and (obscured) Richard Fusco, all defendants in a Mafia trial in New York in 1976 © Getty Images

Frank Sinatra, who radically transformed the image of the Italian-American, was a fervent activist against the racial discrimination campaign that swept America in the 1950s. He supported and included his friend, the Black musician Sammy Davis Jr., in the celebrated group the Rat Pack alongside Dean Martin, Peter Lawford and Joey Bishop, with whom he performed in Las Vegas. The singer took part in charitable endeavours and frequently visited the poorest countries on the planet.

His intense artistic and philanthropic activity was, however, overshadowed by scandals and vices, including alcohol, gambling and affairs with women. But, above all, by his constant ties — never confirmed — with the Mafia and with influential politicians, from the Kennedy family to President Nixon, not always for lawful ends.

Cover image: Frank Sinatra at the Academy Awards in 1955 © Earl Leaf/Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images