What position do the parties standing in the European elections take on migration

What position do the parties standing in the European elections take on migration

Rights · ·

Management of flows and closed borders: an analysis of political manifestos on migration ahead of the upcoming European elections.

One of the most discussed issues in recent years within European institutions is that of migration and asylum, and it will be one of the central themes of the upcoming European elections. Between the ongoing negotiations over the reform of the Dublin system and the increase in agreements with third states for the control of European borders, the general approach has always centred on the pairing of "immigration and security". The past year in particular has been crucial for the creation of the new Pact on Migration and Asylum and for the signing of several agreements with countries beyond the Mediterranean for the control of European borders, at the expense of the rights not only of migrants, but of the citizens of those countries themselves.

EU’s Migration Pact is a Disaster for Migrants and Asylum Seekers trib.al/Nckg1M6

From agreements with Arab countries to pushbacks in the desert

The European Commission's approach has changed drastically over these five years. While in September 2020 Ursula Von Der Leyen described migration as a fact that, over the centuries, had enriched European culture, at the European People's Party congress held in Bucharest last March she changed her tone. Reaffirming that it will be "us", the Europeans, who decide which migrants will enter Europe and how. And the chosen means is evidently the strengthening of the Union's external borders.

Over the past year the European Commission has accelerated the signing of multiple pacts for border control with third states, the primary objective of which is to stop migration flows, at any cost. The model used is that of the agreement signed between Italy and Libya in 2017, through which detention camps and Libyan militias were funded.

Per il Ministro #Piantedosi, l’Italia non ha mai preso parte a respingimenti illegali di persone migranti in Libia.

Forse non è ben informato. L’ultimo episodio che abbiamo documentato risale al maggio 2023.

Basta fingere.
Basta accordi con la Libia.
Basta respingimenti.

Tunisia

Since 2023, several agreements have been signed with Arab governments, including authoritarian ones, for border control, under the guise of strategic partnership. The first was the Memorandum of Understanding signed in Tunis last July, which provided for a total loan of 900 million and a clause requiring austerity reforms demanded by the International Monetary Fund. The first tranche of 150 million was sent to Tunis in March 2024, despite the xenophobic statements of President Kaïs Saïed, the ongoing arrests of activists and journalists who criticised his government, and the deportations at the border with Libya and Algeria.

Morocco and Mauritania

Also in 2023, a migration-related pact with Morocco began to take shape, though it has yet to materialise. In early 2024, Ursula von der Leyen flew to Mauritania to expand the series of agreements on controlling migration flows in Africa. In this case, Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez lent his support to the Commissioner. The agreement provides for the sending of 210 million euros for infrastructure and employment, but the centrepiece remains border control.

Mauritania is denying it will host any migrant centres or Frontex offices, as rumours fly of a migration deal with the EU. middleeastmonitor.com/20240221-mauri…

Egypt

Subsequently, it was the turn of Egypt under Abdel Fattah al-Sisi. Here too, as with Tunis, the Italian government led by Giorgia Meloni played a central role, despite criticism also linked to the limited cooperation of Egyptian authorities in the case of Giulio Regeni.

Cairo finds itself in a severe economic and financial crisis, and the possibility of signing economic agreements with Brussels on migration control could allow Al Sisi to avoid worsening the loan already contracted with the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank. The pact with the European Union is worth 7.4 billion euros, of which five billion are in loans and two and a half billion for projects in the energy and migration sectors.

According to the International Organisation for Migration, Egypt is home to nine million migrants, including four million Sudanese and one and a half million Syrians, in addition to an indeterminate number of Palestinian refugees who managed to leave Rafah. These are people who could depart from Egyptian shores, to whom must be added Egyptian citizens living in conditions of absolute or marginal poverty — people that Brussels wants to stop.

The European Union is ignoring repression and rewarding authoritarianism.

The EU's new cash assistance and migration-control deal with Egypt is a betrayal of human rights. bit.ly/3xaiVkP

Lebanon

Last but not least, there is the agreement signed with Lebanon. On 2 May, Ursula von der Leyen travelled to Beirut together with Cypriot President Nikos Christodoulides, promising to send one billion euros to prevent Syrian refugees from departing towards Cyprus. All of this took place despite evidence of pushbacks in the desert by, in particular, the governments of Morocco, Mauritania and Tunisia, as reported by the investigation carried out by the collective of journalists at Lighthouse Reports.

The new Pact on Migration and Asylum

Following approval by the European Parliament in April, and the definitive green light from the Council on 14 May, the new Pact on Migration and Asylum — which is intended to supersede the much-criticised Dublin system — entered into force after four years of negotiations.

The agreement is structured around ten regulations and provides for accelerated procedures at the border for migrants coming from so-called safe countries, the extension of administrative detention for asylum seekers, and a mandatory solidarity mechanism for the relocation of migrants according to a quota system. Countries that do not wish to accept migrants must contribute financially to the common fund for returns.

The core of the Dublin system, however, has not been superseded. Migrants will still have to apply for asylum in the first country of arrival. Other practices are also being tightened, including the identification of migrants through biometric data — no longer from the age of 14, but from six years of age upwards — and the new rules relating to the Eurodac database (which contains the fingerprints of people who apply for asylum or who have been stopped while irregularly crossing a border).

Numerous criticisms have come from civil society and from organisations working on migration. According to Save the Children, the new regulation does not guarantee the protection of children's rights. For the Associazione studi giuridici sull'immigrazione (Asgi), "the new pact provides for the generalised application of accelerated, summary procedures based on geographical origin rather than on individuals' personal histories."

Barriere, controlli, respingimenti. L’Ue trova l’accordo sul patto immigrazione e asilo ed è un trionfo delle destre. Italia sconfitta, restano le regole di Dublino. Anche ai bambini di sei anni saranno prese le impronte. Von der Leyen parla come Meloni: «Decidiamo noi chi entra

Migration: what do the parties standing in the European elections think?

Ahead of the European elections in June, at which the new Parliament will be elected, on the issue of migration and asylum there is a political narrative that prioritises border control over widespread reception and the possibility of creating regular pathways for those wishing to migrate to Europe. We have analysed what the manifestos of the political groups that make up the European Parliament say about the Pact on Migration and Asylum and, more broadly, on the subject of migration.

The main positions on migration of the parties standing in the European elections