Up close, nobody is normal. How the “mad” became citizens

Up close, nobody is normal. How the “mad” became citizens

Rights · ·

The Basaglia law changed the way we think about mental health. A journey in and out of Lombardy's former psychiatric hospitals of the past, now reopened to the public.

"Why don't we go to the mutual fund anymore?"
"The mutual fund doesn't exist anymore. There's the National Health Service!"
"And what does that mean?"
"It means we're all equal!"

This is a commonplace exchange that could well have passed from a child's lips just over forty years ago, when health finally became a right defined by law.

Health at the legislative level

There was the Constitution of 1948, which in article 32 states that "the Republic protects health as a fundamental right of the individual and an interest of the community," but there was no law specifying exactly how. That law arrived in December 1978. The hypothetical exchange of remarks above welcomes and allows one word to take root slowly: equality. Law no. 833 of 1978 established the National Health Service, under which everyone is equal when they fall ill. A recognition that carried the power to convey a sense of reassurance: from that point on, the State had a duty to look after the health of every individual.

 tre finestre di un manicomio
"The Republic protects health as a fundamental right of the individual and an interest of the community," article 32 of the Italian Constitution © Hans Eiskonen / Unsplash

From object to subject

That law of late 1978 extended and gave universal solidarity to the measure promulgated a few months earlier, specifically on 13 May: Law no. 180. In that memorable year, thanks to Laws no. 833 and no. 180, Italy was able to give dignity to everyone, including the mentally ill. At the root of the radical paradigm shift in how the "mad" were viewed lay a single concept — revolutionary at the time — explained in a question and an answer in the Rai documentary I giardini di Abele, made in 1968. The journalist Sergio Zavoli asks: "Are you more interested in the patient or the illness?" The psychiatrist Franco Basaglia replies: "Definitely in the patient."

Law 180 — known as the Basaglia law — did precisely this: it gave dignity and rights to those suffering from serious psychiatric disorders. From incurable object, to be locked away in places far from the sight of the normal community, in psychiatric hospitals, to active subject of one's own life with citizens' rights, including the right to care, through which the wounds of the mind can be soothed.

Read also: Che forma può assumere la libertà in carcere: come il lavoro rieduca alla cultura

The most striking result of the law is the abolition of the psychiatric hospital — a total institution that annihilated the individual and turned itself into a non-place, a stockroom for defective beings in the eyes of the healthy community. These were segregating institutions that at times housed thousands of inmates — numbers, not people.

Manicomio ex pini
The most striking result of the Basaglia law is the abolition of the psychiatric hospital © Archivio Olinda Onlus

From invisible psychiatric hospitals to communal spaces

Psychiatric hospitals are at the heart of this story — yesterday as places of exile and confinement for the mad, for the different of every kind; today as places to meet and discover oneself and others up close.

The entrance is flanked by a red-brick perimeter wall about a hundred metres long. Then a gate, today always open. The entrance is crowned by a large sign that frames it in a unique way: Da vicino nessuno è normale — that is what is written above the portal of the former psychiatric hospital Paolo Pini in Milan, the city's asylum.

Stepping through the threshold today, we find Olinda: "A collective project with roots going back to 1994, though it was officially founded in 1996, with the aim of de-institutionalising asylum psychiatry, which in those years was still operating despite Law 180. The starting point," explains Thomas Emmenegger, psychiatrist, founder and president of Olinda, "was to simultaneously reconstruct the biographies of the people living inside the Pini and to convert its closed spaces into open ones. There were many people — some of whom had entered the psychiatric hospital as late as the 1990s — and a great deal of space, but both the relationships and the space were configured as distance: wards, corridors, dormitories, walls."

olinda manicomio
Olinda is a collective project whose aim is to de-institutionalise asylum psychiatry © Olinda onlus

The reality of the Olinda cooperative

Olinda today works alongside the various services of the mental health departments, with the Niguarda Ca' Granda hospital and with the Municipality of Milan, after the Milanese psychiatric hospital closed at the turn of the millennium.

"We started with simple things from everyday life: eating, drinking, treating one another well." It was from these small things that the transformation began — the repurposing of spaces on the basis of the Copernican revolution outlined so many years earlier by Franco Basaglia: the "mad" are no longer the objects of care but become the subjects of their own lives, the inhabitants of the space in which they live. "There was a problem: at the Pini we were always among ourselves. The fears of crossing through the gate of the psychiatric hospital were distributed equally between those on the outside and those on the inside. We risked reproducing the ghetto."

How to overcome prejudices about mental illness

To break down prejudices about mental illness, the citizens of Milan must enter the psychiatric hospital and reclaim that space for themselves. Olinda then tries to give the city an appointment — a genuine reason to come and witness the change. Hence the first public project. "It was a peaceful invasion of almost 20,000 people, ending with a Grand Ball, where the people dancing finally considered that celebration their own celebration: we were no longer alone. From that moment on, our bar Jodok became a bar of the city."

bar jodok manicomio olinda
Bar Jodok has become a bar of the city © Olinda onlus

Olinda also tried to engage with another challenge: creating the services needed to welcome citizens to this place of double exclusion — psychiatric hospital and periphery. The northern periphery of Milan, in the Affori neighbourhood. "Closing the psychiatric hospital meant for us not only rebuilding the biographies of the people who had been committed, but understanding how people with mental health problems could become protagonists in the regeneration of the neighbourhood," explains Thomas Emmenegger.

Nature and culture will save the world. The case of San Martino in Como

The Universal Declaration of Human Rights states that "all human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights." But equals are different, by definition. Diversity of culture, character, tastes, aptitudes and ingenuity are the evident expression of our equality. They are the sign that equality lives within diversity. Mental illness is difficult to conceive of as diversity within equality. It belongs to those words that frighten, because, despite the years and the laws, they force us to revise the most entrenched cognitive and ethical paradigms.

Read also: Il "miracolo" del Refettorio ambrosiano alla Centrale dell'acqua di Milano

"Taking care of people also means taking care of spaces, our spaces. Space understood as a configuration rich in resources that allows one to apply one's own abilities." These are the words of Mauro Fogliaresi, a poet from Como who – as he describes himself – has been in exile for twenty years at the San Martino in Como, the former psychiatric hospital. Within this place of confinement, which closed in 1999 discharging almost four hundred people overnight, Mauro Fogliaresi created a free space. In practice and in name: the Libera università del tempo ritrovato (Free university of rediscovered time). An initiative developed under the aegis of the Sant'Anna mental health department and the day centre dedicated to mental distress, based in some of the spaces of the former psychiatric hospital, but also open to the public, which has now reached its fifth academic year. This year's underlying theme is dedicated to the environment and mental health. "It will be a year devoted to lessons in happiness, but also to the praise of slowness and the pedagogy of the snail. We started in mid-October with lessons on the very therapeutic effect of trees."

lavoratori clarabella agricola onlus manicomio
To truly confront mental illness, we should be able to encounter it outside institutions – and not only psychiatric ones, but outside every institution whose function is to label people and fix them in frozen roles © Clarabella agricola onlus

Beyond the garden

Even before the Libera università project took on the function of a telescope through which to look towards one's own future, Mauro Fogliaresi, together with photographer Gin Angri, sensed that the greatest suffering of people who had left the former asylum seemed to be tied to the difficulty of giving shape to a narrative oriented towards their own life, of defining a story, of recognising a kind of plot in the things they do.

The magazine Oltre il giardino was born in 2008. "It is a periodical without periodicity that comes out when we are well." That is how Fogliaresi defines the magazine. The editorial office is at the end of the central avenue of the former psychiatric hospital, after a steep climb, and meets in the spaces of the San Martino every Wednesday. "Oltre il giardino is a courageous and eccentric magazine, found in a magical place where beauty and creativity reconcile with pain in lightness. The magazine's editors add their own distress to the distress of the users, they free themselves from their burdens and together, lightened, they invent an airy magazine."

To truly confront mental illness, one must encounter it outside institutions

The San Martino in Como, like the Paolo Pini in Milan, is not simply an immense endowment of spaces to be repurposed. The former asylums are signs that become symbols, living documentation of the clinical history of an Italy that was at the forefront in 1978 in declaring that we are all equal, even if it has since taken a very long time to eliminate prejudices and to allow mental illness to be conceived of as difference within equality. The "mad" person remains the other par excellence.

And if what is being done in the former asylums is the epicentre of the cultural revolution, Franco Basaglia believed that "To truly confront mental illness, we should be able to encounter it outside institutions – and not only psychiatric ones, but outside every institution whose function is to label people and fix them in frozen roles."

Clarabella and the desire to restore dignity to people

Enabling and rehabilitating people with mental health problems therefore means giving them credit and investing in their abilities: this has been the challenge that the Brescian social cooperative Clarabella agricola onlus has been taking on since 2002. "Our philosophy has historically been this: to give dignity to the person. And we do so through work, which confers sociality and economic recognition on people with mental distress." This is how Ramona Tocchella, the person responsible for the B&B and for work placement, presents the cooperative's purpose and mission.

Clarabella cooperativa onlus manicomi
Enabling and rehabilitating people with mental health problems means giving them credit and investing in their abilities © Clarabella agricola onlus

The cooperative is part of the cascina Clarabella consortium, which networks several cooperatives that provide space and work for people suffering from mental distress. It is a private body that collaborates with the local socio-health authority, Asst Franciacorta, on care pathways. Clarabella also works in synergy with local institutions both to overcome stereotypes towards people suffering from mental illness – regarded as non-persons destined for social and occupational confinement – and to redevelop disused sites by restoring their productivity. "One example is what we achieved on the slopes of Monte Orfano. We brought a vineyard back to life, as well as an abandoned house belonging to the historian Cesare Cantù. All of this was made possible through collaboration with local institutions." Now, within this building, the cooperative has realised a project that on one side provides light residential accommodation for people supported by Clarabella and also by the mental health department, while on the other side, it is home to people in difficulty identified through local service networks.

Read also: Cos'è la giustizia riparativa, voci e testimonianze dagli istituti di pena

"The Clarabella cooperative – explains Ramona Tocchella – runs a B&B that practises sustainable tourism, which is connected to an agri-restaurant. We also have an educational farm for schools and groups, a wine cellar producing 70,000 bottles a year of organic Franciacorta DOCG from our eleven hectares of vineyards. We produce olive oil through the management of our olive groves and the Sapor d'olio oil mill in Rodengo Saiano, and honey thanks to around twenty hives. Finally, we have created a community kitchen garden with vegetables and aromatic plants." Clarabella recently also opened a shop where it is possible to taste these products: wines including – it could only be called this – the 180, but also the products of all the cooperatives in the consortium, from fish to pasta, from sauces to jams.

Tavola della cooperativa Clarabella onlus
The Clarabella cooperative runs a B&B that practises sustainable tourism, which is connected to an agri-restaurant © Clarabella agricola onlus

"Our workers number twenty-two, eleven of whom have mental fragilities. In addition, there are the various internships we offer, to ease men and women, girls and boys with mental health problems into work. At Clarabella there are no fixed roles; everyone is essential. We do not, however, want people to come to our B&B or buy our products simply because they see something good in the project. We want them to do so because the wines and the food are good and the sustainable tourism experience we offer is intense. And we achieve this by being solidary, in the deepest sense of the word, among ourselves: each person takes on a share of another's work and distress, and everyone has a fluid role. Between the person who is ill and the person who provides care, there are colleagues. People with fragilities work shoulder to shoulder with professionals in the fields of catering, tourism, and food and wine."

This is the strength of Clarabella. This is the care.

Up close, nobody is normal

One can therefore argue that bar Jodok and the Olinda projects within the former asylum Paolo Pini in Milan, the magazine Oltre il giardino and the Libera università del tempo ritrovato at the San Martino in Como, but also Clarabella's work among the vineyards and in the field of sustainable tourism, improve the health conditions of people with mental illness. And they do so because they offer those people the opportunity to aspire. To aspire to being people capable of giving shape to a positive narrative about their own existence. Women and men capable of defining their story, of recognising a plot in the things they do, of crossing boundaries, of changing their everyday lives. Of being differently equal.