Israel's accusations against Unrwa risk leaving Palestinians without humanitarian aid

Israel's accusations against Unrwa risk leaving Palestinians without humanitarian aid

Rights · ·

Israel has accused twelve Unrwa employees of having links with Hamas. Many countries have suspended funding to the UN agency.

Many countries have suspended their funding to Unrwa, the UN Agency for Palestinian Refugees, after Israeli politicians accused some of its employees of having links with Hamas. Unrwa has around 30,000 employees, has been providing humanitarian assistance to Palestinian refugees since 1949, and in recent months has been playing a crucial role in bringing some form of relief to the inhabitants of the Gaza Strip, besieged by the Israeli offensive.

In recent days, some Israeli political advisers accused twelve employees of Unrwa of having somehow taken part in Hamas's attack against Israel on 7 October. The UN agency has suspended the staff members and launched an internal investigation, but so far Israel — which has long attacked Unrwa's work — has shown no evidence to support its accusations. The United States and other countries have meanwhile decided to suspend their funding to the agency, which bases more than 99 per cent of its resources on such contributions. The humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza thus risks worsening further.

I morti provocati dai bombardamenti israeliani nella Striscia di Gaza
Deaths caused by Israeli bombardments in the Gaza Strip © Mustafa Hassona/Anadolu/Getty Images

What is Unrwa

The United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (Unrwa) was established in 1949, following the Arab-Israeli war of 1948.

That year, around 700,000 Palestinians were forced to leave their homes in present-day Israel, in what is remembered as the nakba. Refugee camps were established, which over the years transformed into more organised spaces, with tents replaced by proper solid structures where, however, the majority of essential services are still lacking to this day. Unrwa has been providing humanitarian support to these people and, as the decades have passed, to their descendants. The services offered cover education, food, employment and effectively everything that Palestinian refugees need in the difficult conditions in which they have been living for decades.

in 1949, the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees (@UNRWA) was established. Since then, UNRWA has provided vital services to over 5.7 million Palestinians. Being present at the field, UNRWA witnessed and documented many of the Israeli Occupation's(+1)

The refugees currently registered with the UN agency number around 5.9 million. Unrwa operates through the work of around 13,000 employees, the majority of whom are the very Palestinian refugees who have received its assistance. The UN agency is in fact one of the main employers in the Gaza Strip, and its staff recruitment and the humanitarian assistance provided to the population depends for 99.4 per cent on public and private international donations. Almost half of its annual budget of one billion euros comes from the European Union and its member states. Another major donor is the United States, which in 2022 contributed 316 million euros.

The accusations against Unrwa

The situation in the Gaza Strip is dire as a result of the heavy Israeli offensive launched on 7 October. More than 26,000 people have died, 85 per cent of the population has been displaced, no hospital is capable of providing emergency services on a large scale, and two in three hospitals are out of action. 90 per cent of the population is in a condition of food insecurity.

The last and only time the US cut Unrwa funding was by former President Donald Trump during his tenure in 2018. Biden's administration then resumed funding in 2021.

The US said on Friday that it suspended funding following Israeli claims that 12 Unrwa staffers took part in 7 Oct

In this dire situation, Unrwa has intensified its humanitarian efforts in the Strip, above all in terms of food, healthcare and shelter. It has done so while also facing severe internal difficulties: since 7 October, Israeli attacks have caused 152 deaths among the UN agency's employees, destroying 145 of its facilities. But operating could now become even more difficult.

Dopo che la Corte internazionale di giustizia ha individuato il rischio di genocidio, le nazioni più ricche nel mondo cancellano i fondi all'UNRWA. Una decisione disgustosa e crudele che punisce la popolazione più vulnerabile del mondo a causa dei presunti crimini di 12 persone.

Senior Israeli advisers have accused twelve Palestinian employees of Unrwa in Gaza of having links with Hamas and of having even played a role in the 7 October attack on Israel, which caused 1,200 deaths. No evidence has so far been provided by the Israeli side to substantiate these accusations; in the meantime, the UN agency has launched an internal investigation and suspended its employees.

The international reaction

Israel's accusations against Unrwa are nothing new — they have been a recurring feature for decades. Current prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu has repeatedly called on the UN to dissolve the agency responsible for Palestinian refugees, accusing it of having ties with Hamas. This is something that is out in the open, for the simple reason that Hamas governs the Gaza Strip and is therefore the only political interlocutor present, through whom it is necessary to go in order to plan humanitarian activities.

In the past, the controversies surrounding Unrwa had led to the suspension of funding. The United States under Donald Trump had done so in 2018, while in 2019 a similar decision had come from Switzerland, Belgium and the Netherlands. On that occasion the accusations concerned mismanagement of funds and abuse of office; the funding was subsequently restored following internal investigations. Now, with the accusation of links to Hamas's 7 October attack, the suspension of funding has taken on a broader scope. The United Kingdom, Australia, Canada, Finland, Germany, the Netherlands and Switzerland have frozen their funding, as has Italy, which stated that its suspension had already been in place since October without clarifying the reasons or circumstances. France said instead that no funds had been allocated to Unrwa for the first half of 2024.

Il Governo italiano ha sospeso finanziamenti @UNRWA dopo l’atroce attacco di Hamas contro Israele del 7 ottobre. Paesi Alleati hanno recentemente preso stessa decisione. Siamo impegnati nell’assistenza umanitaria alla popolazione palestinese, tutelando la sicurezza di Israele.

In the midst of the worst humanitarian catastrophe of recent decades, the one unfolding in the Gaza Strip, the population risks being deprived of the only real humanitarian support present. This on the basis of an accusation still under investigation that concerns 0.09 per cent of Unrwa's employees. And while those same states continue to support Israel, whose offensive is responsible for the 152 deaths among the employees of that very agency. The agency's director, Philippe Lazzarini, said that the suspension of funds amounts to "collective punishment." António Guterres, Secretary-General of the United Nations, has called on the states that suspended aid to reverse course.