Most exploited workers in the textile world are women

Most exploited workers in the textile world are women

Culture & lifestyle · ·

80 per cent of exploited workers in textiles are women, while the sector's chain of command is in men's hands.

The proportion of women among workers in the clothing sector in China stands at 70 per cent, rises to 85 in Bangladesh and reaches 90 per cent in Cambodia. Globally, we can say that approximately 80 per cent of garment workers are women. This disproportion is not the result of chance, but of a very deliberate form of gender discrimination: women are desirable in the clothing industry because employers exploit the cultural stereotypes that female individuals are so often forced to conform to. Women are more docile, flexible, weak and easier to keep in check.

Suppressing a protest is easier when those demonstrating are only women or girls, who often do not even report situations of exploitation for fear of suffering further abuse, frequently of a sexual nature. In Cambodia in the first days of 2014, 3 people were killed and more than 40 injured during the suppression of a series of protests that had begun on 24 December 2013: workers had taken to the streets to demand a rise in the minimum wage to 160 dollars a month. The more women are employed, the lower the risk of that kind of protest.

LAVORATRICI DONNE SFRUTTATE 3
China, Bangladesh and Cambodia are the countries where the percentage of women workers is highest © Allan Wadsworth

Female labour between emancipation and exploitation in developing countries

Historically, the integration of women into paid work has been one of the driving forces behind emancipation and growing gender equality. Social economist Naila Kabeer, in her essay "The Power to Choose", argues that work in the clothing industry allowed women in Bangladesh to gain recognition for their economic contribution to the family, and that female garment workers tend to be more aware of their rights and to have a more critical outlook than other women.

LAVORATRICI DONNE SFRUTTATE 2
Many factories choose to employ women rather than men because they are more easily subjugated © Iqram O Dowla Shawon

If the aspect raised by Kabeer can represent one side of the coin, this transformative potential is certainly undermined by the conditions of exploitation to which female staff are subjected in countries such as Bangladesh. First and foremost, it is important to understand the way in which women have been integrated into the industry: developing countries compete to produce for multinational brands by offering lower costs and faster, more flexible production. In a labour-intensive industry such as clothing, this translates into lower wages, longer hours and poor labour and environmental standards.

The integration of women into garment factories has played a crucial role in this process: factory owners have taken advantage of women's unequal position in society to build an even cheaper, more docile and more flexible workforce. Thus, instead of challenging their subordination in society, work in the clothing industry reproduces it. Women tend to earn far less than men, face systematic discrimination and can access only the lowest-paid jobs, with few prospects for promotion. Many of them have little job security and, if they are unwilling to work under the conditions set by their employers, they risk losing their position.

LAVORATRICI DONNE SFRUTTATE
Women often do not report the terrible working conditions to which they are subjected for fear of retaliation and further abuse © Pham Yen

The organisation Clean Clothes has, for example, collected the testimonies of numerous Indonesian women workers, who report that "Girls in the factory are harassed by male managers who call them into their offices, whisper in their ears, touch them, bribe them with money and threaten them with dismissal if they do not have sex with them." If in general the working conditions of women are disadvantaged the world over, in these countries the situation is even more dramatic, both in terms of pay and of safety. Still according to Clean Clothes, in some garment factories it is standard practice to ask female candidates whether they are married or whether they intend to have children. Some employers hire only single, childless women, while others have every woman sign a document in which she undertakes not to have children during her period of employment. In other cases still, candidates are asked to undergo pregnancy tests during the recruitment process: pregnant women, or those who refuse to take the test, are rejected from the outset. Women who find themselves facing a pregnancy while in employment are in most cases forced to conceal it, at the risk of causing harm to the foetus; the alternative is to receive verbal harassment, higher production quotas, longer working hours and more demanding tasks, such as shifts that require standing rather than sitting.

And in the West?

This disparity and gender inequality do not disappear as one moves up the chain of command in the global fashion industry — quite the contrary. When it comes to leadership positions, women occupy them in fewer than 25 per cent of cases if the most important fashion companies are examined. A study by the Council of Fashion Designers of America, Glamour and McKinsey & Company reworked the concept of the "Glass Ceiling" into "The Glass Runway": only 14 per cent of major brands can boast a woman at the top, and fewer than 50 per cent of the most prestigious maisons are designed by a woman.

Maria Grazia Chiuri
Maria Grazia Chiuri is the creative director of Dior: women who hold leadership positions in the fashion industry account for fewer than 14% © Getty Images

The report highlighted how, over the course of a woman's working life in the fashion sector, a kind of "ambition gap" develops: at the start of their career, 70 per cent of women aspire to become top executives, while only 60 per cent of men do. Ambitions then reverse along the way: those of men continue to grow, reaching 91 per cent up to the vice-president level, while those of women remain at 73 per cent. This mechanism suggests that women's ambitions are not nurtured along the way, or that women themselves become increasingly frustrated and disillusioned in the face of the obstacles they encounter.

Throughout the entire fashion supply chain, men, despite being in the minority, tend to hold better-paid and higher-level positions, for example as general managers. Men in general find themselves doing more skilled work, which is more valued and better paid even when it comes to manual labour, because they often have more opportunities to acquire a wider range of skills than women.