Cruise ships and maritime tourism are polluting European cities

Cruise ships and maritime tourism are polluting European cities

Mobility · ·

218 cruise ships in Europe emitted as much sulphur as one billion cars. Barcelona the most polluted port, Venice a virtuous case.

Port cities are choking on pollution. According to a study by Transport & Environment, concentrations of air pollutants produced in particular by cruise ships are higher than in the pre-pandemic period.

Despite the introduction of the sulphur limit set by the International Maritime Organization (IMO) in 2020, last year the 218 cruise ships operating in Europe emitted as much sulphur oxide (SOx) as one billion cars. With a few exceptions: one of these is Venice, where pollutants from cruise ships have fallen by 80 per cent.

Venice, that is, following the ban on large cruise ships entering the city, demonstrates that it is possible to tackle the pollution generated by maritime tourism.

porto-crociera-turchia
The port of Istanbul, Turkey © Engin Akyurt/Unsplash

Ports must reduce sulphur emission levels from cruise ships

Constance Dijkstra, shipping campaign manager at T&E, said: "The pandemic gave port cities a bit of a reprieve, but now it's over. Cruises are back and tourist destinations like Barcelona and Athens are once again choking on toxic air pollution from cruise ships. Venice has shown that it is possible to tackle cruise ship pollution, but bans are not the only way. Ports can significantly reduce pollution levels by forcing ships to connect to shore power instead of running their engines, and by supporting the uptake of zero-emission fuels."

Compared to 2019, the number of cruise ships, the time spent around ports and the fuel consumed have all increased by around a quarter (23–24 per cent). This has led to a 9 per cent increase in SOx emissions, an 18 per cent increase in NOx emissions and a 25 per cent increase in PM2.5 emissions — three highly toxic air pollutants.

Barcelona is the most polluted port, Venice has dropped from first to 41st place

Barcelona was Europe's most polluted port last year, followed by Civitavecchia and the Athenian port of Piraeus. SOx limits for cars in Europe are 100 times stricter than those for ships, yet in Barcelona, cruise ships emitted almost three times more SOx than all the cars in the city.

Venice's progress, by contrast, is remarkable: the port most polluted by cruises in 2019 dropped to 41st place last year following the ban on large cruise ships entering the port, introduced in 2021, which led to an 80 per cent reduction in SOx emissions.

However, this has not prevented Italy from overtaking Spain as the European country most polluted by cruise ships. Furthermore, although the Mediterranean bears the brunt of cruise ship pollution, Norway ranked fourth in the ranking and was in fact the country with the highest cruise traffic, albeit with smaller vessels.

venezia
Venice has dropped from first to 41st place in the ranking of the most polluted ports © Stefan Bütikofer/Unsplash

MSC pollutes as much as all the cars in Europe

The most polluting cruise operator was Msc Cruises, whose cruise ships emitted almost as much SOx as all passenger cars in Europe. Taking all its subsidiaries into account, the Carnival group was the most polluting.

"Many cruise operators, such as Msc, are investing in liquefied natural gas (LNG) as a cleaner alternative. This year, over 40 per cent of new cruise ships have opted for LNG," the organisation writes in its report. "These ships are better in terms of air pollution, but are extremely damaging from a climate perspective due to methane emissions from their engines — a potent gas with a warming potential more than 80 times greater than CO2. For example, P&O's MS Iona emitted as much methane as 10,500 cows in a year."

Transport&Environment is calling for greater electrification at ports, extending the zero-emission berthing requirement to cruise ships during their time at anchor as well. Furthermore, the organisation is calling for the extension of Sulphur Emission Control Areas (Seca) to all European and UK waters: currently, Seca areas in Europe cover the Baltic Sea and the North Sea. The Mediterranean is set to become a controlled area from 2025. Finally, it would be necessary to establish operational standards for NOx emissions at European level, and T&E recommends that cruise companies stop investing in LNG-powered ships and focus instead on more sustainable technologies, such as hydrogen, electric batteries and wind energy.