Nevada considers giving up a lithium mine to save a rare plant

Nevada considers giving up a lithium mine to save a rare plant

Environment · ·

The Rhyolite Ridge lithium mine would serve the electric car industry, but at the cost of condemning a plant species to extinction.

With its modest dimensions (up to 30 centimetres in diameter and 16 in height) and its small grey-blue leaves covered in white or grey hairs, Eriogonum tiehmii (Tiehm's buckwheat) is not, at first glance, a particularly showy plant. But it is rare — extremely rare, in fact. So much so that, in order to protect it, there is now talk of abandoning plans to open a new lithium mine in Nevada.

The mysterious disappearance of Tiehm's buckwheat

Tiehm's buckwheat grows only in Esmeralda County, in the US state of Nevada. In September of last year it was discovered that around 17,000 plants had been uprooted during the summer, causing the already meagre population to collapse by 40 per cent. Scientists are still investigating the causes of this episode. Rodents are the prime suspects, though human interference cannot be ruled out.

The plant's restricted habitat also encompasses Rhyolite Ridge, an area that contains the largest reserves of lithium and boron in all of North America, estimated at 146.5 million tonnes. This is the very lithium that is the essential element in electric car batteries. Hence the project, put forward by Australian mining company Ioneer, to open a new, large-scale mine.

Miniera di litio
A disused mine in Germany that contains lithium © Sean Gallup/Getty Images

Environmentalists want to stop the mine

This, however, would spell the definitive death sentence for Eriogonum tiehmii, according to a study carried out by the Centre for biological diversity. As a result, around a hundred scientists, together with 15 nature conservation groups and three local politicians, decided to take a stand, signing an appeal addressed to US president Joe Biden as early as January 2021.

I'm a botanist deeply concerned with the status of plants. I use to think plants on US public lands had relatively more protection. That may be mostly true, but then there is Tiehm’s buckwheat. Endemic to 10 acres on fed lands, it faces an existential threat by a mine.

In June, the United States Fish and Wildlife Service — the agency within the Department of the Interior responsible for the management and conservation of wildlife, fisheries and natural habitats — also sided with them, calling loudly for the protections provided under the Endangered Species Act to be applied.

This does not necessarily mean that the mine will be blocked, but there is no doubt that the path of its environmental impact assessment will be an uphill one. The issue is a sensitive one, particularly at this time of rapid development for the electric mobility sector.