Fossil fuel producers reject the International Energy Agency's accusations. “Don't point the finger.” Yet in the meantime they invest just 1% in clean energy.
That fossil fuels are the primary cause of pollution and of the production of climate-altering emissions is by now a thesis supported by the entire scientific community. Within this debate, particular significance has been attached to the report Oil and gas industry in net zero transitions by the International Energy Agency (IEA), which has called on oil and gas producers to change their approach: "Oil and gas producers face crucial choices about their role in the global energy system, against a backdrop of a worsening climate crisis fuelled largely by their core products. The sector must adopt a more responsible approach and contribute positively to the new energy economy," the report states.
The response from OPEC, the main oil cartel of Middle Eastern countries, was not long in coming, but seems to come from another planet. "OPEC is not an organisation that prescribes to others what they should do. Pointing the finger is not a constructive approach. It is important to collaborate and act with determination to ensure the reduction of emissions and people's access to the energy products and services they need to live a comfortable life," was the reply of OPEC Secretary General Haitham Al Ghais.
Cop28 in Dubai must represent, according to the IEA, the "moment of truth" for those who continue to produce fossil fuels. Indeed, the agency says, "as the world suffers the impacts of an increasingly severe climate crisis, continuing to do business as usual is neither socially nor environmentally responsible."
Currently, oil and gas companies account for just 1 per cent of clean energy investment globally. Meanwhile, those same companies invest around 800 billion dollars a year in fossil fuel sources — more than double what is required by a pathway to limit temperature rises to 1.5 degrees.
"As things stand, companies with targets to reduce their own emissions account for less than half of global oil and gas production," the IEA continues, while "the production, transport and processing of oil and gas generate almost 15 per cent of global energy-related greenhouse gas emissions — equivalent to all energy-related greenhouse gas emissions from the United States. To align with a 1.5-degree scenario, the sector's emissions must fall by 60 per cent by 2030."
OPEC's reply: "the fossil fuel industry defamed as responsible for the climate crisis"
OPEC's initial reaction: "The way in which the IEA has used its social media platforms in recent days to criticise and lecture the oil and gas industry is to say the least undiplomatic. Furthermore, it is ironic that the IEA, an agency that has repeatedly changed its own narratives and forecasts in recent years, now turns to the oil and gas industry saying this is the moment of truth," responded Haitham Al Ghais, who in turn criticises the agency for having adopted "an extremely narrow view of the challenges we face."
OPEC believes that the IEA's proposals are rather a tool aimed at limiting the sovereign actions and choices of developing oil- and gas-producing countries. For the producers' cartel, unsurprisingly, the emphasis should be placed on reducing emissions, not on the choice of energy sources used. "The IEA," Al Ghais continues, "downplays issues such as energy security, energy access and affordability. Furthermore, it unfairly defames the industry as responsible for the climate crisis." The solution put forward by oil producers thus lies in CO2 capture and storage: "Our sector is embracing renewable energy, with significant investments, and is investing in technologies to reduce emissions, such as direct air capture of CO2, carbon dioxide removal and clean hydrogen. Some OPEC member countries are world leaders in this field."
On CCS — that is, CO2 capture and storage — Al Ghais criticises the IEA's approach, which it considers illusory. But the Agency's data speak clearly: "CO2 capture cannot be used to maintain the status quo. Limiting temperature rises to 1.5 degrees would require the capture and storage of 32 billion tonnes of CO2 by 2050 — a wholly inconceivable amount — of which 23 billion tonnes would need to come from direct air capture. The amount of electricity required to power these technologies would exceed the entire global electricity demand of today."
In short, the message from the agency led by Fatih Birol could not be clearer: "Clean energy progress will continue with or without oil and gas producers. However, the journey to net zero emissions will be more costly and harder to navigate if the sector does not come on board."
On fossil fuels, “Cop28 is the moment of truth” for the IEA, but OPEC disagrees
Energy — di Maurizio Bongioanni
Fossil fuel producers reject the International Energy Agency's accusations. “Don't point the finger.” Yet in the meantime they invest just 1% in clean energy.