Not only Nigeria: the hidden massacres in Guinea and Cameroon

Not only Nigeria: the hidden massacres in Guinea and Cameroon

Rights · ·

Beyond the #EndSars protests in Nigeria, Guinea Conakry and Cameroon are also being torn apart by the impunity with which security forces operate.

On the evening of 20 October a crowd of young people is demonstrating at the Lekki toll gate in Lagos, Nigeria. The #EndSars slogan is being chanted loudly over a microphone as participants sit on the ground. Peaceful protests have been under way for weeks. The crowd is calling for the disbandment of Sars, the Special Anti-Robbery Squad, a special unit of the Nigerian police accused of arbitrary killings, theft, extortion and all manner of torture throughout its eighteen years of existence.

The arrival of a Nigerian army unit does nothing to disperse the demonstration. Philip Agu, an electronic engineer who helped set up the sound system, tells the New York Times that the protest's spokesperson had declared: "No soldier will shoot an unarmed citizen holding their country's flag to their chest." Three hours later, members of the security forces open fire on the protesters. It is a massacre. Amnesty International counts at least 10 victims, while the state authorities will first deny, then acknowledge the deaths of just two people.

Opening fire on peaceful protesters is a blatant violation of people’s rights to life, dignity and freedom of expression. The #Lekki massacre must be investigated. #EndSARS

Guinea Conakry: the violent response of the security forces

In Conakry, Guinea, almost two thousand kilometres west of Lagos, the city is plastered with electoral billboards. The image of President Alpha Condé on a yellow background, smiling with a rainbow behind him — the symbol of his party, the Rassemblement du peuple de Guinée (Rpg) — is everywhere. Boubacar Baldè steers his motorbike through street vendors and potholes in the asphalt. Sangoya, Tomboleya, Kokoma: the districts of Conakry follow one another along the city's main artery.

It is here, above all in the outskirts, that the reach of the Fndc — the Fronte nazionale per la difesa della Costituzione (Front national pour la défense de la Constitution), founded in October 2019 — is most extensive. In these neighbourhoods, young men like Boubacar hold meetings and spread ideas about the importance of defending a constitution born in 1989, but only partially applied from 2010 onwards, following the death of dictator Lassana Contè and the military junta.

Electoral billboard in Guinea Conakry for President Alpha Condé ©Marco Simoncelli

Alpha Condé's decision to reform the constitution in order to stand for a third presidential term drove hundreds of young men like Boubacar into the streets. It was a political choice that opened a Pandora's box of clashes and social tension. The months between January and March 2020 were the hardest. Guinea was at the centre of unrest and protests. The police response against demonstrators was severe. On streets that today glisten with rain, between October 2019 and July 2020 at least 50 people were killed, according to data provided by Amnesty International.

On 16 October, two days before the elections, Boubacar joins his companions on an awareness-raising tour. The idea of a new demonstration aimed at blocking the N1, the expressway that cuts through the city, is in the air. In the courtyard of a house in the Matam neighbourhood, some thirty people listen to the careful speech of Mamadou Billo Bah, an Fndc activist and friend of Boubacar. "We are ready for anything. We are ready to be arrested, to suffer violence, even to die. Why should our lives be worth more than those of people who have already lost theirs in recent months?" The Guinean activist's words are punctuated by the now heavy rain beating on the corrugated iron roof. "By now we know we are dealing with a dictator," the young member of the Front national concludes.

Mamadou Billo Bah, activist of the FNDC movement in Guinea Conakry, during a rally ©Marco Simoncelli

The long history of unpunished violence in Guinea Conakry

Billo, like Boubacar, has experienced the repression of the security forces first-hand. But the violence, and the accompanying impunity, with which the police and gendarmerie operate are nothing new in Guinea.

It was 28 September 2008, and the military junta led by Dadis Camara was in power. In a stadium in the capital — today named "28 September" — thousands of people had gathered following a peaceful march organised against the junta leader's intention to stand for the presidency. It was just a few minutes before noon. The security forces trained their rifles on the protesters. The result was carnage: 150 dead and dozens of women raped. After the massacre, the security forces organised a cover-up operation. They sealed all the entrances, removed the bodies and buried them in mass graves, some of which have yet to be identified.

Fatoumata Bah, during the protests of March 2020 in Guinea Conakry, was used as a human shield by the police ©Marco Simoncelli

To this day, victims' associations are demanding justice, despite the establishment in 2018 by then Justice Minister Cheick Sako of a steering committee to organise the trial, and the announcement in January 2020 by Justice Minister Mohammed Lamine Fofana to the United Nations of his government's "unequivocal" support for opening proceedings.

A profound silence that we tested first-hand. Despite the official authorisations in our possession, with press accreditation from the Ministry of Communication, we were not given the opportunity to film or take photographs at the stadium. Those in charge of the facility refused to respond to our requests, or to those of the relevant authorities for foreign journalists, and threatened us.

Post-election protests cost at least 21 people their lives

The morning after polling day, on 19 October, Conakry wakes up calm. Nothing foreshadows what will unfold in the hours that follow. In the afternoon, Cellou Dalein Diallo of the opposition party Ufdg — the Union des forces démocratiques de Guinée — President Condé's challenger, declares victory even though counting is still under way, and people pour into the streets. There is celebrating, singing, dancing. By evening the general euphoria changes character. Security forces intervene in various parts of the city.

Images of police using firearms spread on WhatsApp, stoking anger. According to the state television network, there will be 21 dead, while the opposition speaks of at least 30 people killed. A toll that grows further with hundreds of people wounded and an unspecified number of protesters or suspected protesters arrested. Boubacar Baldè is on this list. On 22 October a bullet strikes him squarely in the chest near his home. He dies aged 28.

A queue of people waits in Conakry, the capital of Guinea, for their turn to vote ©Marco Simoncelli

The Cameroon case: use of force and arbitrary arrests

Moving westward, nestled between the mouths of the Dibamba and Wouri rivers, lies Douala, a coastal city in Cameroon. Here on 22 September hundreds of people gathered peacefully to protest against the organisation of December's regional elections and to call for a resolution to the conflict raging in the Anglophone regions. The police and gendarmerie responded with tear gas, water cannons and arrests.

Counter-terrorism operations in Cameroon serve as an umbrella for widespread and unpunished violence across various regions of the country

Cameroon is an unstable country. Three fronts of conflict — in the north with Boko Haram, in the south-east in the Anglophone regions, where separatist movements are demanding autonomy, and in the west with rebels coming from the Central African Republic — have sharpened a situation in which human rights were already poorly protected. If, under an authoritarian government of thirty years led by the 87-year-old Paul Biya, protesting was risky in the past, today, under the umbrella of counter-terrorism operations, it can cost even more.

"What happened in Douala is nothing new. Security forces have used violence to disperse peaceful protests on other occasions," says Ilaria Allegrozzi, Human Rights Watch (Hrw), who has been covering Cameroon for several years. "Last year, the leadership of the opposition party Mouvement pour la renaissance du Cameroun (Mrc) was arrested, including its leader Maurice Kamto." In a country torn apart by massacres and conflicts, a tendency to silence any voice of opposition or dissent is taking shape. "In this situation, journalists too pay a very high price. They are unable to cover what is happening or are forced into self-censorship," the Hrw representative continues. "After 22 September, journalists from international outlets were also arrested and beaten."

One of the places that conjures the most ghosts linked to arbitrary violence and the impunity of security forces is the SED, Secrétariat d'État à la défense, the State Secretariat for Defence, in Yaoundé. In its basements, according to detailed Hrw reports, detainees who have not had a regular trial are tortured. Suspected separatists linked to the Ambazonian secessionist movement or self-proclaimed terrorists are brought to this unofficial detention centre — all in an informal manner.

The overnight vote count in Guinea Conakry after the presidential elections ©Marco Simoncelli

The situation deteriorates the further you move from the capital

But the violence does not stop at the capital. On the contrary, the closer one gets to the crisis areas, the more cases there are. And while in Guinea Conakry the bond between the military and the government is not as solid — the mutiny of 16 October, two days before the elections, is proof of that — in Cameroon President Biya has an entire army unit under his control. The Bir, battaglione d'intervento rapido, answers to the head of state, while being managed in the field by a former Israeli officer. On this point, numerous investigations have raised questions about the relationship between Tel Aviv and the dictator of Yaoundé. But even more troubling are the methods used by this special unit. Deployed in the north to fight Boko Haram and in the Anglophone regions to suppress the separatist drift, the Bir has been responsible for numerous crimes, including torture, extrajudicial killings and massacres. A worldwide scandal that in 2019, also thanks to Amnesty International's reports, cost the unit its US military assistance.

The massacres of Ngarbuh and Kumba have stirred a new awareness in Cameroon

Yet in a context of impunity and silence that breeds new violence, signs of a profound weariness are beginning to appear on the streets of Cameroonian cities. People are taking to the streets, aware of the risks. At the root of a renewed awareness lie perhaps two recent bloody episodes that have also drawn international attention. On 14 February, men from government forces and armed civilian units of Fulani ethnicity entered the village of Ngarbuh, killing 21 people, among them 13 children and a pregnant woman. According to information gathered by Hrw, Bir personnel were also among the security forces.

The latest episode to shock Cameroonian public opinion is that of 24 October, when around ten armed civilians entered a school in Kumba and killed 7 children, injuring another 13. An event that still has no clear perpetrator, with the parties involved — the Yaoundé authorities and the Ambazonian separatists — continuing to trade accusations.

Seven children have been buried after they were shot dead in their school in the Cameroonian city of Kumba reut.rs/3euXLRj

From Guinea to Nigeria, via Cameroon, a push for change is becoming apparent. An impulse to assert one's rights — so often trampled upon, whether economic, civil or political. In this region overlooking the Gulf of Guinea, the distance between the population and governments is growing. A canyon of mistrust that widens as cases of violence and impunity continue to mount.