Paolo Scudieri, Anfia: vehicle emissions cannot be cut by destroying the sector. An interview with Anfia president Paolo Scudieri: announcing dates
It is undeniable that the automotive world is moving decisively towards powertrains with a reduced environmental impact. But it is important that the ecological transition of the sector be guided by objectives and programmes shared between the European Union, national governments and manufacturers. Otherwise, warns Paolo Scudieri, president of the Associazione nazionale filiera industria automobilistica (Anfia), there is a risk of a kind of "technological massacre" and the destruction of companies whose combined turnover represents 20 per cent of Italian GDP. It is fine, he stresses, to focus on manufacturers' future plans, but only on condition that we do not forget that emissions depend on the car fleet currently in circulation. And from this point of view, the picture is far from reassuring.
You recently stated that announcing precise dates for the end of combustion engines is wrong. Why?
Announcing precise dates without first having held discussions with those who must ensure that these dates can become a reality is wrong. For this reason we propose collaboration and coordination both with the Italian government and with the European Commission, to understand what the right timeframes and the right conditions are – for example in terms of an infrastructure plan – so that the ecological transition can be tackled while containing the employment impact as much as possible and safeguarding the competitiveness of the automotive industry. The latter, in the EU, employs 14.6 million direct and indirect workers and accounts for 7 per cent of gross domestic product; in Italy, it employs 278,000 workers in the production supply chain, a figure that rises to 1.25 million when looking at the broader sector including those working in services, with a combined turnover equal to 20 per cent of GDP.
Is 2035 too close a horizon? Imposing a 2035 deadline would mean causing a destruction that serves no one and, on the contrary, penalises the labour market, businesses and technological development itself. Before setting dates, objectives must absolutely be shared and a programme to achieve them established together. Moving beyond the ideological penalisation of certain technologies means understanding that it is not through demonisation that targets are reached: it is companies that put their own know-how to work in favour of innovation and the environmental and economic sustainability of mobility, according to a technological-neutrality approach that contributes to the fundamental renewal of the vehicle fleet in circulation.
Yet many of the leading automotive groups have announced that in the coming years they will stop producing combustion engines and rely entirely on technologies with lower environmental impacts…
Attention always focuses on vehicle manufacturers' production plans and investments in new technologies and on the new-car market, forgetting that the environmental impact of mobility comes from the vehicles actually travelling on the roads. In Italy at the end of 2019 there were 39.5 million cars in circulation, 13 million of which had powertrains pre-dating Euro 4, with a median age of 11.5 years; all this against an annual average of 1.64 million new cars sold over the last 10 years. Electrification is an established and irreversible trend, which is also growing in the Italian market, but the widespread adoption of electric vehicles is gradual and conditioned by crucial factors.
Which ones? First and foremost, the number and territorial distribution of public charging points – today, in Italy, there are only 2.7 per 100 kilometres, against a European average of 4.9 – and the development of private and corporate ones. And secondly, purchase-incentive measures: in our country, the ecobonus must be extended at least until 2026, because it is a measure that has worked.
What is the aspect that most holds back the full uptake of electric cars? Does the sale price weigh more heavily, or the shortage of charging infrastructure?
The delay we are paying for in charging infrastructure is certainly the sore point. In Italy, in addition to there still being an evident and discriminatory unevenness in territorial distribution, there is a gap compared with other European countries in the number of charging points: according to December 2020 data, Italy ranks 16th in the European ranking. Network capillarity and charging speed are among the most important enabling factors for the spread of electric mobility.
What is needed to accompany the ecological transition of the automotive world in the best possible way? What is needed is an ad hoc plan providing for the creation of a public-private task force to successfully manage the transition of the automotive supply chain towards vehicle electrification and to support investment in new technologies such as hydrogen, connectivity and automation. It is essential, in this regard, that the definition of the PNRR proposal, currently being rewritten before returning to the Chambers and being delivered to the European Parliament by 30 April, should be able to guarantee the implementation of a genuine automotive plan for the country. Among our proposals: simplification and strengthening of industrial policy instruments, human capital skills retraining programmes, financial measures to support businesses, and tools to enhance Italy's productive attractiveness relative to other countries.
How much has the pandemic impacted the car market? Does the Italian situation present any particular features compared with the rest of Europe?
In 2020 the Italian car market closed with 535,000 fewer units than in 2019, a fall of 27.9 per cent which, without the support of incentives, would certainly have been greater, in the order of a further 100,000 fewer vehicles. I therefore highlight the collective benefits of market-support measures which, in our country, substitute social safety nets in keeping jobs alive – in 2020 the Italian automotive industry more than doubled its hours of short-time working support – and implement the environmental and energy policies that set Italy on course for the European decarbonisation targets.
Paolo Scudieri, Anfia: vehicle emissions cannot be cut by destroying the sector
Mobility — di Dario Zerbi
Paolo Scudieri, Anfia: vehicle emissions cannot be cut by destroying the sector. An interview with Anfia president Paolo Scudieri: announcing dates