10 years of environmental struggles in Ecuador, where the rights of Mother Earth are enshrined in the constitution

10 years of environmental struggles in Ecuador, where the rights of Mother Earth are enshrined in the constitution

Environment · ·

Ten years after the inclusion of the rights of Mother Earth — the Pachamama — in the Ecuadorian constitution, we take stock of where things stand.

It was 20 October 2008 when the new Ecuadorian constitution came into force — the first in the world to recognise inalienable rights for the Pachamama, Mother Earth in the local language. The preamble states: "We celebrate nature, the Pachamama, of which we are a part and which is vital to our existence." Its rights are enshrined in the seventh chapter; the first article reads: "Nature, or Pachamama, where life is reproduced and occurs, has the right to be integrally respected for its existence and for the maintenance and regeneration of its life cycles, structure, functions and evolutionary processes." The right not only to be respected, but also to be fully restored wherever it is violated.

Quito Ecuador Pachamama Costituzione
Quito, capital of Ecuador © Ingimage

The buen vivir

In light of this, Ecuador sets out to build a new form of civic coexistence, in the name of diversity and harmony with nature, in order to achieve the good life (buen vivir in Spanish, sumak kawsay in the indigenous language). This is addressed in the second chapter of the constitution. The concept of development, with which we are more familiar and which encapsulates the idea of living ever better, is typical of Western culture, but has no equivalent in indigenous languages; buen vivir is instead the distinctly Andean approach that contemplates a full and dignified life, a harmonious existence across the different dimensions of being, between the environment and the community.

According to Alberto Acosta, former president of the constituent assembly and one of the driving forces behind the 2008 reform, just as social justice was at the heart of the struggles of the twentieth century, environmental justice will be the foundation of the fights of the twenty-first.

While the great innovation of the 2008 constitution was to include the rights of nature, as well as the right to participation and the rights of indigenous peoples, it also reaffirms the importance of social rights. It addresses the right to water (art. 12), to food and food sovereignty (art. 13), to health (art. 32), and the universalisation of the right to social security (art. 34).

foresta amazzonica Pachamama Ecuador
The Amazon rainforest, its rivers and its inhabitants, a living complex © Mario Tama/Getty Images

The constitution is a great step forward, but questions remain unresolved

The 2008 constitution is undoubtedly an important step forward both in practical terms and in terms of principle, but many difficulties remain. To begin with, there is no clear definition of what nature is, but whatever it may be, it cannot independently assert its own rights. It is therefore up to citizens to do so and to call upon the authorities to enforce them. The fundamental problem with granting equal legal rights to humans and to nature lies in the fact that such rights are often in conflict with one another, and although incentives are offered to those who personally champion environmental justice, the matter is complex and the interests at stake are many.

Furthermore, the constitution sets high-level rules to guide legislation and jurisprudence, but in practice there can be contradictions at local, regional or national level: reality can fall far short of what is aspired to, and the vision of the natural world as something "other" with respect to humanity is still difficult to dislodge.

pachamama Ecuador costituzione
The marine iguana is an endemic species of the Galápagos Islands, off the coast of Ecuador © Ingimage

Economic interests at the expense of the Pachamama

In a country that depends heavily on the extractive industry, protecting nature from interference can seem idealistic or unachievable. Researchers at Anglia Ruskin University have observed that the 2008 constitution was enacted during a period of relative prosperity, but that if the economy were to take a turn for the worse, priorities could change.

Read also: Ecuador, le donne indigene dal presidente Moreno per difendere l'Amazzonia

Statistics from the World Bank show that oil exports bring 5 billion dollars a year into state coffers — a figure lower than in the past — and the country's subsoil is also rich in other raw materials and minerals that put the integrity of the Pachamama at risk. Evidence of this can be seen in the protests of indigenous communities regarding oil and mining concessions on tribal territories in particular, as well as in their struggles in favour of biodiversity and sustainable agriculture.

“Big mining & oil industries are moving into our community. It’s a universal problem, not just our community...” - Yaku Viteri of @Sarayaku_Libre #sketchingclimatestories buff.ly/2QB4eO1

The role of indigenous peoples

Article 21 on the rights of communities, peoples and nationalities contains an important passage: "The territories of peoples in voluntary isolation are irreducible and intangible ancestral possession and all forms of extractive activity shall be prohibited within them. The state shall adopt measures to guarantee their lives, uphold their self-determination and their wish to remain in a state of isolation, and protect respect for their rights."

While this approach is clearly positive for those communities recognised as living in voluntary isolation, it amounts to a smokescreen behind which the government can hide, because in practice vast areas continue to be subjected to exploitation and a great many indigenous peoples living in the forest are offered no such protection. On closer inspection, it is precisely the Amazon region that holds the greatest concentration of oil concessions.

For their part, indigenous peoples already have a solution: they ask that their role as defenders of the forest — recognised as a living being — be acknowledged. Their ancestral knowledge has for hundreds of years preserved the environment and given rise to a symbiotic relationship between the community and nature. Now that this relationship has become strained, the concept of buen vivir is once again relevant, grounded in an ecocentric approach in which nature and humanity are one, rather than an anthropocentric one that regards nature as a set of resources to be exploited.