A slap in the face for M49. Will Papillon the bear remain imprisoned for life?
Environment — di Edgar H. Meyer
The Council of State has rejected the animal rights appeal against the capture and captivity orders for bear M49, also known as Papillon.

The Council of State has rejected the animal rights appeal against the capture and captivity orders for bear M49, also known as Papillon.
Bear M49, better known as Papillon (the nickname given to him by Environment Minister Sergio Costa), will remain behind bars for life.
The very lengthy legal battle has reached its conclusion. The Council of State, to which lawyers from the Lega nazionale difesa del cane had turned seeking the annulment of the TAR ruling that had declared "inadmissible due to supervening lack of interest" and "unfounded on the merits" the appeal brought by various animal rights and environmental associations against the capture and detention orders for the bear, has ruled in favour of the "correct exercise of power by the President of the Province of Trento." This effectively locks the door of M49's cage for good — a bear who, it must be said, has caused some economic damage (stealing a little honey and preying on a few unattended farm animals), but has never posed a danger to humans.
What did the animal rights lawyers argue? That the orders issued by the President of the Province of Trento were tainted by an excess of power, as well as by violation of the principles of efficiency, effectiveness and good administration. To no avail.
The environmental and animal rights associations have not ruled out taking the case to the European Court of Justice, which could have its say on the procedures and reasoning that led to M49's capture. However, this would be a long, difficult and costly path.
Even if the Council of State's decision appears legally correct, this does nothing to diminish the enormous weight of errors committed by the Autonomous Province of Trento in its management of the bears in the region. Over the years, a long chain of omissions and wrongful conduct has led to the current situation: three bears (M49, M57 and DJ3) held in captivity in a facility deemed unsuitable, as noted by the Forestry Carabinieri sent by the ministry.
"If the law were truly equal for all, it would be legitimate to want to see those responsible for the mistreatment inflicted on the bears brought to trial," says Ermanno Giudici, president of Enpa Milan. "Incompetence is perhaps not a crime, although when it concerns the exercise of public functions it could become one. But subjecting the bears to environmental mistreatment violates the provisions of the law." The needs of the bears were known to the administrators before the capture orders were issued, yet this did not prompt them to carry out all the necessary steps to create a suitable facility. The last remaining hope for the bears therefore lies with the Public Prosecutor's Office in Trento, which should already have taken action to put an end to the bears' suffering — but has apparently remained inactive until now.
"Humans come first, along with their interests. Everything else comes after," Gaia animali & ambiente spokesperson Stefano Apuzzo commented bitterly. "Bears, like all other animals, are only allowed to exist as long as they don't cause trouble. Or in cartoons."
The views expressed by the author do not necessarily reflect those of LifeGate.