How much hydrogen will we use in the future? Little, but it remains a technology worth betting on

How much hydrogen will we use in the future? Little, but it remains a technology worth betting on

Energy · ·

Hydrogen production is as varied as the colours of the rainbow. What are the real prospects for its use in the near future? We asked an expert.

Green, blue, pink, black, grey, brown: hydrogen can take on different colours depending on how it is produced. For this reason we can afford to speak of "rainbow hydrogen", given the "chromatic" variety that this energy carrier — crucial to the decarbonisation of Europe and the entire world — can assume.

CoverEnergia arcobaleno
The cover of the book "Energia arcobaleno" © Il Mulino

Hydrogen is not the solution to every problem

Hydrogen is often described as "flexible" because it can be produced from different energy sources and used in different ways depending on the user's needs. However, the transition to hydrogen requires significant investment in infrastructure and technology: it therefore cannot be seen as a single solution to combat the climate crisis.

Hydrogen as a fuel, an energy carrier and not an energy source in itself, is a molecule abundant in nature but only in combination with other atoms. Its production is as varied as the colours of the rainbow: black, grey and brown if it has a high carbon content, yellow if moderate, blue very low, while green, pink and turquoise are entirely free of CO2 emissions. How do the different production methods affect economic and environmental cost, and therefore applicability? What are the real prospects for hydrogen use in the near and distant future?

We put these questions to Professor Alessandro Lanza, director of the Fondazione Eni Enrico Mattei and lecturer in Energy and environmental policy at Luiss University in Rome, and author of the essay "Energia arcobaleno. Il futuro è dell'idrogeno?", published by Il Mulino.

alessandro-lanza
Professor Alessandro Lanza, author of the book "Energia arcobaleno" © Il Mulino

Professor Lanza, let's start from the beginning: why this book?
I have always followed the debate around hydrogen with great interest, but I have always identified a problem that seemed to me to lack a precise answer: there is a great deal of talk about how we produce it — hence the muddle over its colours — but so much attention to the supply side is not equally balanced on the demand side, namely: what do we actually do with this hydrogen? How do we use it?

And what answer did you find?
Hydrogen is a serious matter: it has applications that are necessary for decarbonisation, but we cannot yet say with precision which will be the main sectors in which it will be used. The transport sector is certainly a strong candidate, even though at present only two vehicles in the world run on hydrogen, compared with 150 different models and millions of electrified cars. So supply is still very limited, and costly — a hydrogen model costs more than 80,000 euros — and Italy's refuelling network can count on just two points, one in Venice and the other in the province of Trento. Electric charging points, by contrast, are springing up like mushrooms. So while it is true that hydrogen can help decarbonise transport, at the moment electric vehicles are winning out.

What about trains, lorries or heavy vehicles?
Trains that use hydrogen are still few in number; they exist and are in operation, certainly, but right now I am speaking from Sardinia, a region where electrified trains are still very scarce. So there are steps that need to be taken before hydrogen is introduced, and here too we are still behind. One sector is heavy goods transport, such as HGVs. But the truth is that hydrogen is placing a great deal of emphasis on hard-to-abate production — that is, those sectors whose emissions are most difficult to cut, such as steelworks: here you need enormous energy in terms of power, today still provided by "dirty" fuels such as coking coal, so this is where hydrogen can truly be useful. To produce it in large quantities, however, we need a great deal of energy: perhaps when nuclear fusion becomes a reality, then yes, we will be able to produce hydrogen in large quantities, cheaply and cleanly, but that future is still very distant.

And we don't have all that time…
Exactly. We need to decarbonise quickly, so in terms of what is useful right now hydrogen still plays a marginal role. I am not saying research in this direction should stop: hydrogen is a good complement but it does not solve all our problems. We are not throwing away the PNRR money, so to speak, because on the contrary it is a good thing to continue investing in this technology. If we do what we have planned to do, it will be more than sufficient to guarantee hydrogen a real future. But to do it cleanly we need renewable energy already installed, and so we must first focus and accelerate on that front. In the meantime we can press ahead with the testing of fuel cells for ships and aircraft.

What is your view on red or purple hydrogen — that is, hydrogen produced from nuclear energy?
It depends on which type of nuclear energy we use. At the moment fusion has no real commercial applications, so fission remains. It makes no sense to build new nuclear power plants to produce hydrogen, because the world is electrifying and electrification brings renewables along with it — which have a storage problem, if anything — so it makes sense to focus on that. Countries that already have nuclear plants, it makes sense for them to use them, yes. More broadly, technology moves fast, so what we are discussing today around hydrogen could change quickly.