Nature, a silent victim of war

Nature, a silent victim of war

Environment · ·

Nature is a silent victim of war. More than two months after the start of the conflict in Ukraine, the environment is counting its wounds.

More than two months after the start of the conflict in Ukraine, many things are clear, others less so. Among the latter is a victim that goes unheard, one that is barely spoken of: nature. Because the violence of war strikes everyone and everything without distinction. Ukraine, devastated by the armed conflict, has seen buildings, homes, hospitals, nurseries and entire cities collapse, but has also had to witness the disappearance of what surrounded it — a defenceless environment that is, sadly, counting its losses.

La vittima silenziosa
Nature, the silent victim of war ©Spencer Platt/Getty Images

Nature is a silent victim of war

Let us try to better understand the damage this war is causing to the environment. Ukraine is an area of enormous ecological importance; its environmental heritage encompasses wetlands, forests and wide stretches of virgin steppe, as yet untouched by human hand. More than a third of Ukraine's protected areas have now been overrun by military operations.

Guerra e ambiente
A missile in a field in the village of Lukashivka, Ukraine ©Anastasia Vlasova/Getty Images

The Black Sea Biosphere Reserve

One area that has been severely affected is the Black Sea Biosphere Reserve, on Ukraine's southern coast. This reserve is a paradise for birds: more than 120,000 fly and nest among the protected waters of its wetlands. A great many species have been recorded there, many of them at risk of extinction. Yet birds are not the only inhabitants of this environment: dozens of species of fish, molluscs, plants, flowers and rodents — including the Ukrainian mole rat (a rodent endemic to Ukraine and critically threatened with extinction) — dolphins, which we will return to later, and much more besides. To all of this must now be added an invading army. Here, the numerous fires — large enough to be visible from space — have in all likelihood destroyed the breeding habitats of many species. At present there are no precise figures on the losses.

The Askania-Nova reserve

Another highly important area that has also become a theatre of war is the Askania-Nova reserve. This nature reserve has been designated a Biosphere Reserve by Unesco; within its boundaries lies one of the last regions in Europe with pristine steppe vegetation. Among the species found there are Przewalski's horses (the largest captive group), bison, saiga antelope, as well as a zoo. All these animals — again, many of them endangered species — require special care, such as supplementary feeding to get through winter and the beginning of spring. It has not been easy for the government to allocate funds for the protection of these species, so some organisations have raised money to support the reserve and to pay local wheat farmers so as to be able to feed the animals, left to fend for themselves.

animali addestrati
Several animal species are exploited as weapons of war ©Taylor Weidman/Getty Images

Animals as machines of war

Dolphins have long been an integral part of the Russian military — one example being the dolphins deployed off the coast of Crimea to defend Russian military vessels — going back to the days of the Cold War. During that era, numerous training programmes were aimed at creating true animal war machines. Dolphins make excellent underwater weapons: fast, agile and, when the occasion demands, lethal. They also possess a characteristic that makes them even more indispensable: echolocation, which enables them to detect underwater mines. However, military animal training programmes are not solely a Russian matter. Other countries such as the United States, North Korea and Israel have such programmes, in which belugas, seals and sea lions have also been involved. It should not be forgotten that, in other parts of the world too, various species of both marine and terrestrial animals have been trained — but that is another story.

Returning to dolphins and the war, the problem lies not only in the ethics of training: dolphins in the Black Sea are dying. Since the start of the conflict, as many as eighty common dolphins (Delphinus delphis) have been found stranded on Turkish shores. The cause of these deaths remains uncertain. Roughly half could possibly be attributed to entanglement in fishing nets. Yet the Black Sea is home to numerous warships. Underwater acoustic pollution produced by these vessels could be the principal cause: all the noise underwater, while not killing the animals directly, disturbs them and disrupts their activity, driving them to flee towards less familiar territories. Direct acoustic trauma could explain the strandings, while the persistent noise could instead account for the rising rate of captures in fishing nets, the result of a mass flight-migration of fish and cetaceans towards Turkish shores.

I danni della guerra
Damage to the various storage facilities present in Ukraine would cause devastating consequences ©Chris McGrath/Getty Images

The indirect weapons present in Ukraine

Ukraine has chemical plants, oil depots, coal mines, gas pipelines, storage facilities and no fewer than 15 nuclear power stations. All of these can be regarded as time bombs ready to go off. Damage to these sites would cause consequences — not only environmental ones — that would be devastating. More than thirty years have passed since the nuclear disaster at Chernobyl and we are well aware of the effects of radiation (it must be noted that those effects were felt across entire populations, not merely by individuals). The paradoxical fact is that, over the years, a great many species have returned to the Chernobyl exclusion zone, benefiting from the complete absence of human activity. Now the war is driving them away again.

Studies on the effects of war on nature

War is destruction, and the environment is its innocent victim. A 2009 study found that from 1950 to 2000, eighty per cent of armed conflicts took place in biodiversity hotspots — areas harbouring endemic species, threatened species and high levels of biodiversity. Studies on the impact of war on the environment are still not numerous. However, we know that: in Africa, various conflicts led to a decline in wildlife within protected areas; in Vietnam, the use of napalm as an offensive strategy razed the jungle completely to the ground; in Belgium, trenches, tanks, bombs, fires and explosions dispersed heavy metals into both water and soil, and in 2011, at a major First World War battlefield, lead and copper levels were still elevated; in Angola during the 1975 war, anti-poaching activities were suspended, resulting in a drastic decline in buffalo and antelope populations; in Gorongosa National Park, during the Mozambican civil war from 1977 to 1992, populations of large herbivores such as elephants, zebras and buffaloes fell by more than ninety per cent; after the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, poverty levels were extremely high, driving people to hunt, and as a result wild boar, elk and bear numbers dropped dramatically. These are just a few examples.

ritorno di specie a Chernobyl
Many species have returned to the Chernobyl exclusion zone thanks to the absence of humans ©Daniel Berehulak/Getty Images

Nature, once again, is the silent victim. It is hard to say what lies ahead; the environmental impact will certainly be devastating — perhaps the answer is blowing in the wind, as Bob Dylan sang.

"The answer, my friend, is blowin' in the wind"