How major European companies were able to pollute for free

How major European companies were able to pollute for free

Environment · ·

A WWF report explains how the free allocation of CO2 emission allowances has undermined the functioning of the ETS market.

Europe's largest companies, which bear the greatest responsibility for greenhouse gas emissions, have received over the past nine years "rights to pollute" with a total value of nearly 100 billion euros. This is explained in a new WWF report, which highlights how this represents a choice in total contradiction with the principle that those who pollute more should pay more.

How the ETS market for "rights to pollute" works

But let us take a step back: what are these "rights to pollute"? They are the emission allowances distributed within the ETS (Emissions Trading System) market, introduced in 2005 in the European Union. It is a mechanism that sets an overall maximum cap on emissions across European territory, then distributes them among companies, granting them, precisely, free allocations. One allocated allowance corresponds to authorisation to emit one tonne of CO2 equivalent.

Big polluters given almost €100bn in free carbon permits by EU

Free allowances ‘in direct contradiction with the polluter pays principle’, @WWF report says

theguardian.com/environment/20… #ETS

In this way, it was assumed that the most polluting companies would be penalised, as they would be forced to purchase additional emission allowances on the market — allowances sold by the more virtuous ones (which had not used up all their "rights to pollute"). A system that has worked reasonably well (though not perfectly) in the energy sector, but which in the industrial sector (cement, steel, fertilisers, etc.), for example, has had little appreciable effect. More broadly, the ETS mechanism is based on market logic: the price of emission allowances in Europe remained at negligible levels for far too long in past years, drawing widespread criticism of the system's overall effectiveness.

Free allowances worth nearly 100 billion euros distributed

The WWF now explains that the distribution of free allowances was carried out in an ill-considered manner: the 98.5 billion euros in free allocations went to energy-intensive sectors, such as steel, chemical production and aviation, over the period between 2013 and 2021. A figure higher than what the major CO2 emitters — in particular coal and gas power plants — had to spend to acquire additional allowances.

emissioni-co2
The ETS market aims to reward less polluting companies, but its effectiveness is contested © Lukas Schulze/Getty Images

Above all, the organisation explains that the "rights to pollute" were granted without specific conditions from a climate standpoint. It should also be noted that some major "polluters", having too many freely allocated emission allowances at their disposal, were able to sell a portion of them, thereby generating windfall profits worth billions of euros.

"The principle that the polluter doesn't pay has prevailed"

The method of distributing free allowances has, in short, according to WWF, undermined the functioning of the ETS system. The reason why it was decided to grant them was dictated, initially, by the fear that, otherwise, large companies would relocate their production outside the European Union. But according to the organisation, there is no evidence to confirm that this concern was well founded. What is certain, however, is that at least one third of the revenues generated by reselling the allowances was not used for climate change mitigation projects.

In short, a reform of the ETS system is necessary and more urgent than ever. The European Parliament, the Council and the Commission have long been working on the matter, but the proposed dates for phasing out free allowances have been set at 2032 or 2036. Deadlines that are far too distant. In the meantime, according to WWF, it will be the "polluter doesn't pay" principle that continues to prevail.