Indonesia loses 2 billion a year in forests

Indonesia loses 2 billion a year in forests

Environment · ·

Human Rights Watch has estimated a loss of two billion dollars by the Indonesian government due to deforestation in 2011.

Indonesia lost two billion dollars in 2011 alone
due to illegal deforestation and poor management of
its forest heritage. The figure was calculated by the American
non-governmental organisation Human Rights Watch
by taking into
account numbers provided by the government and by companies
relating to taxes not collected due to illegal activities
and to international subsidies withheld for failure to comply
with agreements.

The companies taken into consideration are those in the paper
and timber processing sector which, between concession rights
and reforestation taxes, brought Indonesia only 300 million dollars in 2011.

"It is a conservative estimate," said Emily Harwell, lead author
of the report "The dark side of green growth: human rights impacts
of weak governance in Indonesia's forestry sector" published in
July. The calculation that leads to the two billion dollars lost does
not include all the timber sold illegally or the related human
rights abuses that this activity entails.
By way of comparison, this represents an economic loss
greater than the amount the Indonesian government allocates each year
to the national health system (1.4 billion dollars).

The report makes particular reference to the agreement that Indonesia signed in September with
the European Union
, which is intended to help combat illegal
deforestation by requiring labelling on products containing wood so that
their legal origin can be certified. An agreement,
however, that fails to take into account the fact that even
government-authorised deforestation violates the rights of
local communities, and contains no provisions to counter
the corruption that prevails at the time licences are issued. It is no
coincidence that Indonesia ranks 118th
on the list of 176 countries analysed in 2012 by the corruption
index compiled by Transparency International.

A final point concerns the pledge of one billion dollars
made by Norway
to Indonesia in 2010 to combat climate
change through policies aimed at reducing the
rate of deforestation and fighting land degradation. A
pledge that, at this rate, risks not being honoured.