Unscrupulous traders, unfair competition and stringent regulations are sinking traditional fishers. The future of the Mediterranean is at risk.
Sciacca, Sicily, Mediterranean. When Carlo Giarratano was 9 years old, he used to spend his summers at sea with his father, aboard the family's sailing fishing vessel, built by his grandfather and later modernised with the advent of engines. Until the 1990s, the port of Sciacca teemed with ships, sailors and boatmen. Port life was in full swing, vessels coming and going, laden with every kind of catch, ready to be sold at local markets. Thanks to fishing, entire generations were able to send their children to university or buy them a home. Carlo's father included. Today the port of Sciacca is empty and silent. Only the masts of vessels moored at the quayside emit a metallic sound. White sheets bearing the words "Sciopero. Caro Gasolio" and "Rispetto ai pescatori" flutter alone in the breeze. "They treat us as if we were ignorant and poachers. But are we really the only problem? European Union rules have created unfair competition," says Carlo Giarratano. "So now traders buy the same fish but at lower prices from Tunisians and Egyptians. We know the sea, we've spent our whole lives on it."
Carlo Giarratano is captain of the fishing vessel Accursio Giarratano. For generations his family has dedicated itself to fishing. First trawling for prawns, cod and red mullet. Then it specialised in swordfish fishing. Today, in the house where his grandmother once mended nets, Giarratano has decided to open a bed & breakfast. Between the dizzying rise in fuel prices and competition from foreign fishing vessels, fishing is becoming less and less profitable for Carlo and for Sicilian fleets. The number of fishing vessels is indeed steadily declining. The cause lies in a series of structural factors that have unfolded over the past twenty years in Sicily and throughout the rest of Italy: European Union funding to decommission vessels, high fuel costs, the absence of generational renewal, fishing regulations and competition from North Africa — specifically from Tunisian and Egyptian fishing vessels, which sell the same product caught by Sicilians but at lower costs and without any obligation to comply with EU rules.
The Mediterranean is among the most heavily exploited seas in the world
While it is true that European Union rules were aimed at protecting fish populations and the Mediterranean Sea — one of the most heavily exploited seas in the world — it is equally true that fishing effort has not in fact been reduced. Or rather, it has decreased on only one side of the Mediterranean. This is explained by a group of biologists who, from the offices of the Centro nazionale delle ricerche di Mazara del Vallo, monitor the situation in the central Mediterranean. "One of the greatest critical issues today is that for shared resources such as fish there are different management plans. The European Union has placed ecological sustainability at the centre of its policies. For Tunisia, Egypt or Libya, the priorities are different, such as employment. We have been asking for information on the fishing effort of Tunisian and Egyptian fleets for years, without success. In 2021, we know that the Tunisian fleet surpassed the Italian fleet in cod catches. As regards the pink prawn, the catch remains fifty per cent for the Italian fleet and fifty per cent for the Tunisian fleet. Sooner or later the Tunisians will also overtake the Italians in red prawn fishing."
Fiorentino and his colleague Sergio Vitale explain that the prized red prawn is currently overfished and fish populations are declining. This is due, at least in part, to the increase in fishing effort by Tunisian fleets, but also Egyptian and Libyan ones. A crustacean like the red prawn was, until a few years ago, the almost exclusive target of Sicilian fleets in the central Mediterranean; today, however, competition has increased disproportionately. "It is estimated that in Egypt there are 150 fishing vessels catching red prawns, and 70 per cent do so illegally."
While fishing vessels such as Carlo Giarratano's must contend with the stringent, albeit necessary, rules of the European Union, and use satellite tracking technologies to ensure they do not enter protected areas, North African bottom trawling fleets, by contrast, continue to fish in the Mediterranean Sea without any rules. They catch the same species and sell them on the same market — the European one — but at more competitive prices and with greater profit margins for traders. "The weak link in the system is not the fishers, but the traders. Controls have been developed on the production (and therefore the fishing) of prawns, but not on the trade," Fiorentino continues. It is in fact the traders who dictate prices to Sicilian fishers, because they have the ability to import prawns from other countries and place them on the Italian market. The result is that Sicilian fishers bear the brunt of competition, yet at an environmental level the pressure on species does not change, because it is continued by other fishers whose fishing activities are often impossible to trace. "Traders are not bound by the rhythms of nature, whereas fishers know that nature presents the bill. Fishing and common resources must be shared by everyone under shared rules, otherwise the whole system collapses," he concludes.
According to several experts, regulating access to shared marine resources, such as fish populations, is fundamental to ensuring a regular reproductive cycle for the most commercially exploited marine species. In recent years, it has been seen how the fishing communities of several competing countries were unable to reach agreements, as was the case with anchovies and sardines in the Adriatic Sea. These pelagic species were indeed heading towards a collapse situation in 2018, owing to the impossibility of reaching an agreement between Italy, Croatia and Slovenia. In the end it was the General fishery committee for the Mediterranean (Gfcm), a body of the Fao, the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, that called for urgent measures to prevent the disappearance of these fish from the Adriatic Sea. "In the Bay of Biscay, in the Atlantic waters off northern Spain, anchovies came close to collapse in 2006, and fishing was closed completely to any kind of exploitation of these species," explains Nicolas Fournier, director of the NGO Oceana. "An ambitious management plan was needed to allow these species to recover. Today this population is in excellent health." Oceana is also the organisation that collaborated with the European Union and the Gfcm to establish the so-called FRA zones in the Strait of Sicily, restocking areas where fishing is now prohibited so that species such as the red prawn and cod, both of which are overexploited, can repopulate undisturbed without the pressure of competing fishing vessels.
The Mediterranean's emergencies: warming waters
Bottom trawling and the overexploitationof fish stocks are not the only factors disturbing the seabed. Warming waters and pollution from plastics and microplastics are other factors posing a grave threat to the Mediterranean Sea. Last May, some fishers from Mazara del Vallo who were fishing in the deep waters north of the island of Crete recorded a temperature of 15.1 degrees Celsius, when normally the temperature at these depths sits steadily around 13.8 degrees. "An increase of more than one degree at these depths is a truly alarming figure," explains Cnr biologist Fabio Fiorentino. According to the first results gathered by the CAREHeat project (deteCtion and threAts of maRinE Heat waves), funded by the European Space Agency (Esa), in which Enea and Cnr are participating on behalf of Italy, the heatwave that struck the Mediterranean Sea this summer raised the sea temperature by approximately 4 degrees Celsius compared with the 1985–2005 average, with peaks exceeding 23 degrees.
According to the projections of the Ipcc (International panel for climate change), gathered in the 2022 report, the increase in marine heatwaves in the Mediterranean is mounting pressure on marine ecosystems. Warm-water fish will move northwards, cold-water species will gradually decline and other tropical species, as is already happening, will become increasingly present. The change in water temperature will lead to the extinction of fourteen endemic species from the basin, out of a total of 75. Almost all of these at-risk species are species found on the seabed. According to other studies, human activities — port construction, discharges, bottom trawling — combined with global warming, are causing high mortality among the so-called Mediterranean meadows, specifically Posidonia oceanica, an important underwater forest of the Mediterranean, capable of fixing carbon dioxide and providing shelter for dozens of marine species. Over the last half-century, posidonia meadows are estimated to have lost 34 per cent of their surface area.
The fish war in the Mediterranean, a sea growing ever warmer and more polluted
Environment — di Sara Manisera
Unscrupulous traders, unfair competition and stringent regulations are sinking traditional fishers. The future of the Mediterranean is at risk.