Electric vehicles are simply the best suited to drive the energy transition

Electric vehicles are simply the best suited to drive the energy transition

Mobility · ·

A new study argues that electric vehicles are less impactful than internal combustion engines, from every perspective and over the long term.

An analysis by Rystad Energy argues that battery electric vehicles (BEVs) are more sustainable than internal combustion engine vehicles, even when taking into account the entire production supply chain and the vehicle's long-term life cycle. Despite higher emissions during the manufacturing process of electric vehicles, owing to the materials used in batteries, the environmental advantage of BEVs over their entire lifespan is unequivocal.

Rystad Energy is an independent energy research company headquartered in Oslo, Norway. Its research shows that electric vehicles contribute at most half the carbon dioxide equivalent (CO2e) of diesel or petrol cars over their life cycle, regardless of the country in which they are used. The study takes into account every stage of the production process and vehicle operation, from the bodywork to the engine (social and humanitarian impacts associated with production are not considered, as the report itself acknowledges).

auto-elettrica-parcheggi
The global market is moving towards electric cars, particularly in China and the US © Dana Kenedy/iStock

Electric vehicles compared in China and the United States

Even in countries where the electricity grid is dominated by fossil fuels, battery-powered cars emit less CO2 than internal combustion engine (ICE) cars. The research sets out a baseline scenario in which vehicles are considered in different contexts. For example, an electric vehicle in China will emit approximately 39 tonnes of CO2e over the next 20 years, compared with almost 85 tonnes for an ICE vehicle. The figure is calculated on an average annual distance travelled of 19,000 kilometres.

The difference in the United States – where the average distance travelled is 23,000 kilometres – is even more pronounced. Here, a BEV emits 42 tonnes of CO2e over its lifetime, 58 per cent less than a petrol or diesel vehicle, which emits more than 100 tonnes.

In 2022, 5 million BEVs were sold in China, compared with 17 million ICE cars. Assuming that each of these BEVs emits 39 tonnes of CO2e over its lifetime and that an ICE vehicle emits 85 tonnes of CO2e, ICE sales would emit 1.4 billion tonnes of CO2e in total, while the BEVs sold would add approximately 200 million tonnes of CO2e to the environment. If the same 5 million Chinese BEVs had instead been ICE vehicles, the additional emissions would have been approximately 430 million tonnes of CO2e. It can therefore be said that BEVs result in a life-cycle emissions reduction of 230 million tonnes of CO2e – almost 14 per cent of total passenger car emissions. A similar analysis in the United States shows this figure to be 25 million tonnes of CO2e.

ciclo-di-vita-veicoli-elettrici
Emissions produced over the life cycle of an electric car by country of origin © Rystad Energy

The energy market is the key

In the case of internal combustion engine vehicles, emissions linked to the extraction, refining and burning of fossil fuels account for approximately 90 per cent of the vehicle's total emissions. Naturally, the breakdown of emissions over the lifetime of a battery-powered vehicle is directly tied to its electricity consumption and the way in which that energy is generated. Assuming electricity production supplied entirely from renewable sources, emissions related to the operation of electric vehicles would fall by 86 per cent compared with ICE vehicles.

A country's energy mix will play a significant role in determining how quickly emissions reductions can be achieved when switching to BEVs. While ICE vehicles become heavier in terms of emissions as they age, BEVs will emit less over the years as energy generation becomes greener. For example, in Rystad's baseline scenario, which accounts for the development of the US electricity grid, battery-powered cars will emit just 14 per cent of the emissions equivalent to those of a petrol or diesel car in 2041.

"Overall, battery electric vehicles clearly represent the right technology for reducing emissions in the transport sector. Switching to a BEV will reduce emissions in the long term despite a greater environmental impact at the beginning of the vehicle's life," said Abhishek Murali, an analyst at Rystad Energy. In short, electric vehicles are the vehicles of the energy transition.