Pay by result: how our welfare system could truly change

Pay by result: how our welfare system could truly change

Environment · ·

From English prisons, pay-by-result tools could land in Italy — and support the rehabilitation of inmates even when public coffers are struggling.

An innovative, inclusive welfare system that truly works undoubtedly costs money. In many cases it costs far too much for state budgets, which are already grappling with the costs of basic services. In such cases, private capital can come into play — and perhaps make a real difference. This can happen with the help of ad hoc financial instruments such as pay-by-result bonds: instruments already tested in the United Kingdom that are beginning to attract growing interest in our country as well.

How the "pay by result" model works

A social impact bond based on the "pay by result" model is a bond through which the public sector raises private investment to pay providers of welfare services. As with ordinary bonds, anyone who purchases a social impact bond is entitled, at a set maturity date, to receive back the capital lent plus an interest payment. The difference, however, is that the return on the invested capital is tied to the achievement of a specific social outcome. This rests on a single principle: solving a social problem means avoiding a cost for society. It is precisely this saving that puts public administrations in a position to remunerate investors.

The first experiment was British and dates back to 2010. To support the rehabilitation of 3,000 inmates at Peterborough Prison, seventeen investors purchased social impact bonds worth £5 million — accepting, in doing so, to receive payment only if the reoffending rate fell by 7.5 per cent.

Alla @camcomroma, presentazione dello studio dedicato ai #socialimpactbond per reinserimento persone detenute con @HUMANFdn

Social impact bonds on the agenda at the Ministry of Justice

In recent months, a working group has begun examining the feasibility of adopting pay-by-result bonds in Italy as well, to support innovative programmes for the social and professional rehabilitation of inmates. The result is the feasibility study "L'applicazione di strumenti pay by result per l'innovazione dei programmi di reinserimento sociale e lavorativo delle persone detenute", presented in March to the Minister of Justice Andrea Orlando by Giovanna Melandri (president of Human Foundation) and Massimo Lapucci (secretary general of Fondazione Crt). The analysis was carried out by Human Foundation and Fondazione Sviluppo e Crescita Crt, together with the Politecnico di Milano, the University of Perugia and Kpmg, with the support of the Department of Penitentiary Administration and in collaboration with the management of the casa circondariale Lorusso e Cutugno di Torino.

Il ministro della Giustizia Andrea Orlando
Minister of Justice Andrea Orlando. Photo © Elisabetta Villa/Getty Images

How the rehabilitation of inmates is financed

The idea is to succeed in assigning a precise financial value to a social outcome. In this case, that outcome is the social and professional rehabilitation of inmates. If a person completes their prison term without reoffending, the public administration will no longer need to bear the costs of their detention (meals, bed places, supervision staff and so on). But there is more. Taking a broader view, the community will benefit from a fall in the crime rate. And if the former inmate finds regular, stable employment, the state will collect the resulting tax revenue.

The economic value is undeniable. At this point, one need "only" translate it into figures and find an independent body to verify whether the hoped-for outcome has been achieved. The public administration can then afford to repay the private investors who financed the project by taking on the entrepreneurial risk. In this specific proposal, it is envisaged that the allocation of resources would fall to Cassa Ammende, which has a special accounting arrangement — and that the potential investors would be primarily foundations of banking origin, which need to diversify their portfolios by also investing in activities guaranteed by the public sector.

Minister Orlando too has come out in favour of the possibility of piloting, at least in a trial version, new pay-for-result financial instruments capable of triggering this system. If they work, social impact bonds could provide the impetus to renew the entire prison system in our country.

Giovanna Melandri
Giovanna Melandri © Giorgio Cosulich/Getty Images

What Giovanna Melandri says about the pay-by-result model

One of the people working hardest to promote the adoption of the pay-by-result model in Italy is Giovanna Melandri herself — former minister for Cultural Heritage and Activities and for Youth Policies and Sport, and now president of Human Foundation and of Fondazione Maxxi. "Europe is the Moloch of public social spending, yet despite this it is clear that something is not working. There are areas of demand for social policies that are almost entirely unmet, first and foremost prevention": these were her opening words at the Settimana Sri on 15 November, at an event dedicated precisely to the social and environmental impact of investments.

It is no coincidence, then, that prevention lies at the heart of the project involving Turin's prison. A project that, Melandri stressed forcefully, if it becomes a reality will radically affect the mechanisms of welfare (and their inefficiencies): "What does this mean for the public administration? Not reducing resources, but spending them better. It means no longer being forced to disburse funding without then being able to intervene in the way it is used — a situation that has so far led to certain distortions and, conversely, has meant that some excellent cases have not been given the recognition they deserve."

'Erogare risorse pubbliche sulla base dei risultati realizzati è la rivoluzione copernicana di questo settore' @GioMelandri a #settimanasri @ItaSIF @GruppoCdp @FondCariplo

And what does it mean, instead, for the private sector? "It is a challenge, because it means no longer doing impact investing in just one direction (supply-side), but allows demand to be built — which is precisely what is missing right now," Melandri declared before an attentive audience. The social cooperatives operating in prisons, for their part, find themselves compelled to work together to achieve a common goal.

Pay-by-result instruments, she concluded, are not a ready-made solution but a field of research that every country is trying to adapt to its own history. "It is a challenge to economic liberalism that does not integrate social values into the market," she concluded. "But it is also a challenge to statism, which believes the solution is to disburse public resources without oversight."