Pollution: Italy has violated European Union law, rules the Court of Justice

Pollution: Italy has violated European Union law, rules the Court of Justice

Environment · ·

The EU Court of Justice has ruled against Italy over air quality: fine particle levels have been systematically above the legal limits for 10 years.

The Court of Justice of the European Union has ruled that Italy "has violated European Union law on air quality" by "systematically and persistently" exceeding the limit values set for fine particles. The Court, seised by the European Commission in 2018, "notes that, from 2008 to 2017 inclusive, the daily and annual limit values set for PM10 particles were exceeded very regularly" in a number of areas of Italian territory, and that "Italy manifestly failed to adopt measures in time" to ensure compliance with the limit values.

#ECJ: by having systematically and persistently exceeded the limit values for concentrations of particulate matter PM10 #Italy violated #EUlaw #pollution
curia.europa.eu/jcms/jcms/Jo2_…

According to the Court, the exceedance of the daily and annual limit values set for PM10 "remained systematic and continuous for at least eight years in the affected zones", and only very recently have reduction plans been drawn up, many of which state that the air quality objectives will take several years to achieve — or even two decades after those limit values entered into force.

The measures taken so far by the Ministry of the Environment

Under European regulations, Italy will now have to comply with the ruling without delay: should the Commission consider that the member state has not complied with a ruling of the Court of Justice, it may bring a further action seeking financial penalties. However, the ruling of the European Court did not catch the Italian Ministry of the Environment off guard; the Ministry is keen to point out that the data on which the ruling was based date back to 2017: Minister Sergio Costa explains that "since taking office in 2018, I have deployed every possible instrument, in agreement with the regions, to tackle the issue of air quality."

La Corte di Giustizia Europea ha condannato l’Italia per la cattiva qualità dell’aria, cioè per le polveri sottili, le…

Posted by Sergio Costa on Tuesday, November 10, 2020

Among these, the Minister recalled the agreements signed with Lazio, Umbria, Tuscany and Sicily — and shortly Campania — "precisely to address with operational tools and funding the issues affecting specific areas of these regions"; the Climate Decree of November 2019 "to promote more sustainable lifestyles, such as the purchase of green school buses — 20 million over two years — or urban reforestation, funded with 30 million, and the mobility voucher to encourage electric and sustainable mobility in major cities"; and, finally, programme agreements with the regions most affected by the problem, including the Po Valley basin, Lazio, Umbria, Sicily and Tuscany, which have allocated a multi-year fund of 800 million euros up to 2034 for the reduction of fine particle and nitrogen oxide emissions.

According to Legambiente, the ruling issued today is nonetheless "an inevitable decision, in line with the trend we have been denouncing for years": last January, in the 2020 edition of the Mal'Aria di Città report, the environmental association noted that 28 per cent of Italian cities had exceeded the daily PM10 limits every year over the past decade (10 times out of 10), 9 per cent had done so 9 times out of 10, while 12 per cent had gone beyond the limit 8 times out of 10. Among the cities "in breach" for the total number of days of recorded pollution were Turin, Frosinone, Alessandria, Milan, Vicenza and Asti.