Old and new forms of discrimination. Australia's migration policy, with a glance at New Zealand. An interview with long-standing activist Ian Rintoul.
"The Australian model is shocking for the human rights abuses it has caused. No other government should consider following it." Speaking from Sydney is Ian Rintoul, long-standing activist and founder of the Rac (Refugee action coalition). At 66 years of age, some forty of which spent fighting for the rights of refugees, Rintoul can recount the dramatic effects of the migration policies that Italian sovereigntists would like to emulate in the Mediterranean and in Europe.
The so-called Australian model of pushbacks at sea and detention in offshore centres, far from the mainland and in third countries funded by Canberra, is almost twenty years old. And it has already led to humanitarian crises and enormous expenditure by the state. It was inaugurated in 2001 by centre-right prime minister John Howard with the 'Pacific solution'. Since then, thousands of individuals coming mainly from Asia have been locked up on several Pacific islands: Manus Island in Papua New Guinea, the independent republic of Nauru, and the Australian territory of Christmas Island.
Despite fleeing wars, persecution and extreme poverty, they have always been treated as irregular migrants rather than asylum seekers. In 2008 a new centre-left government, led by Kevin Rudd, sought to ease the pushback and detention system, but four years later his Labour party colleague Julia Gillard reintroduced it. In the subsequent back-and-forth between Liberal and Labor, every government has maintained it, including a second Rudd administration and the current executive of conservative Scott Morrison, who was previously minister for Immigration and Border Protection.
Australia and New Zealand, between xenophobic propaganda and racist legacies
"Australian politicians accuse refugees of taking jobs and weighing on welfare, but the truth is that it is not their fault if there is unemployment and a lack of services. Those who govern are responsible," explains Rintoul. If anything, what is disproportionate is the cost of deportation and imprisonment in third countries. Canberra has handed out billions of dollars to the administrations of Papua New Guinea and Nauru. Each prisoner on Manus is said to have cost one million dollars since 2012. A further 55 million was given to Cambodia to receive just six refugees, while negotiations with the Philippines and Kyrgyzstan came to nothing.
Ahead of the Australian elections (18 May) and those of the European Parliament (23–26 May), Ian Rintoul recounts in detail what is happening on the other side of the planet. These are tense days, but also ones of renewed energy. Following the attack of 15 March in Christchurch, in neighbouring New Zealand, carried out by an Australian white supremacist in two mosques, several demonstrations have been organised. Rintoul, together with tens of thousands of other citizens and activists, marched on 24 March in Auckland against racism and took part on 14 April in the Sydney march to close the offshore centres. These camps are contrary to the Geneva Convention on the status of refugees, which provides for the right of asylum for those fleeing conflicts, threats to personal safety, and also situations of extreme poverty.
"The prisoners come from Iran, Afghanistan, Somalia, Sudan, Myanmar, Bangladesh, Pakistan, Iraq, Syria, India, Nepal," continues the Rac spokesperson, who since the Vietnam War has never stopped defending the value of welcome. "They are traumatised and often ill. The #kidsoffnauru campaign, promoted by doctors, NGOs, artists and local intellectuals, managed to secure the release of many children along with their families." Some of them were suffering from severe depression, known as 'resignation syndrome'. Through Rintoul's words, we retrace the process that led one of the world's richest and largest countries to close its doors to the 'boat people' of the globalised era. We examine the similarities and differences between Australia and New Zealand, where the legacies of their respective 'White policies' and colonial pasts survive. We discover new forms of racism, but also a civil society that refuses to give up fighting them.
Ian Rintoul on Manus Island
Since 2012 the Australian model has been reactivated. Can you explain how?
It has in fact been tightened further. In December 2014 the so-called 'Legacy bill' introduced many more restrictive changes. For example, every reference to the Geneva Convention on refugees was removed from the 'Migration act' (the law that has regulated immigration in Australia since 1958, ed.). However, since last February an amendment from the Home Affairs ministry, commonly known as the 'Medevac bill', allows sick refugees to be transferred from Nauru and Manus to Australia. Around 900 people had already been evacuated for medical reasons even before this amendment became law. It is the result of a hugely successful campaign, #kidsoffnauru, which allowed children and their families to leave the two islands in the final months of 2018.
How many people remain imprisoned in the offshore centres?
In total 915, between Nauru and Manus. On the latter there are three detention camps with very limited medical care. On both islands there are mental health crises among individuals who have been there for almost six years.
And what conditions are the 900 transferred to the mainland living in?
Most of them live in what are known as 'community detention' arrangements. They have a roof over their heads, but are subject to restrictions on their freedom. They cannot change address without permission, work, travel or study. Only school-age children have the right to an education. Adults receive an unemployment benefit equivalent to two thirds of that paid to Australian citizens. Others are hospitalised. Still others, more recently, have been locked up in Australian detention centres in Northam, Darwin, Melbourne, and Villawood on the outskirts of Sydney.
At Villawood itself, in the past 4 months, two people have taken their own lives and two others have attempted to do so. These are asylum seekers from war-torn countries such as Iraq and Afghanistan. One detainee said that suicide has become 'normal' there.
Australian detention centres are called 'mental illness factories'. At present around 1,250 individuals are locked up in them, many of them for a long time — from three to six years. It is well known that long-term detention has a severe impact on psychological health. I have visited the detention centres in Darwin, Wickham Point, Curtin, Perth, Yongah Hill, Melbourne, Brisbane and Villawood. I have never been permitted to go to Nauru, but over the past two years I have been to Manus three times, where I also met Behrouz Boochani, the Kurdish-Iranian exile who has been living there for six years and managed to write a memoir about his imprisonment.
The Australian island of Christmas Island resembles our Lampedusa in terms of the boats that have capsized off its shores, the exiles who have drowned and the emergency landings. Will the centre that was closed in 2018 become operational again? The government led by Scott Morrison has reopened it, but no refugees have been sent there so far. In fact, the executive has announced that it will close the centre again from 1 July.
In the May elections the political landscape could change. And migration policy?
The right-wing government will likely be replaced by a centre-left one, but not much would change. Even if Labor cleared out the Nauru and Manus centres, they would never allow refugees to be resettled in Australia. They would send them to third countries. They might accept New Zealand's offer to take 150 refugees. Let's not forget that the Labor party also supports mandatory detention and the use of offshore centres for refugees. I think the ones in Australia and Nauru will remain open.
What became of the bilateral resettlement agreement signed by Obama's United States and Australia in 2016?
Since then the US has accepted 508 people. By the end of this year they are due to take in 1,250, but we don't know whether that will happen under the Trump administration. The American vetting process is rigorous. Refugees with serious health problems are unlikely to be chosen first. We know how their healthcare system works and how limited access to adequate care is. Hundreds of people will be left behind.
The current Italian government, dominated by sovereigntists, would like to adopt the Australian model for migrants. Television and newspapers spread their ideology according to which "the migration issue shifts votes and Italians don't want new migrants". Those who take the Mediterranean route are pushed back into Libyan detention camps. What do you think of this political narrative?
The Australian model is shocking for the human rights abuses it has caused. No other government should consider following it. Amnesty International has described the offshore centres as torture. Australian politicians accuse refugees of taking jobs and burdening the welfare system, but in reality it is not refugees' fault that there is unemployment and that services are lacking. Those who govern are responsible. Turning back boats carrying asylum seekers is a violation of the Geneva Convention, an abuse of human rights and of the right to seek protection. The Convention was negotiated at the end of the Second World War so that refugees would never again be sent back at any border. Australia's migration policies have a damaging effect: they increase racism and xenophobia in society.
In Libyan detention camps African refugees are suffering just as those in Nauru, Manus and the Australian centres are. There are reports of torture, rape, hunger and depression. What is the "resignation syndrome" that has even affected a number of children?
It is an extreme form of psychological distress that develops when people lose hope. They stop responding to external stimuli, stop acting and feeling. They refuse to drink, eat or receive treatment. They remain indifferent even to their own family members. It depends on various factors. The stress of indefinite imprisonment, of course, worsens the physical and psychological condition of those who have already suffered trauma in their countries of origin.
On 15 March last, an Australian white supremacist killed 50 people in two mosques in Christchurch. As a representative of Rac, you demonstrated in Auckland against racism. In what ways are the migration policies of New Zealand and Australia similar?
In New Zealand asylum seekers do not arrive by boat, except in exceptional cases, but by plane. Before being identified they can be held in prison. There are no detention centres, but open facilities where they are housed while their applications are examined. While waiting, asylum seekers can look for work.
Those are the differences. And the points in common?
Both countries rely on a programme of accepting only skilled workers who meet the labour needs of their respective economies. They also take in refugees: 750 a year in New Zealand, 18,500 in Australia.
New Zealand's prime minister, the Labour leader Jacinda Arden, became popular for the headscarf she wore after the attacks on the two mosques. However, in order to govern she formed a coalition with the Greens and the nationalists of NZ First, whose leader Winston Peters is Islamophobic.
During the election campaign Arden promised to tighten the migrant intake programme and went along with a racist anti-Asian campaign in the midst of a housing crisis. A member of her own party accused Asian communities — Chinese communities in particular — of being favoured in access to housing. Moreover, it is true: in order to govern she formed a coalition with the nationalist party New Zealand First, founded by Winston Peters, well known for his pronouncements against Muslims. Peters (a seasoned politician of half-Māori and half-Scottish origin, ed.) is also her deputy prime minister and foreign minister. Furthermore, local reports frequently carry stories of discrimination against foreign workers and students.
Both nations implemented "white policies" from the early twentieth century until the 1970s. White migrants were welcomed and there was talk of a "yellow peril" directed against the Chinese. Do you think these racist legacies still influence the public imagination and politics?
Australia's "white policy" has formally ended, but it has left a legacy. The demonisation of asylum seekers arriving by boat has gone hand in hand with systematic discrimination against Muslims and a rise in Islamophobia. Some mass demonstrations convinced the government to resettle Syrian exiles, but it preferred (in part) Christians because they were "more acceptable" to Australian society. It did not make its selection impartially and on the basis of genuine need.
In Europe, where propaganda against migrants has taken hold in recent times, countering it is an uphill struggle. How have you Australian activists managed to resist it for twenty years, and what have you achieved?
Although government policies have become more punitive, Rac has managed to bring about changes. In 2017 a social and legal campaign enabled asylum seekers to keep a mobile phone in detention centres (Behrouz Boochani wrote the book No friend but the mountains via text messages, ed.). In 2007 Kevin Rudd's first Labor government was elected on the basis of pro-refugee policies. A majority of public opinion had been moved towards openness to exiles arriving by boat. Today almost every civil society organisation — churches, trade unions, associations of doctors and healthcare workers, lawyers, students, NGOs — is publicly opposed to the "Australian model". Last year #kidssoffnauru and a petition signed by no fewer than 7,000 doctors forced Morrison's conservative government to release and bring to Australia all children together with their family members. Teachers in Melbourne and Brisbane went on strike and demonstrated for the closure of the offshore centres. We have not yet achieved permanent resettlement on the mainland for all refugees, but it is a remarkable victory against the government's cruelty.