M49, the story of the bear fighting for his freedom

M49, the story of the bear fighting for his freedom

Environment · ·

The bear M49, known as Papillon, has escaped for the second time from the wildlife centre where he was being held. For many, he has become a symbol of freedom.

In "Papillon", the 1973 film, Steve McQueen plays the role of a prisoner who attempts an impossible escape from a maximum-security jail. More than 40 years after the film's release, the same nickname has been given to a bear that has escaped twice from the "prison" in which he was being held, sparking a heated debate between those who argue the animal should be left free and those who would even go so far as to have him put down.

M49, the bear hunt

The bear "Papillon" actually has a more technical name: he is identified – and known – by the code M49. His first escape from the wildlife centre at Casteller, in Trento, took place on 15 July 2019. After being captured on 29 April 2020, he escaped a second time on 27 July.

L'orso M49 sui resti di una vacca
M49 was captured because he was considered responsible for the majority of damage caused by carnivores in Trentino © Provincia autonoma di Trento

M49 has been making headlines since June 2019: in the Val Rendena, he was responsible for numerous raids near mountain farms. The bear was spotted and described as a young male specimen, "intelligent and bold", who did not hesitate to smash windows and attempt to break down doors in order to make off with provisions. Being fitted with a radio collar, the forestry service of the autonomous province of Trento recorded 16 attempted break-ins in three months.

Until there was an encounter that came too close for comfort with a shepherd who, to drive him away, fired a rifle. This was the beginning of the bear hunt. The president of the autonomous province of Trento, Maurizio Fugatti, signed the order to capture the animal. The province of Bolzano did the same. The case made front pages and alarmed animal protection organisations to the point of prompting Environment Minister Sergio Costa to publicly warn local authorities against having him put down.

M49's first escape

On 14 July 2019, after evading several traps, M49 was captured and transferred to an electrified enclosure at the wildlife centre in Casteller di Trento, where his radio collar was removed. He would remain there for just under an hour, because in the early hours of the morning the bear escaped from the enclosure, incredibly scaling a 4-metre-high barrier and three electrified fences.

The province was immediately accused of incompetence, and Fugatti signed a new order granting the forestry service the authority to shoot "in case of necessity". The order was opposed by Costa, but nature took its course: the bear, having once again evaded several capture attempts, went into hibernation. It was 7 November 2019, and M49 would show no signs of activity until 2 March 2020, when he carried out a raid on beehives at a farm.

The bear appeared uncatchable and covered kilometres moving from one valley to another. Sightings and reports followed one after another without pause, until, during the night of 29 to 30 April, M49 "fell" into a tube trap and was transported for the second time to the Casteller enclosure.

The second escape

And so we come to the current events. During the night of 27 July, the bear knocked down a section of the fencing and won back his freedom for the second time. But how is it possible, after what happened last year, that Papillon managed once again to outwit the keepers at the centre?

For the second escape, Ispra's technicians were struck by the force the bear used to break down the fencing © Zdeněk Macháček, Unsplash

A first response came from the technicians of Ispra, the environmental protection institute, who were dispatched by Minister Sergio Costa to carry out an inspection of the enclosure. Some speak of possible human assistance, intentional in nature, but the state to which the fencing had been reduced appeared to tell its own story: "This time, some of the metal rods in the fencing mesh – 12 mm in diameter – were wrenched out or bent, and the animal then passed through the gap," wrote the Ispra technicians.

The escape, which took place at night from a section of the structure not covered by cameras, has already had its consequences: the head of the province's agriculture and forestry department, Romano Masè, resigned from his post.

A danger to humans?

M49 is now reported to be, according to tracking data, on the summit of Monte Marzola. The forestry service continues to monitor him via the GPS unit in his collar. The bear is therefore under constant surveillance, to the extent that a public map has even been activated allowing the movements of bears to be followed in real time.

Indeed, "bears" – plural. Because alongside M49 there is another bear specimen, this time female, also being kept under observation. This is JJ4, and she too has achieved a measure of success: recently, the regional administrative court of Trento confirmed that the bear, captured following the injuring of two hikers on 22 June last, would not be put down. The risk of being put down was very real: in 2017, the bear KJ2 had been destroyed following an attack on a man.

+++ Il tar di Trento ha dato ragione al buon senso: sospesa l'ordinanza di abbattimento di JJ4, l'orsa Gaia. Ha vinto la vita! +++

Ho sostenuto dal primo giorno che l'uccisione di un orso non ha senso. #VivaLaVita

The court's ruling is historic because it highlights that the attack could not be attributed "to the problematic behaviour of a single bear", but to a "broader problem of managing coexistence with human beings". A decision that also brought considerable relief to animal protection organisations. "We are absolutely delighted! For now, and until the hearing on the merits (scheduled for 22 October, ed.), no one will be able to touch a hair on JJ4's head – she will be able to continue being a mother, raising her cubs, without the risk of being shot to satisfy political interests that have nothing to do with public safety," declared a number of organisations including Lav, Lipu and Wwf, which had challenged the provincial order.

Will the institutions take the same view should M49 be captured again? "Having him put down, killing him, makes no sense whatsoever," the environment minister reiterated, speaking about the case during the programme Omnibus on La7. Costa added that the president of Trento had in any case "ruled out this intention". The debate therefore centres on the possibility of leaving M49 free.