11 million disposable face masks a day equal 44 tonnes of waste to be disposed of. Legambiente's appeal to the government and schools. We have gathered the position of the Ministry of Education and the Ministry of the Environment.
Just a few months ago, the idea of talking about or imagining the mass use of personal protective equipment – foremost among them, surgical face masks – seemed impossible. Like something out of a science-fiction film. It was February when the race for masks began in our pharmacies. At first there were very few of them, at exorbitant prices, much like latex gloves and hand sanitiser. Now, however, seven months into this new normality, it is hard to imagine ourselves without them.
Face masks have become part of our daily lives. They are compulsory in public venues such as bars and restaurants, and they are issued to us – and to our children – in workplaces and at school. The problem is that the conversation always revolves around surgical masks, often packaged in plastic wrapping, single-use. And therefore disposable.
Every day, the government provides free of charge 11 million surgical masks to schools. We are the only European country to do so, the Ministry of Education points out to LifeGate. A point in favour of the right to education and health. One less for environmental protection. Indeed, 11 million disposable masks amount to approximately 44 tonnes of waste to be disposed of daily through unsorted waste collection. But how did we arrive at this choice?
In the thick of the emergency and the tension surrounding a safe return to school, the Scientific Technical Committee (Cts) – established by an order of the head of the Civil Protection Department on 3 February and subsequently set up by decree of Emergency Commissioner Angelo Borrelli – recommended in its document on the return to school that students, teachers and administrative, technical and support staff (the so-called Ata personnel) wear surgical masks in school premises. A recommendation which, as we can read in the document "Misure di prevenzione e raccomandazioni per gli studenti delle scuole di ogni ordine e grado per la ripresa dell'anno scolastico 2020-2021", is not mandatory.
In other words: anyone can choose to wear so-called community masks at school – predominantly fabric ones, washable and therefore reusable, and in some cases even deemed equivalent to surgical masks. The fact is that every day schools find themselves with another type of mask available free of charge: the disposable kind, which is then distributed and worn, often without anyone even being aware that other choices are possible – more sustainable ones, with the same level of protection.
A joint effort – between the Ministry of Education, the Ministry of Health and the Cts – to guarantee respect for two fundamental human rights: the right to education and the right to health. The priority at the time, the Ministry of Education goes on to explain, was returning to school on schedule and with maximum safety. And even today, with the emergency still ongoing, the priority remains the same, albeit at a more advanced stage (compared to March) of monitoring the situation. It is precisely in this second phase that the appeal from many environmentalists has emerged: replace the daily supply of 11 million disposable masks with an equal number of certified reusable masks.
The alternatives on the table
"It is a senseless decision to supply schools with such a large number of surgical masks," explains Vanessa Pallucchi, vice-president and head of School and Training at Legambiente, "because, while maintaining the same hygiene standards, there is the option of using washable ones. This is a choice the government should have made from the outset: the mistake lies at the source, when they purchased disposable masks."
The problem also concerns the proper disposal of the latter: in the best of cases, they end up in specific containers. But most of the time, surgical masks are thrown away wherever happens to be convenient. For the environmental protection association, this is an educational factor, closely linked to a culture of prevention: "The mask is fundamental," the vice-president clarifies, "but for us it is far more useful to take students on a journey using reusable masks, teaching them how to wash them correctly. There was no need to use disposable ones, which have an impact on waste." For this reason, she continues, "we recommend to young people a sustainable, healthier lifestyle that makes use of the circular economy. I am sorry to say that we adults are not moving in this direction."
Hence, Legambiente's twofold appeal: one to the government and the other to school principals. "Now that schools have reopened safely and there is greater peace of mind, we hope that community masks will be used more and more, because schools can choose if they want to," concludes Vanessa Pallucchi. "We are urging institutions to carry out a shared critical reflection, in favour of a more sustainable use of personal protective equipment. This also concerns the disposal of old desks, which are not broken but have simply been replaced by desks suited to social distancing. Where will they end up — could they be put back into circulation?" Questions that are still awaiting answers.
The effects of disposable masks on the environment
Towards a more sustainable future, then, starting precisely from reusable masks. Even if for the time being they have not yet been certified for use in schools. "It is not our remit to certify masks," comments Environment Minister Sergio Costa to LifeGate, "but we obviously recommend preferring them over disposable surgical masks. It is clear that schools, having to supply them to students, have identified the most suitable tools. We remind everyone that it is necessary not to let them end up in the environment. We are working with the Ministry of Education to keep a close eye on developments. For now, the important thing was to get started, and to do so with the right equipment."
Community masks could soon become the right equipment too: "Reusable masks," Minister Costa continues, "must be made from multi-layer materials that are neither toxic, nor allergenic, nor flammable; they must of course be certified and must not impede breathing. After each use, they must be washed at 60 degrees with a detergent or in accordance with the manufacturer's instructions. We remind everyone that after handling a used mask, hands must always be washed and sanitised. If these requirements are met, students' health is fully protected and the environment is safeguarded."
An environment that is, for the time being, suffering: "We remind everyone that disposable face masks must always be thrown in general waste, but the figures provided by the National Institute for Environmental Protection and Research (Ispra) show no national emergency in terms of disposing of these supplies," concludes Environment Minister Sergio Costa. "I am more concerned about masks that are dispersed in the environment and end up in the sea. Just these past few days, in Sardinia, in the protected area of Capo Caccia, a face mask was found in the sea that had itself become a receptacle for other waste. We absolutely cannot allow this."
Something can be done. Something that requires no great effort and that has already been put into practice by many Italian companies that have begun producing certified reusable face masks. Wearing them means being able to wash them properly — a choice that is good for the small economy, but above all for the environment. A sustainable choice that depends entirely on us.
Face masks at school. Sustainable choices are possible — you just have to want to make them
Environment — di Camilla Orsini
11 million disposable face masks a day equal 44 tonnes of waste to be disposed of. Legambiente's appeal to the government and schools. We have gathered the position of the Ministry of Education and the Ministry of the Environment.