Niles Eldredge: “Let's save the planet from the human catastrophe”

Niles Eldredge: “Let's save the planet from the human catastrophe”

Environment · ·

Thirty thousand living species disappear every year: the most rapid extinction in the history of the Earth. Palaeontologist Niles Eldredge sounds the alarm.

"We humans are
more destructive than the cataclysm that wiped out the
dinosaurs. And I want to make people understand this, hoping they will feel
the need to do something." So says American
palaeontologist Niles Eldredge, with conviction.

The public knows him above all for his partnership with Stephen Jay
Gould, the recently deceased evolutionary scholar, with whom
he developed thirty years ago the so-called theory of "punctuated
equilibria", a modern interpretation of Darwinism that
views evolution not as a gradual process, but as an alternation
of long periods of stability followed by phases in which
various factors – above all environmental ones – cause the extinction
of certain species and generate new ones. But Eldredge is also
the creator of the Hall of Biodiversity, a permanent exhibition on
biodiversity and the dangers that threaten it, housed
at the American Museum of Natural History.

Professor Eldredge, your latest book seeks to bring different
disciplines into dialogue…

It is essential if we truly want to understand how life has
evolved on our planet: the trouble is that
the universe and the creatures that inhabit it are governed by laws
more complex than those many of my
scientist colleagues would prefer.

A description that brings to mind the old "Gaia hypothesis"
proposed by James Lovelock and Lynn Margulis, which saw the Earth
as a single physiological system.

I don't share such a radical point of view, but if we use
the term Gaia to remind ourselves that all ecosystems are
interconnected, and that we find ourselves within a complex
global energy system of which life is a part, I can only
agree. The problem is that today no scholar,
however brilliant, is able to follow in person
the advances across different disciplines in order to achieve this kind of
synthesis.

Is that a criticism of reductionists like Richard Dawkins?
To claim, as Dawkins does, that evolution serves only to allow genes to
reproduce themselves is like saying that the blueprint for
building a car is more important
than the car itself. I am finishing writing an essay
titled "Why people have sex, and other misteries"
(Why we have sex, and other mysteries) precisely to
remind people that we are not in the world merely to have children, as
the church and evolutionary biologists believe, and that reproduction
is governed by other factors too. Not to mention that some
species – ours, for example – do not have sex solely for
reproductive purposes.

You have moved away from the study of fossils to devote yourself to
broader issues, such as biodiversity and
the population explosion. What drove you?

The state of emergency we are living in. It is essential
to take drastic measures to halt the extinction of so many
species, which could have very serious consequences both from an
environmental and an evolutionary standpoint. We must resolve the
most urgent problems, such as the scarcity of drinking water,
the pollution of rivers and oceans that is depleting
precious reserves. And above all we should ask ourselves: how many inhabitants
can survive on this planet? Ten thousand years ago, when
agriculture began to spread, the earth was populated
by six million people; today we are six billion.

Have we reached saturation point?
It has been calculated that 13
billion people could survive on earth. Naturally it depends on what one means by
"survive": if we think in terms of the standard of living of the average American,
even the current six billion is too many. There are some
positive signs, however: in certain countries, Italy among them,
growth has stopped – and an ageing
population raises other kinds of problems – but even in India
birth rates are falling, thanks to improved living conditions
and the spread of education, especially among
women.

And in the United States?
Ours is a very poor environmental policy. But it is
hardly surprising, given that it is the oil companies that
run the country.

Abigaille Barneschi