For a green peace: the energy transition as seen by Foreign Affairs

For a green peace: the energy transition as seen by Foreign Affairs

Environment · ·

Sustainable development and the transition have been elevated to strategic issues for global peace and stability. The analysis by Foreign Affairs.

I have often found myself describing – here, for example – the movement fighting the climate crisis as a battering ram, a trailblazer for all those movements that aspire to greater freedom, rights, equality and prosperity. Because the fight against the climate crisis contains within it the spark capable of igniting the desire to build a fairer, more just, safer and above all more liveable world. And it is precisely from this thesis that the reflection in a highly recommended article takes its cue – published in the current issue of Foreign Affairs, the well-known bimonthly geopolitics journal. The analysis is entitled Green Peace, and was written by Meghan O'Sullivan and Jason Bordoff. The subtitle is quite explicit about the argument the authors wish to make: how the fight against climate change can overcome geopolitical tensions. So this is serious business. At last, it is stated in plain terms that the climate crisis is a geopolitical issue that must be addressed in order to resolve the thousand other issues that have today brought the world to an international situation of polycrisis – that is, a crisis involving multiple dimensions and questions. And a permanent one at that.

Green Peace © Zoë van Dijk per Foreign Affairs
Green Peace © Zoë van Dijk per Foreign Affairs

In a polycrisis, more climate action is needed, not less

If until now leaders across half the world have thought it superfluous to talk about the ecological (and therefore energy) transition in a context of war, humanitarian crises of various kinds, insecurity, inflation and job precariousness, it is now time to change perspective. Because all these "crises" should not lead to less climate "ambition". On the contrary, they call for greater engagement. According to O'Sullivan and Bordoff, it is precisely a failure to act that is a contributing cause of the situation we find ourselves in: "A faster transition to clean energy can reinvigorate economies, hold protectionist impulses in check, and calm tensions between superpowers by addressing the deep anxieties that are now driving calls to slow" the transition.

A subversive concept – in the sense that it tends to revolutionise and overturn an existing state of affairs – because it dismantles all the arguments that have so far attempted to protect the status quo, the business as usual policies that were supposed to avoid further shocks on the international relations front. But beyond being subversive, the call for "more transition" is also damnably pragmatic. This is because, as we know, the energy system goes hand in hand with geopolitics, and the efforts to modernise it go well beyond the objective of curbing climate change.

If countries – above all Western ones, whose governments compete to fill their mouths with words like sovereignty, autonomy, protectionism, particularly of their own industrial activities – were truly to understand and embrace the challenge of the transition, they would probably succeed in reducing inequalities within their own populations, the very populations they claim to want to protect from phantom "invasions", by stimulating markets through a greater propensity to export products and reducing dependence on Chinese factories. On the contrary, the pair of authors continues, "failing to combine climate goals with geopolitical ones would mean letting slip an opportunity of historic proportions."

foreign affairs, transizione verde
A wind farm on green hills © Unsplash

Even before the grids, what is needed are smart policies

And it doesn't stop there. Creating "intelligent" energy policies means stopping the imposition of unnecessary and often excessive costs on people – costs that are the result of poor management and that jeopardise the very reliability of the system. Those who today deny this form of development frequently use the spectre of high energy costs to attack the transition, fuelling a form of populism (and fear) that is an end in itself.

Policymakers should treat the clean energy transition as a geopolitical goal, not just a climate goal—and pursue decarbonization in ways that will curb great-power rivalry and reduce global poverty in the long run, write @OSullivanMeghan and @JasonBordoff.
trib.al/5eQdiCc

Because it is precisely through collaboration and a positive, reassuring form of multilateralism that competition can be improved and, above all, that economic, scientific and human objectives beneficial to the entire international community can be achieved. As the article notes, "unfettered globalisation may have reached its limits, but economic integration is still possible." And making energy more accessible and affordable for everyone, especially in the countries of the global south, can help reduce tensions between industrialised countries and the rest of the world.

To achieve green peace, O'Sullivan and Bordoff conclude in Foreign Affairs, we must work towards an energy transition. Only in this way can we prevent or avoid further damage and disasters, but above all give rise to a new vision of the future, built on peace, prosperity and stability.