Why the blue crab is the symbol of the ecological crisis we are living through

Why the blue crab is the symbol of the ecological crisis we are living through

Environment · ·

An invasion that is putting the lagoon ecosystem and fishing activities at risk. Between scant monitoring and calls for human consumption, the real problem is being lost sight of: the loss of biodiversity. An invasion that is putting the lagoon ecosystem and fishing activities at risk. Between scant monitoring and calls for human consumption, the real problem is being lost sight of: the loss of biodiversity.

The fish market in Pila, in the northernmost part of the Po Delta, will not open today. The wind is blowing extremely hard and ruffling the brackish waters of the lagoon. Going out by boat is impossible. No mullet, mussels or clams, then. A few fishermen turn up all the same, however, with crates full of what has already been christened the "scourge of the Po Delta". The blue crab, or Atlantic blue crab (Callinectes sapidus), has in fact invaded these waters, and over the last summer months its population has grown so exponentially that fishermen now catch almost exclusively blue crab.

"There's only them now, even the local crabs have disappeared," says Marco Bergantin, who has just unloaded an entire crate of the formidable crustacean. Until recently he fished for mullet, clams and other fish typical of the area, but no longer. "I've never seen anything like it. It's been present in these waters for about seven or eight years, but now it has exploded. The more we catch, the more their numbers seem to increase."

Femmina granchio blu con uova
A load of blue crab just arrived at the Pila fish market. A female carrying eggs is visible © Rudi Bressa/LifeGate

Bergantin is a member of the Cooperativa Pescatori di Pila, which together with the fishermen of the Polesine area numbers around 1,500 people, with their respective families. And it is precisely here, in the brackish waters of the lagoon, that the crustacean appears to have found the ideal place to grow and thrive. Its presence in the Mediterranean Sea has in fact been known since the 1950s, and in many European coastal countries it has been known and consumed for decades. But here it seems to have found the ideal place to grow at rates now considered unsustainable for the lagoon and its inhabitants — not only for those who make their living from fishing.

The crustacean indeed prefers to live in river estuaries, in sandy and muddy lagoon areas. It tolerates a wide range of temperature and salinity values: it can live at temperatures from 5°C to 35°C and salinity values between 2 and 48 parts per thousand, but can also tolerate hypersaline waters up to values of 117 parts per thousand. A suitable salinity level it has also found in these waters, which host farms of Manila clams (Ruditapes philippinarum) on which it feasts voraciously. "We have reached the point of no return," says Giovanni Franzoso, president of the Cooperativa Pescatori di Pila. "From the end of June to today we have been sending between 40 and 180 quintals a day to be destroyed." Considering that an adult specimen weighs around 300–400 grams, that amounts to over 50,000 specimens per day. Caught solely in an attempt to contain their increase.

With the blue crab, will we have to say goodbye to the Manila clam?

More crabs arrive in the market yard. Many of them are already dead, so they are neither saleable nor edible. This summer the consortium equipped itself to catch and dispose of them, paying local fishermen 1 euro per kilogram. "Nobody thought it would be this invasive," Franzoso continues. "Until recently you could find crabs, eels, prawns. Those that could escape did escape, the rest was preyed upon." But what worries the fishing consortium most is the risk that one of the flagship seafood products could disappear. "We risk a year without clams," explains Luigino Pela, director of the fish market. "In October we'll find out whether we still have any product; otherwise we risk being idle for at least a year." The crabs also prey on the smallest clams, known as "seed clams," which are used for seasonal harvests: it is as if a farmer at the start of the season could no longer find the raw material to sow.

The fishermen's concern was also confirmed by a monitoring exercise carried out by Ispra (Istituto superiore per la protezione e la ricerca ambientale) and Arpav (Agenzia regionale per la prevenzione e protezione ambientale del Veneto) at the end of July: "on the basis of catches observed with the ostreghero — a type of funnel-shaped net used for lagoon fishing — high blue crab density values are evident," the final report reads. "The clam samples collected and analysed furthermore confirm that specimens showing signs of predation by crabs are present in the areas surveyed," corroborating what fishermen reported in recent weeks. "In particular in the Sacca del Canarin, from sampling carried out in the clam fattening beds, high percentages of specimens with open valves were recorded (68–96 per cent), with valves showing clear signs of damage from blue crab predation, with percentages ranging from 41 to 56 per cent." High figures that put the harvest at risk and, according to the fishermen, also the coming Christmas. "We are nonetheless doing good work," explains Franzoso. "We are working to protect the seed clams, even if we won't be able to meet the fishermen's demand. The idea is to start working in winter, while in summer we fight the crab."

Carico di granchio blu
One of the many plastic bins full of blue crab that arrive daily at the Pila fish market © Rudi Bressa/LifeGate

The biology of the blue crab

The blue crab is considered one of the 100 most invasive alien species in the Mediterranean: these are species that have been transported and introduced, voluntarily or otherwise, by humans into areas of the planet that they would not have colonised on their own. It can live for up to four years and is omnivorous and generalist: it feeds on bivalves (mussels, clams, oysters), gastropods, crustaceans, annelids, insects, fish, and even algae. It prefers to live in river estuaries, in sandy and muddy lagoon areas.

Males and females are easily distinguished thanks to marked sexual dimorphism: in males the abdomen is long and slender, in the shape of an inverted "T," while in mature females it is broad and rounded and in immature females it is triangular. The claws in males are blue with red tips, while in females the colouring is orange with purple tips. It is an extremely fertile species; the female can lay between 700,000 and 8 million eggs. Females generally mate only once, after their final moult; males can mate multiple times. But the blue crab also has predators: fish (such as the brown meagre), particularly targeting young individuals, birds, eels, sea turtles, and of course humans.

Alien species cost us 423 billion a year

The Italian case was recently included in the Rapporto di valutazione sulle specie aliene invasive e il loro controllo, published by the Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services (Ipbes), which assessed not only the biological damage caused by exotic species but also the economic damage: the figure stands at over 423 billion dollars per year, more than estimates of the global annual costs of natural disasters. Moreover, it is thought that invasive alien species have played a key role in 60 per cent of global plant and animal extinctions. While many alien species have historically been introduced deliberately for their perceived benefits to people, the report notes that the negative impacts of those that become invasive are enormous for nature and people alike.

"Invasive species illustrate a phenomenon occurring all over the world," explains Ernesto Azzurro, senior researcher at Cnr-Irbim. "There are species that wait years before exploding, others that naturally regress. In this case we cannot expect it to disappear from one year to the next, because that is not what has happened in other countries." Monitoring the population and collecting as much data as possible will therefore be crucial.

"For years we have been monitoring the alien invasion in the Mediterranean. But, as happened with the pandemic, the problem is the gap between scientific research and political decision-makers." In short, the research community had been aware of the problem for some time — so much so that the blue crab features in Ipbes case studies, alongside the yellow crazy ant (Anoplolepis gracilipes), one of the most invasive species in the world, and the Pacific oyster (Magallana gigas), which has altered the Danish coastal habitat over the past century.

granchio blu nel piatto
A pasta dish with blue crab meat harvested from the Scardovari lagoon. Efforts are being made to promote its use in cooking © Piero Cruciatti/Afp via Getty Images

What is to be done, then? Azzurro is fairly clear on the matter: "We can mitigate the phenomenon, even though the problem of alien species is global, and among the current drivers of the biodiversity crisis. It cannot be solved while maintaining the current model of development and trade in goods." Indeed, every new species introduced into the natural environment — whether for economic reasons (the Philippine clams farmed in the delta have displaced the native carpet clam) or through other unintended causes — brings about a profound shift in the natural balance. A balance that, once lost, is impossible to recover.

It is yet another lesson showing how the acceleration of the global economy, the intensification and expansion of changes in land and ocean use, and the constant predation of natural resources can only compromise the health of natural ecosystems — and, in the medium term, our own wellbeing. A race through an obstacle course, blindfolded. "We will have to wait and see," the researcher continues. "Some species regress spontaneously, but for now we have no grounds to say this could happen naturally here. In Tunisia the Red Sea blue crab (Portunus segnis) has become the country's leading fishery resource. The fishermen will probably have to get used to its presence."

Confirmation also comes from the consortium president, as another haul arrives and the refrigerated container fills up quickly: "There is no doubt about it — we will have to adapt."