Who is Ilaria Salis, the Italian anti-fascist detained for 10 months in Hungary

Who is Ilaria Salis, the Italian anti-fascist detained for 10 months in Hungary

Rights · ·

Ilaria Salis is accused of having attacked neo-Nazis. While awaiting trial, she has been in prison for 10 months in inhumane detention conditions.

An Italian anti-fascist activist, Ilaria Salis, has been held in a maximum-security prison in Budapest for ten months, and requests for her to serve the period awaiting trial under house arrest have gone unanswered by the Italian government. Ilaria is accused of having attacked neo-Nazis during the Day of Honour demonstration in Budapest, and is being held in inhumane detention conditions, according to several sources.

Ilaria Salis è in carcere a Budapest da un anno. E' accusata di aggressione a due nazisti. Il padre scrive a Meloni. "Il governo intervenga". #ANSA
ansa.it/sito/notizie/c…

Ilaria Salis's rights violated

The Italian government, under the leadership of Giorgia Meloni, has been criticised for its silence regarding requests from Ilaria Salis's family to allow her to serve house arrest in Italy. Salis is being held in a Hungarian prison, where, according to testimony reported by Repubblica, she is subjected to "inhumane" conditions, with rats, cockroaches and bedbugs that have caused allergic reactions. Despite this, medical assistance has reportedly been denied, and shortages are said to include toilet paper, soap, sanitary products and food.

But the rights violations go beyond the prison bars: for six months, Salis was prevented from having any contact with her family, while meetings with her lawyers have been restricted. In court, she was brought in with her hands and feet shackled, raising concerns about the treatment she receives during proceedings.

The request to bring her back to Italy was rejected

Ilaria Salis is accused of having taken part in an assault as a member of the German group Hammerbande, an anti-fascist organisation. However, according to her family, there is no evidence to confirm Salis's involvement in the violence. Furthermore, the family contests the severity of the sentence being sought — up to 16 years in prison — for an offence that in Italy is usually punished with 4 years and that ought to receive mitigating circumstances.

The Hungarian authorities maintain that Salis endangered the life of the victim and committed the offence within a criminal organisation. The young woman's family has repeatedly asked the Hungarian and Italian authorities to bring her back to Italy, but the requests have been rejected. Despite the European Court of Human Rights having condemned Hungary for serious violations of detainees' rights, the Italian government has taken no concrete steps to ensure the wellbeing of Ilaria Salis.

meloni-governo
Giorgia Meloni's government has rejected the request to bring Ilaria Salis to Italy © Alessandra Benedetti – Corbis/Corbis via Getty Images

The Meloni government remains silent

The situation takes on a political dimension given the semi-authoritarian regime in Hungary led by Viktor Orbán. Furthermore, the Italian government denied the extradition to Hungary of Gabriele Marchesi, accused of the same offences as Ilaria Salis, citing rule-of-law violations in Hungary.

Ilaria Salis rejected a plea deal of 11 years, maintaining her innocence and stating that she only took part in peaceful counter-demonstrations. While the Meloni government remains silent, the Salis case raises concerns about human rights guarantees and justice in the context of political tensions between Italy and Hungary.