Mexico nationalises lithium: it cannot be exploited by “foreigners”

Mexico nationalises lithium: it cannot be exploited by “foreigners”

Rights · ·

Mexican president Andrés López Obrador continues along the path of lithium nationalisation begun in 2022. Collaborations and investments are planned, but Mexico will always be the principal “shareholder”.

On 18 February, Mexican president Andrés Manuel López Obrador signed a decree nationalising lithium and handing the country's reserves of the mineral over to the Ministry of Energy. The decree designates the more than 234 million hectares in the Sonora region, in the north-west of the country on the border with the United States — where the world's largest lithium mine is located — as a state reserve area. The principal objective is that the lithium present on Mexican territory cannot be exploited by any foreign country, "neither Russia, nor China, nor the United States". During his visit to the region, López Obrador firmly maintained that both oil and lithium are a national asset, belonging to the entire Mexican people.

López Obrador nazionalizza il litio
Mexican president Andrés López Obrador continues along the path of lithium nationalisation begun in 2022 © Alejandro Cegarra/Bloomberg via Getty Images

The free trade agreement between Mexico, the United States and Canada – the Usmca Agreement signed in 2020, which replaced the previous Nafta Agreement – provides for the possibility of participating in the development, production and commercialisation of any goods, including, therefore, electric vehicles, whose batteries require lithium. In this regard, the president declared his intention to develop the domestic mineral processing industry as well as the automotive industry – the same reason that led Zimbabwe to nationalise the same mineral last December.

Sonora will be fundamental to the production of electric cars with lithium batteries

In April 2022, Mexico reformed its mining law, declaring lithium a mineral of public utility and triggering concerns in Washington. To this end, the state-owned company Lithium for Mexico (LitioMX) was created, under the control of the Ministry of Energy. The new decree ensures that Mexican lithium is not exploited by foreign agents, or at least not without strict restrictions. With 1.7 million tonnes, Mexico is the tenth country in terms of lithium reserves, according to estimates by the United States Geological Survey. The country is keen to accelerate battery production after the United States announced its intention to reach 50 per cent electric vehicle sales in the domestic market by 2030. The administration led by Joe Biden wants to invest 2.8 billion dollars in domestic battery production, so that capital remains in the country, but has said nothing about the origin of the minerals needed to produce them.

For his part, López Obrador has never made any secret of wanting to compete with the Asian semiconductor market. Indeed, as early as the visit by US Secretary of State Antony Blinken to Mexico City on 12 September 2022, the Mexican president pushed for greater collaboration between the two countries, taking advantage of Washington's massive investments. At the time, López Obrador had already outlined his plan to make the northern border state of Sonora a leader in the production of lithium, electric vehicles and solar energy. The US diplomatic mission had viewed Mexico City's position as one of great openness. Now, however, it is concerned about the nationalisation process. In this way, López Obrador emulates former president Lázaro Cárdenas, whom he consistently acknowledges as the inspiration for his project. On 18 March 1938, Cárdenas announced the expropriation and total nationalisation of Mexican oil. Since taking office at the end of 2018, López Obrador has rejected new private investment in the oil and gas sector, including joint venture partnerships between state-owned Pemex and would-be private producers. He would appear, therefore, to view lithium in the same way: policy tied to the metal is an echo of his broader state-centric approach to raw materials deemed strategic.

batteria litio
Mexico is keen to accelerate battery production © iStockphoto

Protection of resources or hybrid system?

Although both the current decree and last year's reform give the Mexican government the final say on the exploitation of lithium, they nonetheless leave room for foreign investment. As the president himself has acknowledged on other occasions, Mexico would not be able to fully finance the exploitation and extraction of the lithium found on its territory. Investment models have yet to be decided, but the nationalisation of Mexican lithium is already a fait accompli. López Obrador must find a solution that allows the country to exploit its resources constructively, and to do so he should look to the neighbouring "lithium triangle", namely Bolivia, Argentina and Chile. The three Latin American states do not share the same model: Bolivia has a state-owned lithium-producing company and its legislative framework is not very different from that of Chile and Argentina, even though those countries allow investment or participation by private companies. This has meant that Chile and Argentina are the world's leading lithium producers, unlike Bolivia, despite the latter holding the largest reserves. Finding an investment model will be crucial for the country's economy. After the collapse of GDP in 2020 due to the Covid-19 pandemic, Mexico began to grow again, but the recovery is slow. It is therefore no coincidence that the acceleration of investment is happening right now.

The spectre of organised crime

Finally, there is the significant issue of violence and the presence of organised crime in the state of Sonora, which increasingly threatens local indigenous communities and mining operations: the more economic interests and actors there are in an area, the more the situation of violence spirals out of control.

“This system wants us to get used to the practice of forced disappearances. There are more than 110,000 disappeared people in Mexico… It seems like there is a war against the people” therealnews.com/indigenous-mex…

The Sonora project is very close to the so-called "golden triangle", an area in which a wave of violence and displacement has been documented as a result of mining activity and the territorial dispute between organised crime groups. There is therefore a correlation between the presence of mining projects and the rise in organised crime and repression. Despite the various concerns and uncertainties, work to advance operations in Sonora continues, and the government is pressing ahead with the project, aware that the cartels will seek to infiltrate the management of the mine.