The history of mayonnaise. From the Balearic ports or from the capital of ham

The history of mayonnaise. From the Balearic ports or from the capital of ham

Food · ·

The origin of a gastronomic speciality now found all over the world, from the most gourmet settings to fast-food restaurants, is the uncertain story of a contested sauce.

A few simple ingredients at the centre of an international affair. A recipe with ancient roots and a myriad of variations across different regions, perhaps born in a Balearic port or, perhaps, in the French capital of ham, on its way to global reach.

Mayonnaise is a cold sauce, among the most famous and appreciated in the world, made from egg yolk, oil and lemon juice, vinegar or mustard, mixed so as to obtain a smooth, thick, creamy emulsion. It is easy – with a little care – to make at home, even though good-quality versions are also produced industrially. It is also a formidable base that can be enriched with a variety of flavours.

Il nome maionese potrebbe provenire dal francese mayonnaise o dal catalano maonesa. Una salsa cremosa e omogenea, emulsione di olio e tuorlo d'uovo aromatizzati con aceto o succo di limone, tollerata anche la senape.
The name mayonnaise may derive from the French mayonnaise or the Catalan maonesa, or perhaps even from Charles of Lorraine, Duke of Mayenne. A smooth, creamy sauce — an emulsion of oil and egg yolk flavoured with vinegar or lemon juice, with mustard also permitted.

Among the best-known variants are the Provençal aïoli, in which it is loaded with plenty of garlic and served with bread and olives; curry mayonnaise; Andalusian mayonnaise with peppers and tomatoes; French green sauce with aromatic herbs; chantilly mayonnaise with added whipped cream; cocktail sauce with tomato sauce and Worcestershire; rémoulade with pickles and capers; and the commercial novelty of adding yoghurt, which reduces the calorie count.

Aïoli sauce, the ancestor of mayonnaise

At the origins of the gentle condiment lies the original aïoli (or allioli, in Catalan), made with garlic, oil and salt pounded in a mortar. A blend of the Provençal alh, garlic, and oli, oil, it is prepared in southern France and north-eastern Spain probably as far back as the Roman occupation. Mayonnaise adds a touch of sharpness, with vinegar, lemon or mustard, plus egg to emulsify the components that would otherwise not bind. Elsewhere, there is a clue dating to the 17th century, in the banquets laid on by Charles of Lorraine, Duke of Mayenne, at the time of the Battle of Arques.

The Spanish version, the Seven Years' War and the conquest of Mahón

During the Seven Years' War, the first war fought beyond their own borders by European powers with colonial possessions (1756–63), the French navy stormed the island of Minorca, wresting from the British the capital Mahón, Maó in Catalan, the easternmost city in Spain. Its port has historically been the gateway for many civilisations, given its strategic position at the heart of the Mediterranean. Here, according to some, the French also appropriated a local recipe — the mahonesa — which may have been promptly renamed mahonnaise. According to others, the sauce was an invention of the cooks accompanying the commander Louis François Armand de Vignerot du Plessis, Duke of Richelieu, or Rolland-Michel Barrin, Count de La Galissonière, to celebrate the victory. Doubt arises because of the fifty years separating this historical episode from the first recorded attestation of the word in French, which dates to 1807.

The French version and the capital of ham

Marie-Antoine Carême, the French cook and writer to whom the codification of the culinary style known as haute cuisine (the most elaborate offshoot of French cooking) is attributed, argues instead in L'Art de la Cuisine Française (5 volumes, 1833–34) that the sauce was born under the name "magnonnaise", from the verb manier, to handle, given the constant stirring that preparation requires for a good result.

According to the historian Prosper Montagné — a version also supported by the Larousse Gastronomique encyclopaedia — "mayonnaise" may be a corruption of moyeunaise, with the missing link of the Old French word "moyeu", meaning egg yolk.

In the early nineteenth century, however, a bayonnaise sauce was also known. This preparation is cited by both Alexandre Viard in Le cuisinier impérial (1808) and Luis Eustache Ude, in 1815. The French gastronome Grimod de la Reynière tackles the dilemma of the name head-on in the Manuel des Amphytrions (1808), a treatise on good table manners: "Purists do not agree on the name of this type of sauce: some say 'mayonnaise', others 'bayonnaise'. The first of these names is not French; the second refers to the city of Bayonne, known for its excellent food. This leads us to opt for 'bayonnaise', as the etymology lies in the name of a place already full of imaginative gourmands and which, in addition, gives birth each year to the finest hams in Europe." In short, history matters little — grandeur is all that counts.

The cardinal points of the geographical map of mayonnaise

If one draws on a map with a compass a circle touching Mahón and Bayonne at opposite ends, the point lands at the centre of the broad cultural region stretching from the Pyrenees to the Atlantic, down towards the Mediterranean. This is the homeland of aïoli. It is a linguistically homogeneous area between Spain and France encompassing, on one side, Catalonia and the Balearic Islands (including Minorca) and, on the other, Provence and Aquitaine (which includes Bayonne), where the Langue d'Oc is spoken, a relative of Catalan. This is certainly the area where it was born.

It arrived in Italy later, noted by Giuseppe Sorbiatti in his Gastronomia moderna of 1855, and it landed in America at the New York delicatessen of Nina and Richard Hellmann in 1910.

Such a simple preparation has been able to enrich itself, in every region into which it spread, with gestures and variations that made it typical of that place (think, in Tuscany, of the use of the powerfully flavoured local extra-virgin olive oil; of the Canadian Thousand Island dressing; of the French tartare sauce), while also standardising itself worldwide to become one of the indispensable accompaniments in fast-food restaurants. A unique case of a symbol of food globalisation that remains regional — one that retains, every time it is prepared and reworked, immensely powerful and inextricable local roots, to the point of always being perceived as a sauce of the place. Where it tastes better, and where it is the original.