No Italian city meets air pollution limits, according to Legambiente

No Italian city meets air pollution limits, according to Legambiente

Environment · ·

To date, there is not a single Italian provincial capital where air pollution levels are compatible with the values set by the WHO.

There are three key parameters for measuring air pollution: NO2 (nitrogen dioxide), PM10 and PM2.5 (fine particulate matter). The World Health Organisation (WHO) has set limits for each of them, above which it is legitimate to speak of risks to human health. Of the 102 Italian provincial capitals, not one met all three of these values during 2021. Not one. This is the striking finding that emerges from the latest edition of Mal'aria di città, the report by the environmentalist organisation Legambiente, produced as part of the Clean cities campaign.

Air pollution is a massive problem in Italian cities

The Mal'aria di città study is based on measurements taken during 2021 by 238 monitoring stations located in Italy's 102 provincial capitals.

Fine particulate matter

Almost all of them (230) measured PM10, the coarser atmospheric particulate matter produced by the combustion of car engines (especially older ones) and heating systems, in particular wood-burning stoves and fireplaces. As many as 56 stations in 31 different cities exceeded the legal limit of 50 micrograms per cubic metre (μg/mc) for more than 35 days. Only nine met the new — far stricter — limit set by the WHO, of 15 μg/mc. Record values were recorded in the heart of the Po Valley: in Milan (37 μg/mc), Turin (36) and Catania (35).

Then there is PM2.5, an even finer and even more dangerous form of atmospheric particulate matter because it enters the bloodstream. It can be primary, when emitted by combustion processes, or secondary, when it forms as a result of chemical reactions between other pollutants. Of the 139 monitoring stations that tracked it, one — located at the Santobono hospital in Naples — recorded an annual average of 28 μg/mc, above the legal limit of 25. The WHO limit is considerably lower, at 5 μg/mc. Not a single monitoring station managed to meet it.

Inquinamento
Atmospheric pollution © David McNew/Getty Images

Nitrogen dioxide (NO2)

Finally, nitrogen dioxide, NO2, caused mainly by diesel engines. Of the 205 monitoring stations that tracked it, only 14 remained within the WHO-recommended limit of 10 μg/mc. At the opposite extreme, 13 even exceeded the legal limit of 40 μg/mc; the worst situations were recorded in Naples, Turin, Florence, Milan, Palermo, Catania, Rome and Genoa.

Air pollution must be reduced

To align with WHO recommendations, PM10 levels will need to be cut by an average of 33 per cent, PM2.5 levels by 61 per cent and NO2 levels by 52 per cent. An enormous challenge. But within a few years, Legambiente's scientific director Andrea Minutolo notes, these guidelines will become legally binding. The new European directive on air quality will in fact be calibrated partly in line with the values set by the WHO and will provide for infringement proceedings against non-compliant member states. Infringement proceedings are nothing new for Italy, given that it currently has three active cases.

Legambiente's proposals for breathing clean air again

Legambiente's national president Stefano Ciafani was blunt: "Italy must break free as quickly as possible from the emergency mindset and the culture of excuses that has characterised the last few decades — decades filled with plans, words, promises, often broken, and excuses for not taking decisions, even unpopular ones, to transform our cities and change people's habits."

Among those decisions is the need to redesign urban spaces to make them human-scale, following the model of the "15-minute city" where every neighbourhood is equipped with essential services, expanding "30 zones" and areas closed to cars. This is also necessary to encourage travel on foot, by bicycle or aboard shared electric vehicles, which should be made available even in smaller towns. Still on the mobility front, Legambiente is pushing for the expansion of electric public transport (with 15,000 more buses, 150 kilometres of new tram networks and 500 additional trains), the creation of 5,000 kilometres of cycling routes and cycle lanes, and the adoption of electric vehicles for home deliveries. At the same time, it argues, incentives for the purchase of petrol and diesel cars must be scrapped entirely, with a ban on their sale by 2030.

Ci siamo rotti i polmoni!
Chiediamo al Governo risposte urgenti nella lotta allo #smog, a partire dagli interventi sulla mobilità e l’uso dello spazio pubblico e della strada.

Firma anche tu contro lo #smog in #città
✍️attivati.legambiente.it/malaria

#Mal_Aria #CleanCities

Air pollution, however, is not caused solely by transport, but also by buildings. The various tax incentives — the 110 per cent bonus chief among them — must therefore become an opportunity for a "drastic zero-emission conversion of homes", with the decommissioning of old oil and coal boilers, alongside "a major energy-efficiency programme for public buildings." Finally, agriculture. This is a sector where it is essential to reduce ammonia emissions, regulate the spreading of slurry in winter months and abandon the model of intensive livestock farming.